under/over rated singerz

what do u think bout the followin:

which of the contestants have been overrated??

i think Ankita, Puja, Emon and Abhishek r gettin a lott ov attention.. they deserve or not.

which of the contestants have been underrated??

Smita, Jolly, Amit nd Prashant r not gettin as much appreciation!!

who are the contestants in the midlevel?

Charu, Chang, Deepali, Parleen

annie~~

overrated: ankita and chang
underrated: abhishek/amit
right level: emon, deepali

overrated------------Abhishek is definitely overrated ,he is good nmimic but as far as his original singing is concerned he is 6/10 or may be with all kindness 7/10 which is good but not excellent same is case with deepali .I DONT THINK she has extraordinary voice or excellent singing she is just dark horse 6/10.

deserved attention is only one EMON.........He desrves all praises.......9/10

underrated is -------------------amit and prshant they both are 8/10 definitely as they are both not trained singers but exceptionally good voice..........judges and people should give them more votes.........

rest all are 5/10 in one or the other category......

overrated: its got to be parleen for sure. Very disappointed with his performance till date

Underrated: Got to be Amit and Prashanth. The 2 of them are really good.

overrated::def chang...the guy is good but not so good

underrated::prashant..he is THE dark horse of indian idol

midlevel::emon, puja

As per singing is concerned,

Over Rated - Parleen
Under Rated - Amit

The rest all are what they deserve

I don't think Abhishek is underrated anymore. Most people feel he's one of the best in II3. He got the praise he deserved yesterday. The extra drama too.

Originally posted by: *payal*

overrated: ankita and chang
underrated: abhishek/amit
right level: emon, deepali

i agree. to over rated, i will add parleen and smita too and to under-rated i hope i dont have to add jolly.. i liked her persformance a lot. to right level, i will add pooja also.

Overrated-Parleen
Underrated-Amit(he's such a good singer but he doesn't get the required attention)

over rated= completely emon
underrated= prashant, amit