ASR only had one choice? Really? - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

117

Views

10.4k

Users

74

Likes

689

Frequent Posters

sbk2 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: Doc_Manaal

Really beautifully written with so much LOGIC which is surprisingly lacking in most of the posts in his forum..Loved ur post.. so precise and to the point..



Same here dear.. I just hate physical abuse no matter what by parents or who-ever and the Garima woman never before acted like a proper mother to Khushi..
And what SICKENS me most that some members are even THANKING Garima for the act..


Thank you! 😃

This morning I logged in and came across posts appreciating and literally commemorating Garima's slap on Khushi. Her anger and shock as a mother is justified, but slapping her daughter in front of everyone, that too her in-laws! - was jarring to me. Especially knowing how Khushi's nature is...she is not a wayward child...heck, she is not a child to be treated like that.
That scene was shot that way to create a dramatic impact...typical of Indian soaps.
It completely put me off.

Khushi is in for more anguish and distress...we should brace ourselves!
I only hope that on Monday they show someone stepping in and rescuing her from the firing squad!
Edited by sbk2 - 13 years ago
showstruck thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#52
ASR is wrong today...no double. But one differnce between shyam and ASR is shyam has no regret for his actions but ASR does. We didn't it see it today but saw it before.
But again today ASR was WRONG.
anitamalik thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#53
Oh btw, I totally didn't disagree with your post. I agreed with a lot of it..It was a very intelligent post no doubt! But like the member above me says,...Shyam would never regret his actions, ASR will..He's back to being ASR, but he's going to regret this when he comes to know the truth- and when he does. He's going to have to redeem himself in Khushi's eyes and his eyes...and also win her trust back after ridiculing her to such an extent.
PSharada thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#54

Originally posted by: misclog2003

Disclaimer :

I am attempting to commit forum suicide with this post. But please read this with an open mind.

I am not writing this to sensationalize anything. I have utmost respect and admirations for BS and SI. They are definitely two of the top 5 actors in Telly Land ' for me. They keep exchanging number 1 rank for me ' in my mind.

My negativity is also not against any post, poster, CVs etc.

Only point I am trying to make is, can't every coin have two sides.

Shyam falsely got engaged to Kushi. There was quite some time before Kushi knew his truth. He never tried to steal a kiss from her, all though he was her fianc (remember except viewers no one knew the truth about him). He never spoke to her harshly. Never called her status, her intelligence or anything to question. Even when confronted by ASR, he says, he doesn't love his wife and is in love with someone else and probably wants divorce from his wife.

I know bear with me, I am sounding like I am defending Shyam. But please read on.

Shyam fell for someone. He also does not believe in marriage and wants to leave his current relationship for Kushi. The reason Shyam is wrong is because he full well knows Kushi absolutely dislikes him and absolutely hates him. That is why what he is doing is wrong.

But let us think from different point of view ' maybe as ASR. You are ASR and for all practical purposes fell in love with Kushi ' when you are supposedly in a relation (call it what ever ' he didn't believe in marriage, so the story suggested, live-in was equivalent to marriage for him) with Lavanya. You knew how much in love Lavanya was with You. You knew how her hopes and dreams were shattered when she realized you were not in love with her, all because, you were falling for another woman with whom you were not in a relation. You did not even know if Kushi would be interested in you. It could be Kushi was in love with someone else. But the correct thing to do was, you were not in love with Lavanya and it was not right for her or to keep her in a relationship with you, irrespective of you getting Kushi or not. The right thing to do. So you broke of the relation, Lavanya understood and exited. Problem solved. Lavanya was shattered. But she moved on.

Now you being ASR think, Shyam is married, but does not believe in his marriage, wants to leave your beloved sister and be with a girl who he claims is his true happiness. You being ASR also think, this girl is in love with Shyam. So for you Shyam and Kushi are in love. Shyam also doesn't believe in his marriage. Just like the logical way you solved problem of You ' Lavanya ' Kushi triangle, what would have been the logical solution of the problem of Shyam ' Anjali ' Kushi.

I know, everyone will say, he did the only thing he can do. Why was torturing Kushi the only thing to do. If he could balck mail couldn't he balckmail Shyam.

He could go and explain Profit and Loss to Shyam. He could tell Shyam, until Di delivers the baby you be nice to her, stay away from Kushi for 6 months. Once the baby is here, Di is strong, I personally will see to it that, Di gives you a divroce and you can happily be with your lover. But if you meet Kushi between now and next 6 months, I will have you killed in an accident and Di will be better off being a widow than a divorcee and I will make sure your precious Kushi also is hurt. No?

