priyav thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

Guys,
Please calm down and think what happ in ydays gala.
Remember it was a TOP 2 GALA,not just any other one.
Competition gets tougher with every gala and judges too,coz to become the Indian Idol they have to be really good and ready to face any challenge to achieve this title
If judges expect the top 2 contestant to be perfect on Sur,its nothing wrong.
Again remember this is not a preliminary round or earlier galas,this is the Deciding Gala for II2.

Coming to Sandeep,i wont agree that he sang bad,but he was not perfect on sur,but this is the Top2 gala,so judges expected him to be on sur 100% which he didnt and hence anumalik was tough on him.
Farah ji always focus on performance,so according to her sandy was good which is ok.
If you listen to Sonu's comments again,it was purely Tongue in cheek,coz anuji has already done enough damage to Karunya by bashing sandeep,so may be he wanted to be a little easy on Sandy(My personal opinion).

At this time Sandy,Karunya and Janta needs to remember the best voted out contestants.
I would say Amey,Antara,Meenal,Monali,they deserved to come in top2.


Janta chose sandy & karu over these 4,so both Sandy & Karu needs to understand the importance of this gala.
I think Karu did justice to that,but sandy was not to a certain extent.

When monali was voted out,that gala she was not 100%,but i wud say 90%,but poor girl didnt get a second chance.
The same goes for Meenal & Antara.
Coming to Amey,why he was voted out is still a mystery ???????
Remember Sandy also had a bad day on Mitwa,but he got a second chance unlike others

When Janta has chose Sandy over Amey,Antara,Meenal,Monali doesnt he need to be perfect?
I think thats what he lacked yday and judges got a little tough on them.

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

969

Users

8

Frequent Posters

tisha_bhatia thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: priyav

Guys,Please calm down and think what happ in ydays gala.Remember it was a TOP 2 GALA,not just any other one.Competition gets tougher with every gala and judges too,coz to become the Indian Idol they have to be really good and ready to face any challenge to achieve this titleIf judges expect the top 2 contestant to be perfect on Sur,its nothing wrong.Again remember this is not a preliminary round or earlier galas,this is the Deciding Gala for II2.


Coming to Sandeep,i wont agree that he sang bad,but he was not perfect on sur,but this is the Top2 gala,so judges expected him to be on sur 100% which he didnt and hence anumalik was tough on him.Farah ji always focus on performance,so according to her sandy was good which is ok.If you listen to Sonu's comments again,it was purely Tongue in cheek,coz anuji has already done enough damage to Karunya by bashing sandeep,so may be he wanted to be a little easy on Sandy(My personal opinion).


At this time Sandy,Karunya and Janta needs to remember the best voted out contestants.I would say Amey,Antara,Meenal,Monali,they deserved to come in top2.


Janta chose sandy & karu over these 4,so both Sandy & Karu needs to understand the importance of this gala.I think Karu did justice to that,but sandy was not to a certain extent.


When monali was voted out,that gala she was not 100%,but i wud say 90%,but poor girl didnt get a second chance.The same goes for Meenal & Antara.Coming to Amey,why he was voted out is still a mystery ???????Remember Sandy also had a bad day on Mitwa,but he got a second chance unlike others


When Janta has chose Sandy over Amey,Antara,Meenal,Monali doesnt he need to be perfect?I think thats what he lacked yday and judges got a little tough on them.



I agree! With two contestant remaining - there is bound to be a comparision. Sandeep fell short in comparision to Karunya and hence the comments. If he really sang better - Karunya would have gotten the flak. The comments Karunya got - he truly deserved,I do not feel there was any sort of exaggeration there.
uknaik99 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
Yes.. Sandeep was not up to the mark..

for god sake he was singing in last 2.. just smiling,making face or pouting does not make him good singer
Bubbles_Rox thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
i really dont mind if karu wins but i really want sandeep to win!!! 😃 i love him and i'll feel bad and starty cryin if he doesnt win but still i like karu! 😃 😭
sreejan thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5
totally agree 👏 👏 👏 sandeep should have attempted a bit difficult song and gave a good competetion to karunya.....i never saw judjes not giving good comments when someone was awesome ....karunya did a wonderful job by choosing mannadey song ....it was perfect ending 👏 👏 👏 good luck to both of them ......may the best win 👍🏼
ng4khan thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: sreejan

totally agree 👏 👏 👏 sandeep should have attempted a bit difficult song and gave a good competetion to karunya.....i never saw judjes not giving good comments when someone was awesome ....karunya did a wonderful job by choosing mannadey song ....it was perfect ending 👏 👏 👏 good luck to both of them ......may the best win 👍🏼

