Created

Last reply

Replies

98

Views

9.2k

Users

54

Likes

581

Frequent Posters

sunshine99 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#31
😕

Originally posted by: Punkin22

What a marvelous thread. I have so enjoyed reading each post with your comments. I have a small question for any or all to answer. If ASR only said to Khushi I know about you relationship with Shyam and stops there then Khushi believes that he is speaking engagement then how with only that part information would she understand the why of forced marriage plus devastation of Arnav's belief of her and Shyam affair? I would appreciate any clarification ladies...Thank you again for great discussion...

Logically she would not.It would be nothing more than a clever move to get us interested in the story and continue with the dragging. There can be the following logical scenarios-

He blurts out the entire truth and she understands the forced marriage & the devastation of Arnav's belief of her & shyam's affair sets in.

He blurts out the entire truth but refuses to believe Khushi's innocence and her devastation of Arnav's belief of her & shyam's affair sets in.

Alternately ASR only tells Khushi he knows about her relationship with Shyam. She assumes that he is talking about the engagement. She says sorry for her actions and goes on to say she tried to set things right... but he might not let her continue and the crux of the matter as usual remains unsaid. So MU starts unraveling but major misconceptions continue... Sounds flimsy but then the MU was also based on a very weak foundation. The suave businessman not investigating the incident further and just going ahead with one side of the story. He forgot what he learnt about Khushi as a person in the last 10 months.😊


ChitraF thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#32
wow.. Awesome thread.. loved to each post with comments..
Punkin22 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: sunshine99

😕

Logically she would not.It would be nothing more than a clever move to get us interested in the story and continue with the dragging. There can be the following logical scenarios-

He blurts out the entire truth and she understands the forced marriage & the devastation of Arnav's belief of her & shyam's affair sets in.

He blurts out the entire truth but refuses to believe Khushi's innocence and her devastation of Arnav's belief of her & shyam's affair sets in.

Alternately ASR only tells Khushi he knows about her relationship with Shyam. She assumes that he is talking about the engagement. She says sorry for her actions and goes on to say she tried to set things right... but he might not let her continue and the crux of the matter as usual remains unsaid. So MU starts unraveling but major misconceptions continue... Sounds flimsy but then the MU was also based on a very weak foundation. The suave businessman not investigating the incident further and just going ahead with one side of the story. He forgot what he learnt about Khushi as a person in the last 10 months.😊

Thank you sunshine for answer. I understand better now. The first two scenarios is my first choice not the last. Would like the story to move to next level. Thank you again...
Edited by Punkin22 - 13 years ago
sunshine99 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: momma1128



The trick here is the ASR Khushi fell in love with and the Khushi ASR fell in love with cannot drastically change or else the whole premise of opposites attract is debunked. ASR will change in the way he is willing to believe the worst in people and Khushi will change the way she believes in people only being good. I also think ASR will have to grovel, not at the feet of Khushi, but eventually at her mother's feet - Devi Maiyya. I think that is the change coming.


Fair enough but another change needs to be their in Arnav's thought process-each and every relationship in life needs to be nurtured and you cannot be oblivious to the need of one for the other. He has to let go of his cocooning of Anjali. He has to let her mature emotionally then only he is free of his bondage. If not then what stops him from sacrificing khushi or someone else for that matter when faced with another crisis of this magnitude.
Besides understanding goodness and evil do coexist she needs maturity in her thought process. Her character still lacks the desired depth in comparison to ASR.
Edited by sunshine99 - 13 years ago
Rita.C thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#35
👏👏👏

@TM, well said. totally agree with you. I have no idea why the CV s have stopped showing any scenes of introspection for Arnav and no scenes of discussion for Khushi, which was the best part of the series. Both of them separately thinking about each other, about their relationship, about their transactions and rejoicing or in torture. Those were to my mind the best part of the serial.

And during the redemption track, that is exactly what we need more of. I hope to goodness the CV s do that.

Can you post this post on FB on their page please? I have no idea if anyone reads it but it would be good if they did.

Fair enough but another change needs to be their in Arnav's thought process-each and every relationship in life needs to be nurtured and you cannot be oblivious to the need of one for the other. He has to let go of his cocooning of Anjali. He has to let her mature emotionally then only he is free of his bondage. If not then what stops him from sacrificing khushi or someone else for that matter when faced with another crisis of this magnitude.
Besides goodness and evil do coexist she needs maturity in her thought process. Her character still lacks the desired depth in comparison to ASR.