He said, he had to do something for his sister. He blackmailed Kushi saying do this for your sister. He is balckmailing someone for his sister. If that person is ready to do what you are blackmailing her for, how is your love for your sister being understood more than Kushi's love for her sister? Marriage was finished. Yet she walked with you outside and got married to you. You stood like a mute when everyone was yelling at you and demanding an answer. That was the only way Kushi could have gotten slapped. If he said, it is none of your businees, Kushi and I have our reasons to get married, we will tell you in due time, no one including Guptas would have dared press him further. No?

What if Kushi said, he blackmailed me into marrying him for his sister's sake, or else he said he will stop Paayals wedding, that is why I married him. What would have happened then. What if she said, this is a fake marriage, now I will see how you will stop Paayal's shaadi, as it already happened. What would have happened then. What if she said, now you will create problem in Paayal's marriage and have Akash divorce her? Is that what you will do, now that I called your bluff and break this contract marrige? What would have happened then?

She did not. She kept quite. Suffering. How come he who can do so much for his sister, not realise there could be more to the story than what he saw and heard. How.

It pains me, because, ASR is arrogant. I like him like that. He talks status and intelligence etc. I like him like that. ASR is ruthless and I for sure like him like that.

But what I cannot like about ASR is acting like a typicla villain who can only prey on utterly impresionable 18 year old females.

Someone even said, Kushi will realize this was a good thing. Please. An 18 year old, who has taken the Guptas burdens on her is being emotionally scarred like this, and people think it is good for her, just because ASR is played by Barun and we all love Barun and we all know ASR deep down loves Kushi, so Kushi will be alright. Just like everyone can understand ASRs pain as he doesn't know the truth of Shyam completely, but no one is ready to accept Kushi's pain and how cruel of a punishment this is for a 18 year old and actually say ASR loves Kushi so it is ok what is happening.

Yes. It is a story. Yes, CVs have every right to tell it like they want. Yes Barun is better than 90% of actors in the country. But let is not forgive and glorify ASR because we understand his pain, but turn a blind eye to Kushis pain.

How can women be so indifferent to a women's pain is beyond me.

Sorry if I ruffled any feathers. If people think, I should keep my opinions to myself or get lost from the forum. So be it. But I had to say this and I did.



Completely agree with you on all the points. The cvs should have atleast shown that ASR defends Khushi's parents and I am still pissed off that he didn't tell the whole truth to Khushi either. He didn't give her a chance to explain her point of view. Does she love Shyam. What was the thing that happened on the terrace. Did he say that Shyam intends to harm/leave his Anjali Di and is now obsessed with Khushi and hence he has no other way to keep his Di and Khushi safe other than marriage. Maybe then Khushi would have readily agreed to this deal and would have atleast walked into the marriage head held high. Let's hope the cvs close this misunderstanding within 1-2 months. Considering how they have un-muted the conversation within a day, and not extend it like other serials, I am hopeful of the misunderstanding getting cleared within a month or 2.
queenie11 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#55

Originally posted by: misclog2003

Just like everyone can understand ASRs pain as he doesn't know the truth of Shyam completely, but no one is ready to accept Kushi's pain and how cruel of a punishment this is for a 18 year old and actually say ASR loves Kushi so it is ok what is happening.

Yes. It is a story. Yes, CVs have every right to tell it like they want. Yes Barun is better than 90% of actors in the country. But let is not forgive and glorify ASR because we understand his pain, but turn a blind eye to Kushis pain.

How can women be so indifferent to a women's pain is beyond me.



Before I started watching the episode today, I was jumping in my seat - oh my god I'm going to watch this episode 5 times on repeat, etc.

But then I started watching, and it almost killed me.

I couldn't tolerate Khushi's pain.

I know in the forum we're always like Khushi speak up come on stand up for yourself, but in today's ep, I could see how an 18 year old girl could be shocked into silence, she is clueless and deeply hurt and traumatized and no one understands or gets her, and the man she was falling in love with betrayed her, and everyone is disappointed in her and she can't do a thing.

I hate, abhor, how she is put into such a situation. I hate how weak she is forced to be. I hate how the circumstances have made her into this character. I hate how she is humiliated and how marriage, in her eyes the most sacred institution, has been turned into an or else contract for her.

I hate how ASR didn't ask Khushi a single question about Shyam or at least explain anything to her, like she doesn't have a right to it or doesn't deserve it. It's obvious that he is deeply hurt, but he's going to have to work a helluva lot to make up for what he just did to Khushi.

