AllThingsNice thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Aansuo ke girne ki aahat nahi hoti,
Dil ke tootne ki awaaz nahi hoti,
Agar hota khuda ko ehsaas dard ka,
Toh use dard dene ki aadat nahi hoti.

I gracefully accept the wah wah's on behalf of whoever has written this. This one occurred to me when Rishi broke the glass and everyone was in their own world and did not notice that he was hurt. That blood was still trickling about an hour later when it had to fall into Husna's maang. Symbolic. After all, lest we all forget, we just had to be reminded that this was janmon ka pyar. Janmon ka rishta. She also prevents Kabir from wiping it off. Can we have more proof about whose wife she is?? But hadn't they used a similar haldi symbolism when Zara was around? But because that went nowhere, I'm ignoring these obvious, cheesy hints that are being flung at us.

Husna has to personally thank the Sharma family for all that they have done for her. And its supposed to be ironic that she goes and says the exact wrong thing to the wrong person. I really loved Munna here. The sheer opportunist that he is, he never lets go of a chance at smooth talk. 😆

Husna cooks for everyone as a parting gift. Rishi and Indu do not have the mutton biryani cooked by Husna. And instead of Kabir going and fetching Rishi, Husna goes. Isn't this violating some code? I don't see why someone's wife should go and coax back some random man and bring him back to eat food cooked by her.

I apologize for asking this question in this manner, but I don't know another way to phrase this...isn't purdah something that is still religiously followed? Is it okay for men and women to mix like this? And aren't Pakistanis more rigid about it than Indian Muslims? Aren't Kabir and Husna a bit too open and demonstrative? They touch each other, say sweet nothings to each other in front of a family that is practically unknown to them. Not sure its the done thing. If this is creative licence, then I must say they're using this in a weird manner. But if there's something I'm unaware of then would be glad if someone could clarify. Thanks.

Today's epi flashed back to some nice moments from the beginning of the show. When Husna was bandaging Rishi's hand, I felt they could have flashed back to the scene in GK 69 when Rishi hurts himself and Indira is scolding him. "Bilkul Ishaan hain aap" she had said 😃

Rishi brings to Husna's notice that she has done nothing about her khooni maang. Her confused look had me confused too. Is she affected by him? Is she thinking about why she did not wipe it off? No idea. We'll get to know tomorrow. After all, tomorrow is another day!
Edited by AllThingsNice - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

2.5k

Users

13

Likes

58

Frequent Posters

TBDRESS thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Kanan! This is so freaky! I was about to make a post for the episode (thought you may not be around today) and was totally going to title it "Overdose of symbolism.": Okay let me read the rest of your post now 😆
Rasha4eva thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: AllThingsNice

Aansuo ke girne ki aahat nahi hoti,
Dil ke tootne ki awaaz nahi hoti,
Agar hota khuda ko ehsaas dard ka,
Toh use dard dene ki aadat nahi hoti.

I gracefully accept the wah wah's on behalf of whoever has written this. This one occurred to me when Rishi broke the glass and everyone was in their own world and did not notice that he was hurt. That blood was still trickling about an hour later when it had to fall into Husna's maang. Symbolic. After all, lest we all forget, we just had to be reminded that this was janmon ka pyar. Janmon ka rishta. She also prevents Kabir from wiping it off. Can we have more proof about whose wife she is?? But hadn't they used a similar haldi symbolism when Zara was around? But because that went nowhere, I'm ignoring these obvious, cheesy hints that are being flung at us.

Husna has to personally thank the Sharma family for all that they have done for her. And its supposed to be ironic that she goes and says the exact wrong thing to the wrong person. I really loved Munna here. The sheer opportunist that he is, he never lets go of a chance at smooth talk. 😆

Husna cooks for everyone as a parting gift. Rishi and Indu do not have the mutton biryani cooked by Husna. And instead of Kabir going and fetching Rishi, Husna goes. Isn't this violating some code? I don't see why someone's wife should go and coax back some random man and bring him back to eat food cooked by her.