@Sunshine, yup. Personally, for me the flawed ASR is interesting. I would actually be quite satisfied to see a Arnav who essentially does not change, still distrusts people but deeply cares about Khushi and Anjali. I know that this leaves the risk as you point out always but for me, that is the great love. the great love is that he may not become a better person overall but includes Khushi in his insider story. Franklly I have no idea how one can show a redeemed kind, good hearted Arnav- changed forever. It will take away that bit from his character won't it?

interested to hear how that would work.

great discussion btw. After a long time, I found some really interesting conversation on the forum:)

Edited by Rita.C - 13 years ago
sunshine99 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: Punkin22

Thank you sunshine for answer. I understand better now. The first two scenarios is my first choice not the last. Would like the story to move to next level. Thank you again...

mine too... but then cv's might have something more interesting up their sleeves. It is quite late in the night in my part of the world. So good night / good morning wherever you are.

sunaina02 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 13 years ago
#37
Anu- Nice predictions - and hope Cvs are will be sensible to have a sensible redemption track .
If you ask me - I ust do not want the redemption track to carry on forever . The intenisty of Arnav- Khushi relationship has already been halved, The intensity of Shyams villaneous action also lost. CVs will have to work up a lot to bring back the fire .
I am just afraid they may turn the redemption track also comical .
sunshine99 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: Rita.C

👏👏👏


@TM, well said. totally agree with you. I have no idea why the CV s have stopped showing any scenes of introspection for Arnav and no scenes of discussion for Khushi, which was the best part of the series. Both of them separately thinking about each other, about their relationship, about their transactions and rejoicing or in torture. Those were to my mind the best part of the serial.

And during the redemption track, that is exactly what we need more of. I hope to goodness the CV s do that.

Can you post this post on FB on their page please? I have no idea if anyone reads it but it would be good if they did.

Fair enough but another change needs to be their in Arnav's thought process-each and every relationship in life needs to be nurtured and you cannot be oblivious to the need of one for the other. He has to let go of his cocooning of Anjali. He has to let her mature emotionally then only he is free of his bondage. If not then what stops him from sacrificing khushi or someone else for that matter when faced with another crisis of this magnitude.
Besides goodness and evil do coexist she needs maturity in her thought process. Her character still lacks the desired depth in comparison to ASR.

@Sunshine, yup. Personally, for me the flawed ASR is interesting. I would actually be quite satisfied to see a Arnav who essentially does not change, still distrusts people but deeply cares about Khushi and Anjali. I know that this leaves the risk as you point out always but for me, that is the great love. the great love is that he may not become a better person overall but includes Khushi in his insider story. Franklly I have no idea how one can show a redeemed kind, good hearted Arnav- changed forever. It will take away that bit from his character won't it?

interested to hear how that would work.

great discussion btw. After a long time, I found some really interesting conversation on the forum:)

Life shattering experiences change people drastically. The change always need not be on the brighter side it can have the opposite effect too. You are never the same again you can never be.Life's lesson from experience 😊. But life's lesson are not for fiction.

If Iss pyar ko kya naam do were a book what you say would make an interesting love story where forgiveness from your love only is acceptable. That would not work for a televised series in India. Redemption has to go the complete distance in all aspects. So redemption in reality, readable fiction and television are three parallel roads. Will they meet ? still on the search mode.
Edited by sunshine99 - 13 years ago
WittyKitty thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#39
I for one am sick of a whole lot of people suffering because of one gosh-I-am-so p-delicate-I-live-in-my-own-universe Anjali! I hate how she walks around in her dream world!

Honey,hasn't anyone told you life isn't easy and escaping into Poojali-ness isn't going to make it less easy! No wonder the man strays! Who can live with an escapist all the time?

I want Anjali to do the suffering ! Poor Khushi, stuck with a name that mean happiness but never given any! Why should she have to suffer always?
gheeshakkar thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#40
Great post!

What I don't want to EVER see is them redeeming Shyaam. I have been watching some of the early episodes and have this tiny fear that the CVs might attempt that. That will be the worst and if that day comes, we should all burn down Star Plus.

But seriously, another interesting thing here is how will the Arnav-Khushi separation play out in terms of Anjali and Payal, the ones who an important part of the wheel. Sooo many lives are going to be messed, I hope we get some great drama. *fingers crossed*

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".