Hate Sonu Nigam's judging!!!

I totally hate sonu as a judge, in yesterday's performances he was comparing like everyone to karyunya.... what the heck is that suppose to mean?? all that does is makes the other contestants feel bad and it lowers their confidence. In every show he has a different mood, sometimes he just gets too rude, i understand his singing point-of-view but he doesn't need to tell everyone that karunya is better than them. 😡 I was really mad at the fact that he told amey that karunya was better than him, i mean howw rude??!!

Its a COMPETITION...n every contest is competing with the other...Sonu is doing the right thing by comparing them cuz he wants them all to be as goood as Karunya 😊
That mighht bring some life back to this show..

i agree with nikki ,it is not fair enough on sonu's part to say such to amey

I luv u Nikki...tune to meri muh ki baath cheen li...lub u re... 👏 👏 👏 ...

He is supposed to judge them, nt compare them with other singers...Singers mein jo kamiyaan hai use baata na chahiya...Nt belittle them by comparing them with another contestant...

It is definitely my personal opinion, didnt mean to offend anyone...

Originally posted by: ~Nikki

I totally hate sonu as a judge, in yesterday's performances he was comparing like everyone to karyunya.... what the heck is that suppose to mean?? all that does is makes the other contestants feel bad and it lowers their confidence. In every show he has a different mood, sometimes he just gets too rude, i understand his singing point-of-view but he doesn't need to tell everyone that karunya is better than them. 😡 I was really mad at the fact that he told amey that karunya was better than him, i mean howw rude??!!

I agree word to word.
i respect Sonu and his amazing singing talent...but that doesnt necessary mean I will buy whatever he says...yesterday, he was so rude and even Anu was kind of 'karunya raised the bar" now whats the heck is that? you are pushinh down their confidence rather than encouraging them on healthy competitive note.....anyway, he's more mature in his field than any of us but being a human, he's also entitled to have biases and I wont mind if he still keep this nature of weighing right on the spot one with other.....not a good thing though....

Peace

Sonu knows his stuff. Amey has a few defects and especially high pitch singing and he is exceptional in softer songs.

You are a fan and fans react like you without rhyme or reason. Amey can bark like a donkey and you would probably find it good :-) Anyway, coming back to judgement. Yes on that DAY KARUNYA WAS THE BETTER SINGER AND SONU MERELY STATED IT.

Sonu supported Amey in piano and other rounds when he was selected last. He said he saw him in top 2 unfortunately for you Karunya is going to win it!

I would like Karunya and Amey to duke it out in the finals. So far I feel that Karunya and Amey have given steady performances and they deserve to be in the final two!

I have to agree with u guys its not fair why did he compare them all to karunya.... ok so he can sang but so can amey he is as good as karunya...

Amey ne kal acha nahin gaya tha...that is right...and sonu said that too...I agree with it completely...but he definitely didnt have to compare him with karunya... Karunya is brilliant 👍🏼 ...usme koi shak nahin hai...lekin..he doesnt have to say that to amey that Karunya was better than him...Poora confidence chala gaya hoga bechare ka...

i know whats going on in your mind Nikki ... its just that you are feeling insecure ..... why is it that the fingers have pointed to sonu nigam and why not towards Anu Malik ..... he raised the karunya topic and insulted sandeep ... it was a comparison!!
But i stand by Sonus comments .... his comparison is very fair .... he is guiding the viewers towards better music and talent and its high time he does that before we loose karunya. He is in bottom three every week inspite of him being the least deserved!

Originally posted by: delhiboy_vijay

But i stand by Sonus comments .... his comparison is very fair .... he is guiding the viewers towards better music and talent and its high time he does that before we loose karunya. He is in bottom three every week inspite of him being the least deserved!

I agree that Karunya has to be saved... Sonu is guiding viewers towards better music and talent but while doing that he is sacrificing Amey.... is it OK if Amey goes out? Karunya is great singer but Amey is no less.... This is my opinion and i am sure most of people who understand music will agree this.

Today what Sonu did to Amey... was it really necessory specially at this stage of competition????? Fine he did not like Amey's singing but he could have said in a better way.... I believe Karunya going out of competition will be a great loss to Indian Idol but Amey going out will be no less than that.....