😊I also feel that Sandeep has taken the last Gala lightly, may be as Anuji said he is confident rather over confident that how ever he performs still people will pour Votes for his supposed to be cute smile. There is not much of effort in his singing. At this level he is singing casually and with a sheepish grin telling that he gives himself 20 out of 10. I don't agree that he is so innocent that he won't understand the seriousness of this competition at this stage. Atleast he should have seen the efforts Karu has put all through the galas, and especially in the final gala. He really created Magic as Sonu said with his Album song and Mannada's song. This will remain with us and it is so easy to forget Sandeeps last performance in comparison with Karu. Even though i canm also say May the Best person win. Here we know clearly who is the BEST among the BEST. So i will say Only KARUNYA deerve to win. If that won't happen, it is not only insulting to Music. I just watched Popcorn show where after Anuj's exit Sonu was telling that If Karunya wins this competition he will be remembered for years to come as INDIAN IDOL. I think that will be such a proud moment to Sony , To all judges and finally to all Indians. Thanks. Gina.

priyav thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: ng4khan

😊I also feel that Sandeep has taken the last Gala lightly, may be as Anuji said he is confident rather over confident that how ever he performs still people will pour Votes for his supposed to be cute smile. There is not much of effort in his singing. At this level he is singing casually and with a sheepish grin telling that he gives himself 20 out of 10. I don't agree that he is so innocent that he won't understand the seriousness of this competition at this stage. Atleast he should have seen the efforts Karu has put all through the galas, and especially in the final gala. He really created Magic as Sonu said with his Album song and Mannada's song. This will remain with us and it is so easy to forget Sandeeps last performance in comparison with Karu. Even though i canm also say May the Best person win. Here we know clearly who is the BEST among the BEST. So i will say Only KARUNYA deerve to win. If that won't happen, it is not only insulting to Music. I just watched Popcorn show where after Anuj's exit Sonu was telling that If Karunya wins this competition he will be remembered for years to come as INDIAN IDOL. I think that will be such a proud moment to Sony , To all judges and finally to all Indians. Thanks. Gina.

thanks gina..

priyav thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: sreejan

totally agree 👏 👏 👏 sandeep should have attempted a bit difficult song and gave a good competetion to karunya.....i never saw judjes not giving good comments when someone was awesome ....karunya did a wonderful job by choosing mannadey song ....it was perfect ending 👏 👏 👏 good luck to both of them ......may the best win 👍🏼

yeap sandy didnt choose tough songs yday

kothra thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9
hi..
its gng to be a tough decision to make...best wishes to both karunya n sandeep
huzi
104869 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: ng4khan

😊I also feel that Sandeep has taken the last Gala lightly, may be as Anuji said he is confident rather over confident that how ever he performs still people will pour Votes for his supposed to be cute smile. There is not much of effort in his singing. At this level he is singing casually and with a sheepish grin telling that he gives himself 20 out of 10. I don't agree that he is so innocent that he won't understand the seriousness of this competition at this stage. Atleast he should have seen the efforts Karu has put all through the galas, and especially in the final gala. He really created Magic as Sonu said with his Album song and Mannada's song. This will remain with us and it is so easy to forget Sandeeps last performance in comparison with Karu. Even though i canm also say May the Best person win. Here we know clearly who is the BEST among the BEST. So i will say Only KARUNYA deerve to win. If that won't happen, it is not only insulting to Music. I just watched Popcorn show where after Anuj's exit Sonu was telling that If Karunya wins this competition he will be remembered for years to come as INDIAN IDOL. I think that will be such a proud moment to Sony , To all judges and finally to all Indians. Thanks. Gina.

sonu has said the rgt thng, hope ppl dont start abusing karu and sonu even for this

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".