We can accept anika with her faults why can't we accept shivaay too??? - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

90

Views

6.3k

Users

28

Likes

321

Frequent Posters

StayStrong thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#61

Originally posted by: ..CrazyInLove..

Thanks for penning your thoughts so beautifully. 😃 Being a silent reader on social media platforms, I have always noticed Shivaay being put on trial for every single action, whereas so many justifications are given for Annika's acts. I am quite fond of Annika and do empathize with the stuff she has had to put up with especially with Pinky, but her turn these days to being abla nari is just .

Anyways, since this post is about Shivaay I would like to add my two cents. Shivaay's character has shown so much progression. TBH he is the first bad boy on Indian TV I have fallen in love with. The immense love he feels towards his family and especially his brothers is much like how protective I am of my family and my sister.

Today, he stayed quiet and listened to the charges she was laying on him and his family, offering justifications and trying to analyze the sudden change in Annika and the issue she was truly facing. It wasn't until she started speaking rudely to Dadi and brought in Om's issue did he lose his shit. And why shouldn't he? I would get angry if someone (even if it were my spouse) raised a finger against my sister, then Shivaay's emotional range is 10 times mine so him going ballistic is a given. This man, whose belief system is engrained with NKK's obsession, has been consciously trying to change himself and his beliefs for his love, while his love uses a similar NKK truth, which might forever alter the life of his most beloved brother, just to taunt him? Why isn't he allowed to get upset without someone questioning his love? Didn't Annika also believe his SSO beastliness when he had asked her to get ready for the lodi pooja after the whole Sahil thief incident? I agree it may have been a tad bit easier for her to believe him after his wedding stunt, but still. In this case, Shivaay didn't think of getting her out of his life when she came in between the share transfer to OmRu, in fact he let go of the issue after she came in the room and said sorry. He was mad because this was an issue which he truly thought would alter Om's life negatively.

I did feel so bad for Annika, but my heart just broke for Shivaay today. While Annika's character has changed to satisfy the TRP aunties by becoming a sacrificial lamb, listening to all of Pinky's taunts and crying, Shivaay is truly changing for the better. And I loved one of his dialogues in the forest rangers track in which he says, change is a journey which takes a lifetime. Change is not an overnight process and Shivaay's change has barely scratched the surface. His identity has always been his brothers, his family and his belief in NKK. He has just started letting go of the NKK, and for me at this stage of his progression it is way to early to expect him not to react when a matter influences the lives of his brothers or family. He prides himself for being the great wall of SSO, it's what he has always been and what he always wants to be. And now if he can't even shelter his brothers and family, what of his identity remains?

For all that Shivaay does for his family, I am so glad that he has Annika to do the same for him, to be his great wall. Though, I don't agree with her methods in this case, I do appreciate that he has someone loving him so selflessly like he does his family. Annika's never been in a situation where she has to choose between Sahil or Shivaay, but he is constantly put in situations [all thanks to the darned Pinky] wherein he has to choose between his family or Annika. Therefore, he is always left with the shorter end of the stick wherein one party will always be displeased with his stance.

I just can't deal with all the mutes that were watching the tamasha today. What are they thinking, and how can someone as sensible as Om and Jhanvi possibly think what Annika is doing will be beneficial for Shivaay? And how can they possibly include Tej in the plan and think he would help from the goodness of his heart? Do they not know the jealousy he fosters towards Shivaay? I mean what even 😕 I can only hope Annika becomes the headstrong, self-respecting and smart girl again instead of this self-sacrificing, crying, usual Star Plus bahu.

I didn't realize, I had gone on for so long. Thanks for making this post to give me an opportunity to vent. Coming back to the point, this time it wasn't Shivaay's fault. 😊


You have put the voice of my heart into to words better than me, that's an excellent analysis👏
Larae thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#62

Bang on post. I'm surprised that he is still getting bashed for this track when has zero fault in this. lol his past deeds are being brought up to justify what anika is doing now. Bhai he got bashed a lot (rightly) for it already so there's no point bringing it up again just to defend anika's mahanta.

Anika said all the right things but the timing was wrong..none of it made an impact on me though because she doesn't mean any of it and is only saying it to get thrown out.


No words for jhanvi and omru, instead of trying to stop her, they're actually encouraging her stupidity 😳

Shonasyl thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#63

Originally posted by: -LetItGo-

fatima,enaz,billu ki billi and everyone else my replies to all your comments are due thanks alot for your support!!!

@shona: there was no need to say keep your chamelis it kinda felt rude, I am not offending anyone else or hurting feelings nor I am trying to impose my opinion on you or anyone else and about not discussing her awful timing is one of the main reason why I made this post, though you are requesting me not to mention but it cannot be helped.
Sorry if i sound rude or anything that's not my goal. And about not talking about annika awful timing i just mean that i'm not talking about it not that YOu can't talk about it.
And i'm not trying to justify annika annika's action either.

And about shivaay trusting his family too much, everyone trust their family it is as simple as that and if you say anika is also his family yes ofcourse she is and he trusts her completely, shivaay does not know that his family is keeping secrets from him nor in his worst and wildest dreams he can imagine that he's an illegitimate son of kamini and shakti.

He thinks that his family is perfect and can't do anything wrong. Now he will know that they arenot so perfect and will understand that they can do mistakes too. Again i'm not saying that He deserves it or anything. I just feel like he need to get out of the bubble.

Thanks for stopping by and leaving your comment despite of disagreement.

Thanks to you too.


