Amit and Emon fighting for second positio

r_tvfan thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1

I think it is a known fact by now that Prashant is the unofficial II since he is getting most votes from his region. I don't think it is possible for the other 2 to beat his record unless people spend their entire salaries voting for Amit/Emon.

So Emon and Amit are fighting for the second position. All the judges want Amit to win the title. Even from the voting, it is quite obvious that Amit gets more votes then Emon. So I think this week it is definitely Emon's turn to leave. Personally, I would have liked to see Emon with Amit in the top 2 as then it would be a fight for the Idol. But if Amit and Prashant are in the top 2, it is quite obvious that Amit is a far better singer, infact there is no comparison with Prashant and will be the II for me irrespective of who gets more votes.

Created

Last reply

Replies

28

Views

2.6k

Users

14

Likes

3

Frequent Posters

simple320 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: r_tvfan

I think it is a known fact by now that Prashant is the unofficial II since he is getting most votes from his region. I don't think it is possible for the other 2 to beat his record unless people spend their entire salaries voting for Amit/Emon.

So Emon and Amit are fighting for the second position. All the judges want Amit to win the title. Even from the voting, it is quite obvious that Amit gets more votes then Emon. So I think this week it is definitely Emon's turn to leave. Personally, I would have liked to see Emon with Amit in the top 2 as then it would be a fight for the Idol. But if Amit and Prashant are in the top 2, it is quite obvious that Amit is a far better singer, infact there is no comparison with Prashant and will be the II for me irrespective of who gets more votes.

agree..but i think more than money, we need more ppl, if we can get more ppl to send in their votes than that would even help..i think at this stage, the fans that have been voting for amit since the piano round will prolly tripple their votes but if we can get those who haven't voted for amit yet to vote for him now, that would help a lot too..😊 ...no matter where anyone is from, everyone has an oppurtunity to vote so if yall want amit to win or atleast come to top 2 then now everyone has a chance to make it happen...

elegantjatti thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
Parshant's voice quality is really superb all he need is little training so you can't say amit has no competition with parshant just because he could not affoird to have classical training....he is diamond who need to be polished thats all
tanvi85 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: elegantjatti

Parshant's voice quality is really superb all he need is little training so you can't say amit has no competition with parshant just because he could not affoird to have classical training....he is diamond who need to be polished thats all

no man prashant is not a gud singer its a known fact now even with training he can never be a playbak singer
doctorwordsmith thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: elegantjatti

Parshant's voice quality is really superb all he need is little training so you can't say amit has no competition with parshant just because he could not affoird to have classical training....he is diamond who need to be polished thats all



Well, we're talking about a playback singer here. Why pick someone with potential to become great when there are two other people who already are great?

It's like choosing between an unpolished diamond and two 24 karat diamonds 😆
elegantjatti thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: doctorwordsmith



Well, we're talking about a playback singer here. Why pick someone with potential to become great when there are two other people who already are great?

It's like choosing between an unpolished diamond and two 24 karat diamonds 😆

funny your 24 carat diamonds....lol......dude have you ever seen one ...a 24 carat diamond??? sure!!

Parshant has better voice quality and there is no doubt about this...he has been criticized because he does not have classical traing and as per regard to "Puja, Deepali and Emon" the person who does not have classical training does not deserve the title ...even though the fact is that Parshant is singing this good without training just imagine what will he do with proper training he will become an outstanding singer ......whereas Emon even though he has years of training he still make mistake and moreover he does copy sonu .....yes it may sound harsh to emon fans but Emon unintentionally or intentionally does copy sonu listen to his both performaces of friday ....you an make out a difference between the voice when he sang sonu song and when he sang kishore da song

I do feel for him but getting emotional is not the way out you can't ognore that parshant is singing this good without training.

....as per regard to Amit and Emon....i guess Emon is definitely more over rated as compare to Amit....all the janta here is ready to vote for emon and to save him what about Amit .is he not a great singer.?....Parshant or Amit one of them should win the title

biswita thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7
Most ppl are ignoring that Prashant has better voice quality than Emon, although Emon is a better singer.
Irrespective of whether it is Amit vs Prashant or Amit vs Emon, the true II3 for me is Amit. No doubt about that. I would go as far as to say Amit is the best singers across all current reality show singers.
sabbucha thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8
Vote to either Amit or Emon only. don't vote to both ( votes will divide and difficult to come near to Prashant's votes)
If u want Amit in the final then more vote to Amit only.
If u want Emon in the final then more vote to Emon only.

So, ready for Second Position for either Amit or Emon.

doctorwordsmith thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
sorry, but Emon and Amit are both about a million times better than Prashant. I'd be happy with either of them winning. Prashant did not even deserve to be in the top 5, let alone win the competition.

And btw, you keep commenting on how great Prashant sounds with no training- but Amit said himself that he hasn't been trained either, yet he still is better than Prashant.

Emon can't help it if his voice sounds like Sonu. But he only sounds a lot like Sonu when he sings Sonu's songs.

Emon sure as hell is NOT over rated- have you seen the way the judges treat him? If Prashant or Amit or Ankita goes out of sur, forgets their lyrics, etc, judges will be like, "oh, that's ok, it was still good."

When Emon did any of those things, he was criticized like anything. When he sang well and performed, he was called overconfident. When he sang better and stopped performing, he was told he's not a good performer. When he started singing even better, he was told he sounds too much like Sonu.

Sure doesn't seem over rated to me...
elegantjatti thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: doctorwordsmith

sorry, but Emon and Amit are both about a million times better than Prashant. I'd be happy with either of them winning. Prashant did not even deserve to be in the top 5, let alone win the competition.

And btw, you keep commenting on how great Prashant sounds with no training- but Amit said himself that he hasn't been trained either, yet he still is better than Prashant.

Emon can't help it if his voice sounds like Sonu. But he only sounds a lot like Sonu when he sings Sonu's songs.

Emon sure as hell is NOT over rated- have you seen the way the judges treat him? If Prashant or Amit or Ankita goes out of sur, forgets their lyrics, etc, judges will be like, "oh, that's ok, it was still good."

When Emon did any of those things, he was criticized like anything. When he sang well and performed, he was called overconfident. When he sang better and stopped performing, he was told he's not a good performer. When he started singing even better, he was told he sounds too much like Sonu.

Sure doesn't seem over rated to me...

well dude then vote for him instead of writing here....if you think he does derserve to win the title and not Amit/parshant then vote for emon.

Edited by elegantjatti - 18 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".