Whats Wrong With Judges & Today's View:)

Why Judges were so good ? I mean all three were competing with each other in praising.Except few comments , all comments were too good and lack the real analysis.I mean common give some comments so that people can decide who is good and who is bad or you all wanna belive that all 14 are mind blowing singers and they all are ready for singing ? Then just compare Tinka Tinka from Alisha and Priyanka or for that matter any song . I didn't like most of judges comments.

What was wrong with band ? It was pathetic and it was shows weakest point.Sony needs to take care of these issues

Now contestant's performance I mean from morning I read so many reviews or may be bcoz of all that my expectations were really high.Sorry Amrita and gang but I don't think it was that great. Few singers were good but they lacked real punch .Some singers were in so hurry and they just wanted to finish it of.Remember the song Tere bin nahi jina mar jana from deepali she not even stoped at tere bin word ...listen original song ..

Here are my todays top list ...order may not same but these are the five who were good today

1.Charu
2.Richa
3.Aisha
4.Sifa
5. Puja

People might say I am baised towards Richa but belive me she was good today .Listen again and please don't bring prashant issue while judging.

Anyway guys I know lot of people won't agree with my view but this is our show and we have to write what we really feel after watching and thats why this post.
Have fun and enjoy your weekend ...Lets see how guys perform tommorow
Cheers!

I agree but you should have added Varkita too

You got it bro !!! 👏 Infact, I was also contemplating on opening a post on this topic, but u beat me to that .... 😊 ... Anyways, totally agree with u ... it was all just goody-goody .... only javedji was attempting to be real, but I guess hearing all those goody remarks from other judges, even he couldn't be really constructive .... I really would like to have Sonu back !!!

Originally posted by: gill1

I agree but you should have added Varkita too

yeah she was also good but today may be she was holding mike differently or something ...I guess the song Bhage re man kahi might be wrong for her voice ...I think she might come in top 10 though

Originally posted by: finfreedom

You got it bro !!! 👏 Infact, I was also contemplating on opening a post on this topic, but u beat me to that .... 😊 ... Anyways, totally agree with u ... it was all just goody-goody .... only javedji was attempting to be real, but I guess hearing all those goody remarks from other judges, even he couldn't be really constructive .... I really would like to have Sonu back !!!

thanks man yeah me and my friend were so annoyed with those goody goody comments:) You won't belive but today first time I missed Anu malik even though I dont line him ...Sonu is too good and I think everyone will miss him lot in future episodes too

i knew sonuji was the best judge everrrr 😭

Ok, I said I would be unbiased so here goes...

Richa wasn't the best.
But after listening to the recap, she was much better than some of the other contestants. Compare and contrast. [LOL But definitely not the best. Unlike Javed saab, I do not think she was singing like a tradedy. The original isn't a very peppy, upbeat song either. But yes, she could have bought more 'khushi' into the voice. Besides pleasing the judges, she would have sounded less monotonous.
Sure, she could improve but so can everyone else. No one is perfect. 😆

Charu could have been a little more original with her rendition. But she was the best today. 👏 I like her voice a lot.

Aisha was the most original with her rendition. I think her voice is perfect for folk type of songs though I'm sure she can do justice to peppy songs as well. She did sounded good when singing ek nazar mein bhi in the theater round.

Vartika is slightly overrated. 😳 I did not like her performance that much. Sounded too forced, especially the chorus.

My top five would be the same, though order is different:

1) Charu
2) Puja
3) Shifa (admire her for picking a tough classical number, especially when many of the others were picking wellknown peppy, upbeat songs or item numbers)
4) Aisha
5) Richa

Oh, the judges were a big disappointment.
I really miss Sonu Nigam's judgment now. Unlike Anu Malik, he wasn't too rude but always sensible. His comments & constructive criticism meant the most, both to us viewers and the contestants.

Alisha is the Paula Abdul of II3. 😆

Add Deepali to my top five too.
They've shown her so less that we keep forgetting about her! 😕 😕

Originally posted by: srk_lover

i knew sonuji was the best judge everrrr 😭

Megha Ji Sonu ji was best judge and best singer in India today ...How can we forget his valuable comments 😊