Originally posted by: LordLuminous
Thanks! For the nails bit, why not? Chandni was not allowed to say no. The stakes were high. They had already so many problems. And everyone was insisting, what more could she have done? She had to say yes. Was it cruel? Yes. But isn't Advay just as cruel and manipulative with her? I think Chandni should be allowed to fight back. If Advay gets to destroy her family, he should walk on nails regardless. And I'm not on any team. I try to objective about both characters.
Rant about. Please, I insist. I love a good conversation.
Okay. I got the permission now I probably won't stop😆. About this whole nail thing, I found it inhuman. If it was PP I would object. If it was indrani I would object. That's the way I am and I can't tolerate torture regardless of circumstances.
Coming to chandhni, I hoped being a victim herself she relates to the pain. May be all the anger, sadness and helplessness she was feeling over the past few days...weeks?...boiled over and advay was the one to pay the price. I agree she must be angry at all the things advay is doing to break her family apart but it's not like she has been silently taking it. she always give backs to him. I like that bit but I I never thought she would physically hurt him.
So far advay tried to burn her dupatta but he stopped and she didn't even get a single burn anywhere. He tried to humiliate her to stop the mandir treasure being taken by vishasht family to avenge his family, yet he bought the house and let everyone live in the house. All the weird things he do, they never have a lasting impact. except for the fire bit for PP , that was truly horrific and even though PP was not hurt I am still miffed about it.
Chandhni defamed advay when she posted that video online and as far I know it's still out there and advay is as badnam as chandhni.
Why I am sticking more for advay because he is making more sense. Except for science bit.Advay emotionally tortured chandhni but fact is that she betrayed their friendship is a constant emotional torture to advay. Chandhni also said that advay didn't deserve a family and God did it because advay is not worth it. That's bit haughty from a girl who believes in God but ready to use the treassure for her family when technically all that treasure belong to all people of India. Secondly she is set to marry PP to make her family situation better. I am okay with it. People make choices when they have few options but I can't help but think that why can't any of her sister marry PP? especially megha. She seems ready to marry. Chandhni is eldest true but so far this family doesn't seem to follow any tradition.
Again, chandhni character is inconsistent . Her being with advay and getting romantically involved , and then saying stuff to advay seems like pot calling kettle black. especially after yesterday episode when she says she is still in love with Dev and want him like a hubby. like seriously? I feel like advay and want to say ''really''.
I am siding with advay once again in today''s episode because I am loving the way advay is open in front of chandhni. He never lies. He never gives her false hopes. He hates her and he shows it. This bit is contrast to last season where shlok was much more grey. he lied to aastha that he loved her to trap her in marriage and they were much more physically intimate and he hightened her expectations and then broke all of them on their wedding night. I loved shlok especially since he had his reasons, not good enough but still he had them but I felt too bad for aastha that I think I am still not over it. I loved shlok and aastha in different ways.
But here advay he never made any fake promises. He shows chandhni his true face all the time.He is not grey enough but chandhni's chatacter is bit more grey and there are no conneting dots. I hope her character is given bit more thought. The writer should show clearly what she feels and then connect it with rest of plot. We know dev and advay are same but she doesn't so at this point it would have been better of they kep Dev and chandhni as friends.
All said, I love shivani tomar acting and I don't hate chandhni. but the way writers have written the character it makes it hard to justify it. You may not agree to what I say but those are the feelings I get after I see chandhni. I don't want her character to be changed but I hope she won't hurt people like that.
Edited by Neelum.drashti - 8 years ago
Jhanak