(forgive my rant)

SIZZZLER thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#56
A very sensible thought 👏 👏 👏. I agree with your each n every word. I know this is a story... But,V can't imagine a deep pain of KHUSHi,in this situation. She loves her family too much... B'coz,she knows the reality that she is an orphan...so,meaning of the word 'Family' was very big for her... today,she lost her family again...and most important she lost her 'Love' too... without any fault.

Her loss is bigger then ARNAV... B'coz, after 6 month [According to current situation of Character] her life is going to be big mess.

inanyregard thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#57
who needs logic when all you have to do is dangle hints of passion and romance at the audience.

Seriously! who do they think we are?
SNR7 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#58
Ok i totally agree that there could have been a better way for ASR to handle the situation 😡 but what I still don't get is how Kushi didn't question Arnav for why he was doing this in the first place?😲

I mean correct me if I'm wrong but from Kushi's POV - she doesn't know that Arnav knows Shyam's truth right? Her last encounter with ASR so far till this point has been really nice...so in the name of all common sense, would she not question he's sudden change in persona? Couldn't she have asked him out right "What has happened to cause you to behave this way? Why do you want to Marry me? For what purpose? To achieve what?"

Why didn't she? 😕
uniquebluerose thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#59

Originally posted by: misclog2003

He said, he had to do something for his sister. He blackmailed Kushi saying do this for your sister. He is balckmailing someone for his sister. If that person is ready to do what you are blackmailing her for, how is your love for your sister being understood more than Kushi's love for her sister? Marriage was finished. Yet she walked with you outside and got married to you. You stood like a mute when everyone was yelling at you and demanding an answer. That was the only way Kushi could have gotten slapped. If he said, it is none of your businees, Kushi and I have our reasons to get married, we will tell you in due time, no one including Guptas would have dared press him further. No?

What if Kushi said, he blackmailed me into marrying him for his sister's sake, or else he said he will stop Paayals wedding, that is why I married him. What would have happened then. What if she said, this is a fake marriage, now I will see how you will stop Paayal's shaadi, as it already happened. What would have happened then. What if she said, now you will create problem in Paayal's marriage and have Akash divorce her? Is that what you will do, now that I called your bluff and break this contract marrige? What would have happened then?

...

Yes. It is a story. Yes, CVs have every right to tell it like they want. Yes Barun is better than 90% of actors in the country. But let is not forgive and glorify ASR because we understand his pain, but turn a blind eye to Kushis pain.

How can women be so indifferent to a women's pain is beyond me.

Sorry if I ruffled any feathers. If people think, I should keep my opinions to myself or get lost from the forum. So be it. But I had to say this and I did.



I just love you dear!!!!! I simply love you...i made a similar post and thought what you have said from the live in perspective and slimy Sankes's perspective is away beyond me this point of yours regarding sibling love is right!!!!

simple Khushi sacrificed herself for her sister for good life!!!! and Arnav sacrificed Khushi for his sister that too useless life!!!!

As common person who thinks from heart i feel Khushi has been greater sister than Arnav has been!!!
mayad thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#60
Glad you have the intelligence and courage to call this script for what it is! A real insult to not just the audience but to the characters of Arnav and Khushi! It makes no sense based on the character development thus far!

The only thing I can add is that it takes 9 months to carry a baby to full term not 6 months!
So where's the logic? Or is "Di" so naive that for the last 3 months she was not aware she was pregnant! Or is it Arnav who is naive!! Or maybe Lalit Moan did not think we would notice!

For those postings that say the fans cannot write or dictate the story, you are correct and I do not propose to tell the writers, directors and producers how to do their jobs but they are in a profession whereby they can only improve based on the reviews by the critics/fans!

Excellent analysis! I enjoyed the review!

Related Topics

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine · 2 years ago

Walking through the memory lanes of the secretive doors of our remembrance, looking for forgotten benchmarks of our lives, we can find...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: Pixiepixel11 · 4 months ago

Draped in Desire It had started with a challenge. Khushi Kumari Gupta Singh Raizada never backed down from one, especially when it came wrapped...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: Pixiepixel11 · 4 months ago

Title: Unspoken The music had barely begun when their eyes met. Khushi froze, breath catching in her throat. The opening notes of Teri Meri...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: Queen0fDarkness · 8 months ago

The Taser Arnav prided himself on being a man of precision, intellect and control. But sometimes, there comes a moment when even an intelligent...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".