I apologize for asking this question in this manner, but I don't know another way to phrase this...isn't purdah something that is still religiously followed? Is it okay for men and women to mix like this? And aren't Pakistanis more rigid about it than Indian Muslims? Aren't Kabir and Husna a bit too open and demonstrative? They touch each other, say sweet nothings to each other in front of a family that is practically unknown to them. Not sure its the done thing. If this is creative licence, then its must say they're using this in a weird manner. But if there's something I'm unaware of then would be glad if someone could clarify. Thanks.

Today's epi flashed back to some nice moments from the beginning of the show. When Husna was bandaging Rishi's hand, I felt they could have flashed back to the scene in GK 69 when Rishi hurts himself and Indira is scolding him. "Bilkul Ishaan hain aap" she had said 😃

Rishi brings to Husna's notice that she has done nothing about her khooni maang. Her confused look had me confused too. Is she affected by him? Is she thinking about why she did not wipe it off? No idea. We'll get to know tomorrow. After all, tomorrow is another day!


As usual loved Reading it😳👏

Yup symbolic n whose idea was it???😆It was lovely..I have to say.."khoon bhari maang
And yess if in fb they could have shown those past moments..Indira scolding Rishi when he got hurt ..it would have been great!!

And yeah agree with you Muslims are a bit conservative or rigid about "touching" n all in public..😕😆

@ bold this line compelled me to post😆I love love love that book!!!😳😆
AllThingsNice thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Rasha4eva

As usual loved Reading it😳👏


Yup symbolic n whose idea was it???😆It was lovely..I have to say.."khoon bhari maang
And yess if in fb they could have shown those past moments..Indira scolding Rishi when he got hurt ..it would have been great!!

And yeah agree with you Muslims are a bit conservative or rigid about "touching" n all in public..😕😆

@ bold this line compelled me to post😆I love love love that book!!!😳😆

Me too!! 😃 I love the book and I adore Scarlett O'Hara with all her weaknesses. What a heroine!

TBDRESS thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
The writers of HD clearly don't understand that symbolism only works when it is used sparingly. In Rishi's words, itna sara symbolism mujhe hazam nahi hota 😆 Ab dekhna ye hai ke kiske symbolism mein zyada taqat hai. Is Husna's passing out when Kabir was hit in the head across the border more symbolic or is khoon bhari maang more symbolic 🤣
I have been wondering why Rishi does not tell Kabir about Indira. I have a feeling that the precap will also be a dream or something.
BTW Kanan, you seem to have missed the sweet empathy that Rishi has been showing towards you in the last few episodes. Tumhare dard ko share karne ke liye, he also has decided to injure his hand repeatedly...first with the knife catching, then Indu helped him out with the biting, and today with breaking the glass. Isse kehte hain asli symbolism 😳 🤣
samrudhi.r thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: AllThingsNice

Aansuo ke girne ki aahat nahi hoti,
Dil ke tootne ki awaaz nahi hoti,
Agar hota khuda ko ehsaas dard ka,
Toh use dard dene ki aadat nahi hoti.

I gracefully accept the wah wah's on behalf of whoever has written this. This one occurred to me when Rishi broke the glass and everyone was in their own world and did not notice that he was hurt. That blood was still trickling about an hour later when it had to fall into Husna's maang. Symbolic. After all, lest we all forget, we just had to be reminded that this was janmon ka pyar. Janmon ka rishta. She also prevents Kabir from wiping it off. Can we have more proof about whose wife she is?? But hadn't they used a similar haldi symbolism when Zara was around? But because that went nowhere, I'm ignoring these obvious, cheesy hints that are being flung at us.

Husna has to personally thank the Sharma family for all that they have done for her. And its supposed to be ironic that she goes and says the exact wrong thing to the wrong person. I really loved Munna here. The sheer opportunist that he is, he never lets go of a chance at smooth talk. 😆

Husna cooks for everyone as a parting gift. Rishi and Indu do not have the mutton biryani cooked by Husna. And instead of Kabir going and fetching Rishi, Husna goes. Isn't this violating some code? I don't see why someone's wife should go and coax back some random man and bring him back to eat food cooked by her.

