Whats Wrong With Judges & Today's View:) - Page 3

Originally posted by: *payal*

does it matter what the judges say? its not like majority listen to them anyway...based on last years voting pattern 😕

I don't know about voting people but sensible viewer care about Judges comments I guess .

Originally posted by: tpam

i agree , she has tremendous potential .. she will be gr88 someday , bt she was not the best .. her audition is still the best.. and i feel her song selection was not guddd , it didnt suit her

ofcourse her audition was best but we can not compare every round with audiation performance.what was wrong in her perfomance except she was little tensed and not dancing and giving emotions .Have you watched Nihira Joshi in SRGMP ? On name of performance she got voted out and she was the best.For me singing comes first and then everything else...But I too agree her song selection was not that great ...its not that popluar song even though its good song

Originally posted by: tpam

ajay i hav seen nihira 👏 👏 👏 , she is the best ever singer on any platform , i dnt care abt performance .... bt i expect lot from richa thats why i am saying this

Well may be you are expection lot IF doctor :) Listen one more time and see the difference ..anyway lets see who goes in next round .Tommorow I am expecting good perfromance by Maiyang and Emon ...Lets see how invisible Man parleen sings 😛

Originally posted by: tpam

in true sense i hav a gut feeling the guys may not turn really gud..i hav lot of expectation from shantanu , emon and meiyang.. i cant comment on parleen

Well judge guys based on voice and then sur and for initial round forget other drama :) I really liked Maiyang's voice ...its different .Emon is like sonu/rahul vaidya/vineet so lets see

Originally posted by: *Ajju*

Well judge guys based on voice and then sur and for initial round forget other drama :) I really liked Maiyang's voice ...its different .Emon is like sonu/rahul vaidya/vineet so lets see

I too am really looking forward to tomorrow's show .... I m sure Meiyang, Emon and Shantanu r going to rock the place .... From today's episode, I felt some performances were above-average and some were average ... hopefully, tomorrow we get to see some exceptional performances albeit they might be very few in number ...

i couldnt agree more ajju..

first thing...i dont think that all 14 were mindblowing ! not at all..oh common i have seen better singers! n they have not receivd such positive comments from the judges.. 😕 how come they just kept praising everyone? udit/alish are singers..they shud point out mistakes..how can these contestants be perfect..learning music is like a continuous thing..how can these aspiring singers be so perfect..

who said everybody is perfect???? people said that the show rocked because overall the performences are much better than previous years ..actually this is what us Idol fans want too..when u r nitpicking 28 out of 50,000 people we expect superb show and we were satisfied ....

I think judges gave some very apt comments ....after Rashmi's song Javedji said that her sur was hila in some places ..

When priyanka's performance was over Alisha pointed out that emotion was lacking in her song and it could have been better but after charu's perf she said it's flawless ..

and I agree with Alisha ..Tinka Tinka was totally Alisha's song but Dilko hazaar bar was nailed superbly by Charu and the praise was justified .....Deepali was criticised By javedji about her breathing problem and he told her to control that..only all out praise for Harshida surprised me , her sur "slipped" in some places....

Anyway, just my 2 cents ...dekhte hai kal( sorry aaj) kya hota hai ......counting on Emon, Meiyang , Shantanu and Parleen....but like today some dark horse may surprise me too 😉

If Alisha keeps praising so much, she will run out adjectives (awesome, fantastic, mindblowing, rocking) by next week. 😕

Originally posted by: sonyaee

If Alisha keeps praising so much, she will run out adjectives (awesome, fantastic, mindblowing, rocking) by next week. 😕

i think she already is out of it 😆

lets see wht she says tonight 😛😉

Originally posted by: sonyaee

If Alisha keeps praising so much, she will run out adjectives (awesome, fantastic, mindblowing, rocking) by next week. 😕

maybe tonight she will use the hindi versions of these words...