OVERDUE ANALYSIS: Thread 2 Link, p150 - Page 24

Originally posted by: 21-07

Hoila devils! i was going through the discussions since page1..

The thing which caught my attention was how maan always protected geet's honour( her dupppata) and dev failed miserablely in it...

Today I want to ask one thing which had always bugged me..Hope u guys would help me..

The first scene Of maan and geet where goons were after her, she asked for maan's help..those goons clearly wanted to rape her..As she had no money with her...so the only motive for them to run behind her was to rape geet..so why in that scene maan threw her aside..

i always wondered one thing..Had geet did not fall into the river, she would have been robbed of her izzat..In that case also she could have been died..so why maan only bothered to save her life when she fell into the water..isnt it weird..or maan knew it already that geet will fall into the river and he will come to save her...😕

The idea of being raped is more dreadful than paani mei dubna..

can someone help me in this.I failed to understand maan's pysche here.😲

Lily! I understand ur point..maan was the reason that geet stood up for herself..he believe in " help yourselves' thing.All the other incidents which immediately took place after he saves her were up to the mark..where he was clearly not intrested in leaving back her home.par given the situation, where 4 goons are after one single girl..its so difficult to help yourself at that time...and if he can help her in savin her life when she fell into the river, he could have helped her in goons case too..she was a stranger for him in both the cases..

Originally posted by: Samanalyse

@Ruchi: I think Maan just did not give a crap when he saw her with the goons. Frankly, I don't even think he was listening to her or understanding the situation. He was just like, here I am sipping my beer ALONE and I hear this annoying whiny voice, what is it saying? I don't really care! Get it away! So I think he was just tuning her out and giving her the royal ignore.

@above- Its the perfect explanation- if someone suddenly stumbled across you -you'd probably try to jerk them off & in MSK's case -who was the detached sort -neither the meddler nor the intruder -he mightn't take a random person's plea so lightly-he'll be suspicious of them if its the first time ever.

I really liked the "tuning out" & whiny voice interuppting while having a swig of his drink part😆

Thats putting hs self thoughts in words I guess

Also, I agree with Lily. I think his attitude would have been one of why on earth should I save this girl when I could get hurt in the process? This MSK is in no mood to put anything on the line for a girl!

As for rescuing her from the water, i don't know. Maybe because it was so much more in his hands. He could actually do something without risking anything himself. Also, it was much more literal this time around that she was going to die if he didn't help her.

This too - he may've suspected the earlier incident's ingenuity-but there wasn't any doubts about these -though he wiped his hands off her instantaneously in literal sense after rescuing her.

He's not the one to be a courteous saviour.

All in all -they were trying to show -that a true person extending a helping hand mayn't come all with sugar-toned words ,wearing his heart on sleeve-nor would they mince words in telling your flaws -but yet giving you strength which Maan came to become -by series of events if not by one stand alone act & not always being too smooth nor too harsh.

Or maybe he just fancied a swim. 😉

LOL!! Yeah may be that too😆