I apologize for asking this question in this manner, but I don't know another way to phrase this...isn't purdah something that is still religiously followed? Is it okay for men and women to mix like this? And aren't Pakistanis more rigid about it than Indian Muslims? Aren't Kabir and Husna a bit too open and demonstrative? They touch each other, say sweet nothings to each other in front of a family that is practically unknown to them. Not sure its the done thing. If this is creative licence, then I must say they're using this in a weird manner. But if there's something I'm unaware of then would be glad if someone could clarify. Thanks.

Today's epi flashed back to some nice moments from the beginning of the show. When Husna was bandaging Rishi's hand, I felt they could have flashed back to the scene in GK 69 when Rishi hurts himself and Indira is scolding him. "Bilkul Ishaan hain aap" she had said 😃

Rishi brings to Husna's notice that she has done nothing about her khooni maang. Her confused look had me confused too. Is she affected by him? Is she thinking about why she did not wipe it off? No idea. We'll get to know tomorrow. After all, tomorrow is another day!


@red: 🤣. Exactly the thoughts that crossed my mind.

Nice analysis Kanan.

Saheb and Husna is definitely a very demonstrative couple when it comes to showing affection. May be they cant do more of this in Pakistan in front of Noor, so they are taking advantage of liberal Indian ways and doing it as much and as often as possible without considering onlookers embarrassment, before they go back to the old restrictions in pak.
AllThingsNice thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Walden

The writers of HD clearly don't understand that symbolism only works when it is used sparingly. In Rishi's words, itna sara symbolism mujhe hazam nahi hota 😆 Ab dekhna ye hai ke kiske symbolism mein zyada taqat hai. Is Husna's passing out when Kabir was hit in the head across the border more symbolic or is khoon bhari maang more symbolic 🤣
I have been wondering why Rishi does not tell Kabir about Indira. I have a feeling that the precap will also be a dream or something.
BTW Kanan, you seem to have missed the sweet empathy that Rishi has been showing towards you in the last few episodes. Tumhare dard ko share karne ke liye, he also has decided to injure his hand repeatedly...first with the knife catching, then Indu helped him out with the biting, and today with breaking the glass. Isse kehte hain asli symbolism 😳 🤣

I don't know what is to be achieved by Rishi telling Kabir about Indira. See, in the real world, that's the way to go. The logical way. But if you were to tell HD writers that they should get Rishi and Kabir to talk and clarify things, they will most likely ask you "Zara ke time pe karvaya tha na Malik aur Rishi ki baat!! Kya hua tha tab? Isliye, is baar, Rishi chup rahega. Dekhte hain kya hota hai."

And then...when Husna and Saheb have returned to Lahore and Husna is (against her will) remembering Rishi, at that time, Rishi will be shown illegally crossing the border and we will have more symbolism. Here, Husna will cut her finger while chopping bhindi and there, Rishi will cut his fingers because of the barbed fence. Here, Husna will faint because of excess blood loss and there, Rishi will faint because of... something...something creative.

Am done with my rambling. 😛

@bold: What an analogy, sirjee! But no...had we been twin hearts in different bodies, then instead of being bitten, broken, and whatever else, he would have torn a ligament 😆

Edited by AllThingsNice - 12 years ago
AllThingsNice thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: dhanya.r

@red: 🤣. Exactly the thoughts that crossed my mind.


Nice analysis Kanan.

Saheb and Husna is definitely a very demonstrative couple when it comes to showing affection. May be they cant do more of this in Pakistan in front of Noor, so they are taking advantage of liberal Indian ways and doing it as much and as often as possible without considering onlookers embarrassment, before they go back to the old restrictions in pak.

@bold: i swear I thought of this too! 🤣 Chance maar rahe hain!

-Paulomi- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
This fakirs and all and of course those haldi and khoon,don't fall on these cheap pranks of HD.

DIKHAAVE PAR MAT JAAO APNI AKAL LAGAAO.😆
AllThingsNice thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: -Paulomi-

This fakirs and all and of course those haldi and khoon,don't fall on these cheap pranks of HD.


DIKHAAVE PAR MAT JAAO APNI AKAL LAGAAO.😆


You mean look beyond these scenes and search for deeper meaning?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".