STAR ONE - PLEASE DON'T EDIT GEET! UPD:GOOD NEWS - Page 21

this is outrageous!!!😲how can the channel do such things???ruining their own shows by doing stupid thingss..😡they should really stop doin this....we hav already lost two gud shows on the channel....we dont want Geet to go the same way....they shud just trust the director and the PH ...they knw wat is gud for the show....

When it works, film editing ' which could just as easily be called "film construction" ' identifies and exploits underlying patterns of sound and image that are not obvious on the surface. Putting a film together is, in an ideal sense, the orchestrating of all those patterns, just like different musical themes are orchestrated in a symphony. It is all pretty mysterious"

Walter Murch- Oscar Winner 1979

We are not kids we understand that due to time constraints you cannot air all the footage you have shot and that editing is crucial, but when editing takes away the essence of the story you have lost the viewer.

There is a reason why awards are also given for editing alongside acting, script writing, directing, etc., because it is in the editing room that the final product takes shape. The actions in the editing room decide whether a piece will be a success or a failure, editors are like the diamond polishers who take a rough still expensive diamond and polish it just right so that its beauty comes through for the public to admire.

You are creating a story here pulling the viewer into the World of Fantasy'Geet is an awesome show and due to unsound editing for the last few weeks it has lost the plot'for month you gave us the build up to Maan and Geet confessing their love to each other, the truth revelation and ultimately their commitment to each other'

However we were let down completely. Shattered is as close as I can describe our disposition during the last two weeks'the truth gets revealed and no contemplation on Geet's words by Maan, just hurry hurry like he was literally going to miss his train. Maan declares his love for Geet at the train station and no self-talk on Geet's part. No wait you did give us self-talk, one line "does my past really not matter to him?" That was laughable, what about her asking whether he was doing it out of pity or guilt, or if he was more concerned about Dadi? What about Maan feeling elation and talking to himself about how lucky he was that Geet had missed the train and that she was back in his life? Why didn't Geet look for the Taveez in her bag, since that was the sole reason she missed her train for?

Another fine example of your unsound editing, yesterday how did Maan loose Geet in a tiny market and Geet end up in the middle of a crowd. If Maan Singh Khurana's grip so fragile and loose that Geet's hand slipped out. I hope not, else just as slowly he got Geet, that's how fast he will lose her.

There is a reason why you have a daily show so that you can show the viewers the proper development of the story. There is a reason why there is a difference between reel time and real time, so that you can show the events of one day taking place during a few episodes, so the question remains why have you been rushing one of the most important moments of the show and editing parts that are crucial to the story line, leaving viewers asking questions regarding the story.

In conclusion editing's main purpose is to construct a story not destroy it, when done well it will leave the viewers spell bound, if not you will soon lose viewers who have been loyally following the show, then not only will you have a crappy show but also low TRPs.

So who ever has been making the decisions to edit at the Production House keep in mind you have been trying to pass of coal in place of a diamond for the last few weeks. And although chemically they are similar they are very different when it comes to value. Don't lose the value of the show.

If you continue to pass of badly edited work all I can say is ..Congratulations you will have achieved your goal of instant success and instant failure.

stop editing. star one is spoilling Geet team's work and we cant take that quietly. whole geet team is working really hard for this serial and starone is spoiling their work, but we all fans, wont tolerate that. 😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡

Star one

My Dearest Editors,

How are you? Busy editing I guess!! I just wanted to personally thank you for all the wonderful work that you do. I was so happy about yesterday's episode and was on cloud nine. But later I heard a "rumor" that some of the MUCH NEEDED self talk scenes from Maan were edited out! Now I know for sure it's just rumor!! Why on earth would a LOGICAL human being edit out Maan's self talk scenes following the truth revelation? I know you are not that ILLOGICAL right? RIGHT? You always make smart editing decisions right? RIGHT? Ok, that's about it. Let's hope that I don't have to write to you again!

Love,

Marsha

No matter how hard the production team works, despite the wonderful storyline and great preformances by the actors, despite the creative forethought and vision, this serial can be flushed down a composite waste site because of the poor choppy editing. There is no excuse for editing all the wonderful bits that are essential to the story, the subtle nuances that make this story different. Whoever makes these decisions should invest their time in producing a video called Decision Making- how to take the worst decisions instead of spoiling a good show, or quit his/her job. For not only will these decisions be the downfall of the show, slowly one day people will forget that there ever was a channel called star one. You poor decision making is shocking, why dont you go back to school and learn the art of making the right decision, the art of editing. If only emmy awards had an award for worst editing decisions, this would be a frontrunner.

Originally posted by: Marsha_Patel

My Dearest Editors,

How are you? Busy editing I guess!! I just wanted to personally thank you for all the wonderful work that you do. I was so happy about yesterday's episode and was on cloud nine. But later I heard a "rumor" that some of the MUCH NEEDED self talk scenes from Maan were edited out! Now I know for sure it's just rumor!! Why on earth would a LOGICAL human being edit out Maan's self talk scenes following the truth revelation? I know you are not that ILLOGICAL right? RIGHT? You always make smart editing decisions right? RIGHT? Ok, that's about it. Let's hope that I don't have to write to you again!

Love,

Marsha

Sometimes there is no connection between one scene and other. When Maan was taking Geet along with him away from old guy when he mentioned he was looking for a bride to his son. Maan was holding Geet's hand. Immediately she was seen in between old man and his relatives. How is it possible. There are many such incidents. The 100th episode with the song WHERE is the party tonight would have been much better. Because of Channel's scissor we could not enjoy to the extent we all expected.

Ann, Thank you very very much for starting this topic. In support for your topic, I have started a thread

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/geet-hui-sabse-parayee/1493995/contact-details-of-starone-and-news-channels

which has the contact details of some news channels and tv channels. So that those who want to post to these channels can get the information easily.

please dont butcher the show... please please dont... 😭