Discuss here-JA-Anu tiff in tonights epi - Page 2

Originally posted by: kyph_1fan

i noeee....i wanted to cry...he was being sooo mean!!....dats liek saying he is gud for nothing 😭 😭
i actually supoorted anu ji for a change.....he is rite!!..Emon can b an awsum playback singer and he can perform!😳 👏

I Know.... Me tooooooo i actually Cried...😭

It was completely unfair! Emon has sung like every type of song- hes so
versatile! fine, javed ji has his own opinion bu he should let others talk,
he was creating such as scene. if anu malik wants to say something, he
should be allowed to...its not like his word is the final word. he shouldnt
be soon rude, hes demoralizing emon so much- hes only 18!!!!

Originally posted by: at57

Agreed.. WHat the heck.. I am stull fuming.. The way he said those harsh words to poor Emon.. Who is he ? DOes he really know anything about Sur.. I think its time other judges join forces and start hitting back to his stupid comments. He has objected to other judges' comments umpteen times in a very rude way and here Anu making point in the most polite manner and this silly guy with hugo ego interrupting him. It was like a puke.

Kick that old man out.. Enough of Javed SAAB and Javed JI.. He is a disgrace.

i agree....being a die hard fan of Emon....javed ji totally was a disgrace!

wtz wrong with JA man?...he is totally lost it..total biased judge of all reality shows now 😡

JA didnt do shower for 3 months that y he is speaking out hahahahahahahahahahahahaahha my opinion..

Even through i agree that javed saab had the right to present his and no1 had the right to try to change his mind or give comments on his opionon, he was very rude and had no right to give such statments that emon can never be a playback singer. Thats for god to decide not him. He was acting very baised towards ankita and it was very sad.

Unfair & Rude and Inhuman is my comment about JA !

It seems Javed Akhtar is supporting Ankita solely for gender bias. As someone said to imply a gender bias on the basis of individual preferences is, in my opinion, a bit of a stretch. I mean if I like reading books written by women, more than books written by male, does that mean gender bias? Or if I prefer the color red to white, does that mean I'm color biased? Its stupid, really, we all have our own preferances. And I'm sure most of us voted for Emon/Amit/Prashant more than for Ankita because we liked them, not because we thought "Ok Emon is a guy, that means a vote for him." I don't think any of us solely voted for a contestant just coz he's a guy. And it makes me question his credibility as a judge. Suppose imagine if the top 4 were deepali, puja, ankita and emon? Would he still be championing for ankita to stay in the competition? Or would it be emon?

Also I did not like the way JA conducted himself today, because he does have an opinion, but he does not have to be so demoralizing and pessimistic, when sonu nigam himself praised emon, how can he insult emon on the basis of the fact that he sings like Sonu Nigam when infact yesterday Emon completely proved his criticism wrong with his dil bar mere performance. The problem I had with his opinion infact was, instead of giving points on why ankita should be kept in Indian Idol, he took the opportunity more to INSULT emon on his singing skills. Whereas the other judges basically said "ankita is good at this and this and this, emon is good at that, this comp is based on that, so he's my choice" Javed akhtar was more like "Ankita is amazing at this, emon is bad at everything and he will never be a singer so ankita's my choice" I don't like it when a judge (especially a judge) puts another contestant down just to prove some other contestant as better.

All comments are fixed..

JA, AM, UN and AC have been doing these fake fights since many galas to increase ratings. Poor Emon is on the wrong side of the stick this time but I do thin he will reach the final top 2 alongwith the eventual winner (either Amit or Prashant). Sont Tv knows the trend in voting and this fight is only to generate controversey and more votes for Emon.

I got the feeling that Javed is working with bookies ... he has personal financial interest in supporting Ankita ..behind the serious face is one of the most sly person in form of javedji