#Devil's Den# :Maaneet Hue Show se Paraye :( - Page 27

Originally posted by: hegdemedha

As I perceive it, and I may be completely wrong, the passion and the charm that is yearned for had its genesis in the interaction between two people who stood by their values, yet were magnanimous enough to accept when they were at fault; who instinctively brought out the worst reaction in the other, yet provided the opportunity to bring out the best in the other.

Take their basic characteristics away, and what we are left with it is the Maan and Geet of the Amritsar track and the Maan and Geet of episodes such as yesterday. If I were to wipe away from my memory the characteristics of Maan and Geet and their story, and see a photograph of DD and GC together, all I'd say is, "Well, that's one photogenic couple." But, that would be it.

@ Mila: Ouch. You had to suffer that episode as a gift on Eid. Anyways, belated wishes for Eid.

I agree especially with the point you made about this Geet whose ultimate aim in life is a trip to Mumbai and new clothes for the wedding, as opposed to the post-Amritsar Geet who, without a word, stood by her husband, accepted a life of relative austerity and appreciated the value of a mere Rs. 50 earned by her husband through sheer manual labour.

@ Usha: Bye. See you around later.

@ all: I'll take your leave for now too. Be back later.

@Medha and Usha:I know what u both r trying to say ..but the point is GHSP series hv already touched its pinacle too soon where initially for first 7-8 months we got flawless episodes with flawless characterisations on a daily basis ...now slowly from that pinacle its sliding down and thats why the downfall is looking so painful and we r reacting so strongly ...

Jyo, I like your thought process in that. Now, if only the GHSP team saw it that way, we'd have a better product.

And, I could not resist this. If they are to show the difference between the fairytale and reality, we need Maan and Geet alive in this birth and not reincarnated.😆

@ All: Happy Ganesha Chaturthy🤗.

Holaaa

I hope GHSP is here to stay 🤓 want an official confirmation... its like hanging upside down...lolz😆

here made an maaneet VM on "Stay with me by hurts..' chek it out if you had time...and happy Ganesh chaturthi 🤗

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MvryPIUsVqs

Jyo and Medha I agree with you both. Jyo, yes, post-marriage is not as 'dreamy' as pre-marriage is. All of us, married women here only know that too well. Maaneet are no exceptional couple who should be spared from the harsh reality of life.


I was thinking back on how Geet reacted yesterday and to be frank I too have acted as devilishly as her at times when I dont get what I want. But Geet's behaviour coming in the heels of last week's episodes, it left us all stunned and angry. I hope her insane behaviour is temporary and a result of her PMS and soon the story will go back on track. One thing I noticed while watching the repeat of the first five minutes of the show today. As I said yesterday, GC's messy hair distracted me from observing the scene more closely but there appeared to be a loop closed in the scene where Maan handed such an important file to Geet. In an earlier scene when they were to go visiting the site, Maan did not trust Geet and picked up the file which was lying on the bed before leaving the room. It is another matter that he picked up the wrong file but he had serious trust issues with her and exhibited it through his personal handling of the file. Yesterday was a closure of this loop because Maan himself comes to give a file which he considered important to his wife for safe keeping. He demonstrated to her how much he trusts her with things connected to his work which is all important to him. He could have kept the file himself but he gave it to her. Alas, our dear madam was in a foul mood and did not see the significance of his action and instead vented her anger on that poor file. Now when she realises what she has done in her fury, she is going to repent big time. When Maan realises what had triggered her untypical behaviour even he will feel a bit of remorse that he had pushed his wife to such a corner that her craving for his company has marred her pleasing personality and turned her into a shrew.

Medha, bang on as usual. Yes, if they have to show how Maaneet cope with real life we need to see more on the current Maaneet and not the reborn Maaneet.

Originally posted by: jyoti06

@Medha:Only last week I saw everyone going gaga over Maaneet scenes and this same Maan and Geet and this week once again we r saying this is not the old Maaan and Geet ...so as viewers r we really consistent in our analysis as well ??

Jyo, the CVs are the ones not consistent not us viewers. The Maan and Geet they showed us last week particularly the ones on the Wednesday episode were close to their earlier characterisations (which is why I think Mahesh may have been on a holdiay last week). Surely you cannot dispute the Maaneet we are seeing this week are markedly different.




I guess today if one mahii comes we will forget all the cribbing that we did last night 😆

It is not a question of mahi alone. In fact inappropriate mahis can only marr the scene not enhance it.

My point is yes these r not the same Maan and Geet we met last year ..the characters hv taken 180 degreee turns with new CVs coming in and I dont expect them to go back to that old Maan and Geet again ...

We did have glimpses of the old Maaneet in the pauper track which was cut short thanks to Mahesh arriving back from his wedding vacation.

All I want is that Maaneet charm to come back ..the whole passion element for which GHSP was known for to come back ...and for that I m ready to take any alternatives whether its RC or any XYZ track ...

Passion per se would make no sense if not grounded in strong characterisations and screen play. It may give a momentary high but cannot sustain. We saw that only too often in the Amritsar track. There was a momentary high in a couple of intimate Maaneet scenes but they could not hold on because the screen play and the characterisations were weak.

Yes we cannot guarantee that the glory of old Maaneet will come back with any XYZ track ,but there is no harm in trying it...maximum it will also fail in a month or so and then they can close shop ..but at least noone will repent later saying I wish they had tried out 😆

By then Maaneet would have already been done to death both physically and metaphorically. My request is address the root cause and not the symptom.