To the people who like Harry-hermy as a p - Page 8

Created

Last reply

Replies

116

Views

7.8k

Users

18

Frequent Posters

Mrignaini thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#71
Although I dislike Ginny, I find it totally sexist to say she'd been roaming with different guys so that makes her evil, that sounds so medieval. I guess it's OK for Harry to be involved in different relationships but not Ginny cos she's a girl.
sentimentalfool thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#72
SEE I told you I also forget names easily😆😆, but now I remember Labib😛
Edited by redhotght - 17 years ago
sentimentalfool thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#73

Originally posted by: sandali_

Although I dislike Ginny, I find it totally sexist to say she'd been roaming with different guys so that makes her evil, that sounds so medieval. I guess it's OK for Harry to be involved in different relationships but not Ginny cos she's a girl.

LOL...I dislike her not because she's been roaming with boys, but because she criticised Ron and hermione...no one can criticise them ok except they can criticise each other😆*terribly biased opinion*😳😆But i like Ginny for some things like she doesnt ever make fun of Luna or Neville...she was the first to befriend and be nice to them😛😳

Edited by redhotght - 17 years ago
Mrignaini thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#74

Originally posted by: redhotght

LOL...I dislike her not because she's been roaming with boys, but because she criticised Ron and hermione...no one can criticise them ok except they can criticise each other😆*terribly biased opinion*😳😆But i like Ginny for some things like she doesnt ever make fun of Luna or Neville...she was the first to befriend and be nice to them😛😳



Khushboo, I too appreciate her for the same reasons as you've stated but overall I don't find her too appealing as a character. I too can be biased when it comes to Hermione but anyways I just felt it was wrong to slander her merely cos she's been in relationships. And I know you didn't criticise her for that.😛
Edited by sandali_ - 17 years ago
sentimentalfool thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#75

Originally posted by: Mrs.Brett Lee


PS- Wen I read d 4th buk..I hd a crush on d character of Viktor..Krum..Acc to me it ws 2 gud for it 2 b true..He ws so popular..n he lyked hermione a lot..n cared for her..

lol....but when he asked harry if ron hermione are together he had no problem wht soever tht hermy was going out wid him😆good boy vicky👏
cezzurockz thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#76
GINNY IS NOT THT BAD!!!!
i dnt knw hw to defend this bt stop bashing her
luna n hermy r also nt perfect they also hv flows in their characters
no body is perfect alright
n she best suited with harry
n as far as hermy is concerned ron is the best companion for her
344471 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#77

Originally posted by: sandali_

Although I dislike Ginny, I find it totally sexist to say she'd been roaming with different guys so that makes her evil, that sounds so medieval. I guess it's OK for Harry to be involved in different relationships but not Ginny cos she's a girl.

Well, if Harry wud have also roamed around with so many girls i wud have also blamed Harry, I am also not a sexist, either. Harry only loved Ginny, but Ginny dated with a lot of boys. But other than her all characters had only one lover. IMO i dont like i concept of having or dating with so many people, but once again thats only my opinion.
I also, havent said that i only hate her for roaming with many boys. I had given my reasons why i hate her. Plus, it isnt important for a character to be negative in order to be hated. Even if we think her to be postiive, i will still hate her. Feelings comes naturally which cannot be stopped. I dont find anything appealing in her character. And also, she critisized and made fun of Hermy in book six, which i absoulutely loathed.and she didnt even tust Harry, and was extremely jealous of ChoShe didnt even think wether Harry will be alive or not, all she cared about is that Cho doesnt go with HarryAnd she didn't even come with Harry when Harry needed her the most...she was having fun in Hogwarts...
Lastly, my point is that i don'thate Ginny thinking that she roamed with so many boys etc etc...my point is i am also not a sexist. (Just clarifying if u thot otherwise)😊
Edited by stranger@mirror - 17 years ago
344471 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#78

Originally posted by: cezzurockz

GINNY IS NOT THT BAD!!!!

i dnt knw hw to defend this bt stop bashing her
luna n hermy r also nt perfect they also hv flows in their characters
no body is perfect alright
n she best suited with harry
n as far as hermy is concerned ron is the best companion for her

