Discuss here-JA-Anu tiff in tonights epi - Page 4

BACHEY KI JAAAN LOGEY KYA JA ???

A judge of JA's caliber puts Emon down so badly and then adamnantly dominates AM !! Shame on JA !! JA is not my Idol anymore - Sorry JA !! You owe an apology to Emon .... KDNBKD

After reading all the posts in most of the threads I feel JA needed to be more diplomatic today. I felt sad for EMON today for a 17 year old to hear these comments is demoralizing. Emon does have a thin voice no doubt about that..

JA has years of experience in the field. He has give us his honest opinion. He isn't giving his judgement to please people. Anu Mallik does not have to agree with JA's opinion.

If Emon has to succeed he will no matter what. I remember reading once that
Karan Johar had offered John Abraham one scene in his movie K3G. As Poo's bf who asks her out to the PROM night. John refused the role...Today JA is a big star.

Amitabh Bacchan was considered very UN hero like. The industry thought he was too Tall and Dark. Different from the Dharams, Kumars and Kapoors. Look where he is today...Similarly EMON will shine no matter what if he has too. I hope he takes this up as a challenge and doesn't get discouraged.

God Bless Emon...

Best Wishes to the other three contestants.

Dont even get me started!!

I still cant belive it, omg yoo JA is soo lucky i wasnt there in that room, I would have sent the old man home crying.

Who is he to say Emon wont be successful? he isnt God, he knows nothing about anyones destiny. It's a music directors job to pick singers, not JA's. How dare he? He should be fired after that comment, I mean...can you imagine Emons mental condition, a judge said it right to his face that he cant be successful. I mean, who does he think he is? I cant believe it, how can anyone say that? JA should be ashamed of himself.

I hope his next gala isnt effected by this, I'd be scared to preform infront of JA after this.

This boy will have to sing infront of JA next Friday, he'll have to hope for good comments from him. From the man who declared already that he cant be successful. A judge has the right to comment on his singing, not on his future. JA didnt just attack Emon's singing, he attack Emons hope.

i also cried,if emon is gud 4 nthing,thn y he praised him soooo much 😭 😭
last ngith i was sooo shocked 2 c JA like tht,y soo much discouragement 2 emon,y?? 😭 😡 😭

I think JA forgot to take his BP medication last nite....Just forgive him coz he wasnt thinking straight! 😃

Originally posted by: arkamu

JAVED AKHTAR WAS RIGHT

EMON IS NOT TALENTED
HE SINGS OK OK
HE COPIES SONU WHY TO TAKE HIM WHEN SONU IS ALREADY
HE IS PHYSICALLY DISABLED TOTLA AS WELL
HE HAS NO RESPECT FOR OTHER MAKES FUN OF THEM
HE MISBEHAVED WITH ANKITA TEAMED WITH DEEPALI AND POOJA
HE DIDNT EVEN CONSOLED ANKITA

HE IS SELFISH
JAVED AKHTAR MASHALLAH IS SO OLD AND EXPERIENCED

I THINK EMON SHLD DISAPPEAR HIMSELF SUDDENLY
I WILL REALLY APPRECIATE IT

what do u mean emon's disabled?????? thats probably one of the most meanest and rudest and childish thing ive ever seen on this forum? are you seriously trying to ruin the name of pakistan and disgrace it or what?

Originally posted by: arkamu

JAVED AKHTAR WAS RIGHT

EMON IS NOT TALENTED
HE SINGS OK OK
HE COPIES SONU WHY TO TAKE HIM WHEN SONU IS ALREADY
HE IS PHYSICALLY DISABLED TOTLA AS WELL
HE HAS NO RESPECT FOR OTHER MAKES FUN OF THEM
HE MISBEHAVED WITH ANKITA TEAMED WITH DEEPALI AND POOJA
HE DIDNT EVEN CONSOLED ANKITA

HE IS SELFISH
JAVED AKHTAR MASHALLAH IS SO OLD AND EXPERIENCED

I THINK EMON SHLD DISAPPEAR HIMSELF SUDDENLY
I WILL REALLY APPRECIATE IT

Your post showed your maturity level. Can you tell me how is she physically disabled? I would like to know. And he is totla. How come the judges didn't point this out? His pronunciation sounded perfect in gala 10, so what are u talking about.

Javed Ji is old and experienced, but you forget when people become old they lose their intelligence and enter the second childishness phase. This same Javed Ji you praise said Emon should become the II in gala 1. This same Javed said Emon's voice is unique in the auditions. This same Javed in most galas said Emon toh acha gata hai, ab kya kahein. This same Javed Ji also praised Emon in gala 10 for his second song and said he sung the first song well.And you call him intelligent. A wise man does not contradict himself and change colours like a chameleon contradicting his previous statements.

Amit does not always choose s Kishore Songs thats a wrong allegation. He has sung many singer songs and wonderfully. From In Dino, to Nasha yeh pyar ka Nasha to Jhoomrooo to PehLa Nasha to Yeh Jo Des hai tera.. to many others...

Also just technically correct singers do not make good playback. The we would have had the classical singers into playback, for playback feelings in music, and the voice to suit the actor and situation is more important.

In a way Javed is right, Emon's voice is not matured enough to do playback for say Aamir, SRK, Hrithik, Abhishek etc. He needs more time to mature, but to for JA to say he cant do playback is wrong. He can after he matures.

But Emon WILL SUCCEED. JA is wrong!!!

But, I can visualise Amit as Amir, Hrithik's etc voice. Infact Amit's dreamy voice would suit Hrithik's dreamy eyes...😳😳

JA in his blind support for Ankita lost control i guess.

I hope to see a Emon vs Amit finale. Hope we can get that..But lets see what Janta has in store next week. And how they perform.