Mallu


Reply in red.
Edited by shonasyl - 8 years ago
StayStrong thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#64

Originally posted by: Onyx.

Bang on post. I'm surprised that he is still getting bashed for this track when has zero fault in this. lol his past deeds are being brought up to justify what anika is doing now. Bhai he got bashed a lot (rightly) for it already so there's no point bringing it up again just to defend anika's mahanta.

Anika said all the right things but the timing was wrong..none of it made an impact on me though because she doesn't mean any of it and is only saying it to get thrown out.


No words for jhanvi and omru, instead of trying to stop her, they're actually encouraging her stupidity 😳


in bold: true, I am saying this again and again that I am not against what she said but it created no impact because of her awful timing.

and everything you said, absolutely agree😊

Shonasyl thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#65

Originally posted by: EnasZ


@bold : becccause after leaving ... she needs some 1 to look after shivaay after she leaves ... some 1 to make sure that Pinky doesn't hurt shivaay in any way

i agree both are guily ...totally with u on every point ... however, the point of this entire post, people are just trying to justify Annika...saying that they are happy because Annika said the truth IS JUST ANNOYING

i know Annika needed to say that...but not after he redemed himself so much
i notice that even though annika forgave him for many things ... people still want to punish him for it...NOTHING & I MEAN NOTHING JUSTIFIES THE PAIN SHE REFLECTED ON HIM TODAY...HER REASONS ARE 100% UNDERSTOOD...I DON'T EVEN BLAME HER...

BUT WHAT SHE SAID WAS HURTFUL ...VERY UNCALLED FOR CAUSE IT'S TOO LATE TOO TALK ABOUT THE PAST THAT IS BEHIND THEM...& SHIVAAY DIDN'T DESERVE THAT

what annoyes me about this track is this:
1- Annika is given the sympathy that her reason is shivaay while many couldn't relate to his reason being NKK (INCLUDING ME)

2- Annika is given sympathy by telling the truth she bared so long

3- no one is looking at the difference in times...when the wedding happened ...they both were not on speaking terms ... he was angry but was avoiding her & keeping away till the miss happened

but here...they're in love ...they were so close to their FIRST NIGHT ... & yet she squashed his heart out...

everyone (specially for me) felt Annika's pain as she was being hurt without knowing what went wrong (although they were nothing to each other) at the wedding

BUT what should he do now?? can u imagine the kind of shock he received today...a man who never opened up his heart has put it out in front of her and she simply broke it (not her choice) but look at it from his point of view...

if i was him ,
1- i wouldn't be able to pick up those hints ...they're not subtle enough for me to follow ... we all say u will miss me and should i leave all the time ...does that mean that we will?

2- i would think she did all this in revenge...it makes sense ...nothing about Annika's actions made sense to him & that what made him fall for her...WHEN SHE SHOULD HAVE LEFT SHE STAYED BY HIS SIDE ... WHEN SHE SHOULD HAVE TAUNTED HIM SHE FORGAVE HIM,

WHEN HE HURT HER BROTHER SHE NEVER BROUGHT IT UP...& now when everything is ok...SHE'S TALKING MISTAKES,PAST & FORCED MARRIAGE...but thinking of revenge makes perfect sense .

thee puzzle called annika finally is solvable ... that girl stayed in OM, helped the family to gain trust...to win everyone's love ... she wanted to bring SSO to his feet ...she made an ishqbaazi out of him only to break his heart and family (the two most fragile things he has) like he broke her two most valuable things (her self respect and her heart by using sahil)...that makes sense

sorry for the long comment 😆😆...in summary...it's both their faults yes...whoever,no one should try to justify her actions in words like :a he DESERVES IT,it's the TRUTH, or anything...she did wrong...that simple...& she will have to redeem herself (in other words...she's being justified and given excuses so that eventually she doesn't have to redeem anything...while he'll be on his knees crying apologizing for reacting as a HUMAN WOULD when faced with such actions)


@underline i agree no one should justify her action. She is wronG, her timing is totally wrong and we need to accept that their are just human. More than episode Fandom reaction are depressing.


Ps: thanks for yur comment 😊



StayStrong thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#66
@shona: unfortunately, when it comes to shivaay no one treats him as a human.
StayStrong thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#67
@shona on pg8: your welcome:)
Shonasyl thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#68

Originally posted by: -LetItGo-

@shona: unfortunately, when it comes to shivaay no one treats him as a human.


Well it's sad. Maybe people will change their mind after Annika's Fiasco.

Let's hope for the best.
livelytanu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#69
The most sensible post in the forum.
Its so hard to see there has been no amount of sympathy for Shivaay. Suddenly from good pati he turned out to be a bad pati. 😭
That man was in his happiest phase of life when he got the biggest shock of his life.
Leaving Annika, I felt disgusted how his loved ones played with his emotions. Gave in to the game which Annika planted. Imagine your family members hiding truth & playing games with you. . You cannot even imagine.
Maybe whatever Annika said is partly true. But this doesn't change the fact Shivaay is the victim here.
He has no fault in this situation.
And if I start ranting about the pathetic forced separation track, I won't be able to stop. This is the most least thought, badly executed separation track ever. And probably the worst track of IB. Still sticking around for NaRbhi.
StayStrong thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#70

Originally posted by: shonasyl


Well it's sad. Maybe people will change their mind after Annika's Fiasco.

Let's hope for the best.



in bold: but the way things are going it will only get worst so I don't have any hope, its better not to hope at all

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".