Do u know what does the term "bashing" means?? 😕
Bashing means to critisize someone extremely harshly, and thus by the usage of extremely filthy words. Here, in I-F, bashing means anyone who uses words which arent allowed in I-F. As far as ican see, me or anyone over here, has not bashed Ginny. We are critisizing her, not bashing. There is a huge difference b/w critisicm and bashing. Critisicm is very well allowed here, so it cannot be stopped just because u r saying it to. Bashing isnt allowed, and no one bashed her - everyone critisized her. I request u, check the meaning of bashing plz.😊
I have said Ginny to be "evil minded" "Bad" "evil" and lots of things...but they all fall in the catagory of "critisicm". And not and never bashing. Hope it is understandable. Bashing is if i call Ginny to be some extremely degratory names, which arent allowed in I-F. but critisizing someone and saying her to be evil minded is allowed. and is not bashing.😊
As for "luna n hermy r also nt perfect they also hv flows in their characters no body is perfect alright " - yeah u r right. Luna and Hermy werent right too. If this is the case, then y arent u critisizing them aas well?? As i said critisicm is very well allowed in this forum. If u want, u can critisize Hermy and Luna for their mistakes as well if u want. No one is gonna stop u.
After all, this is the purpose of a discussion forum. We are here to discuss...and in a discussion its not always possible to agree...disagreement will occure, and so critisicm will occure too.
Lastly, let me make this clear again: Critisicm is Allowed, Bashing isn't.
Edited by stranger@mirror - 17 years ago
Mrignaini thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#79

Originally posted by: stranger@mirror

Well, if Harry wud have also roamed around with so many girls i wud have also blamed Harry, is it clear?? I am also not a sexist. Harry only loved Ginny, but Ginny dated with a lot of boys. But other than her all characters had only one lover.
I also, havent said that i only hate her for roaming with many boys. I had given my reasons why i hate her. Plus, it isnt important for a character to be negative in order to be hated. Even if we think her to be postiive, i will still hate her. Feelings comes naturally which cannot be stopped. I dont find anything appealing in her character. And also, she critisized and mad fun of Hermy in book six, which i absoulutely loathed.🤢and she didnt even tust Harry, and was extremely jealous of Cho🤢She didnt even think wether Harry will be alive or not, all she cared about is that Cho doesnt go with Harry🤢And she didn't even come with Harry when Harry needed her the most...she was having fun in Hogwarts...🤢



You can feel whatever you want for her, I just felt it was unfair to slander her for having boyfriends which was done in your previous post and I just stated so within my rights. Who ever enforced upon you that only positive characters have to be liked?😕, I myself am not fond of Ginny.
Plus your last point, can you elaborate on that? Because as far as I'm aware Ginny had no choice but to go back to Hogwarts as the Death Eaters had enforced that in the DH, so even if she wanted to go she couldn't have. And puhlease everyone was having far from fun in Hogwarts during the DH, they were away from their families and it was unlike any academic year as they could hear news of death of their close ones due to the circumstances.
Edited by sandali_ - 17 years ago
344471 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#80

Originally posted by: sandali_



You can feel whatever you want for her, I just felt it was unfair to slander her for having boyfriends which was done in your previous post and I just stated so within my rights. Who ever enforced upon you that only positive characters have to be liked?😕, I myself am not fond of Ginny.
Plus your last point, can you elaborate on that? Because as far as I'm aware Ginny had no choice but to go back to Hogwarts as the Death Eaters had enforced that in the DH, so even if she wanted to go she couldn't have. And puhlease everyone was having far from fun in Hogwarts during the DH, they were away from their families and it was unlike any academic year as they could hear news of death of their close ones due to the circumstances.

I have edited that post of mine and had added and substracted things from there. i request u to check that post and comment on it, rather than the previous one.

Related Topics

Harry Potter thumbnail

Posted by: minakrish · 4 months ago

⚡ Happy International Harry Potter Day!🧙‍♂️✨

Happy International Harry Potter Day Today, 2nd May — we celebrate the magical world that gave us spells, friendships, bravery, and...

Expand ▼
Harry Potter thumbnail

Posted by: Quantum-Dot · 11 months ago

Hello fellow Potterheads!⚡ Exciting times ahead in the Wizarding World! As many of you have heard, HBO has officially announced a brand-new...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".