3 IDIOTS-Deep Analysis - Geet CANNOT step on Maan! - Page 8

Thoughtful Analysis Nags, Vrush and all. Symbolism personified. And to some extent the lead characters seem to be completing some of the rituals of a married couple. My comments too :)

a. Of the broken glasses: Her life is presently like pieces of broken glasses broken by a deliberate push, shattered everywhere and all she sees is Maan in reflection in those broken pieces. she doesn't want to step on those pieces and take any step forward, for she wants not to step anywhere where Maan's image is reflected. And she wants not that his image get tarnished.
b. Maan lifting her and taking away from the glasses symbolises that he's ready to offer her a new path, devoid of those broken pieces. A safe path to tread.
c. He swaying the swing loudly tells the fact that he's ready to offer himself, his big, broad and safe arms to her even if she tries to run away no matter what, she's to come to him. What goes around comes around, so the harder she tries to be away from him, she's bound to get back to him. He's ready to sway her in this 'Zindagi ka Jhoola' and steadfast it as well, should it go astray or go out of control. Isn't it something a husband does for his bride too.
d. Of the Moon : Not many see shooting stars but our protagonists are lucky enough and kyun na ho, is pyar ke saamne to khuda bhi jhuk jaaye.
Well said enough by Vrush and Nargis. The dark clouds and bright Moon go together night after night and so will Geet and Maan. With Maan's and Geet's dark past, Maan's like the strong and bright moon engulfing the darkness. Vice verca we see, the same logic seems befitting for Geet too.
e. The chase : Beautifully done. It says no matter what she tries to run away from the world and is afraid to take on challenges and change her life, there will come a time when she'll have to stop, reflect and take a new course.

I so loved the fact that the CV's showed his pragmatical and watchful side when with his dialouges with NT. Cool episode.

sure...infact i do crave and wait for posts such as these....i'm not much of drooler so these posts are the only reason i like exploring the forum...
and no ways we making it up...its there for all to see and feel...some notice - some don't thats all...but the symbolism and emoting of it is always present


yep so we have another person to deduce what Maan says with words, with eyes, with his body language...hmmm btw..loved the open..shirt...i would love to run my hands..on his torso..

okay i know..i shall write a scene..and have Geet do it for me...!!

@ Preeti..

thanks girl....loved the addition... i am always bowled over..by your analysis.. that is what i look for..a reflection of my/our thoughts..for..we three idiots do talk a lot about Maan...and..yes..it helps us..consolidate our belief that we are not the only one..in this journey of understanding...and enjoying..Geet...

thanks for being part of our madness...it gives us insight..

Originally posted by: Pretzels

Thoughtful Analysis Nags, Vrush and all. Symbolism personified. And to some extent the lead characters seem to be completing some of the rituals of a married couple. My comments too :)

a. Of the broken glasses: Her life is presently like pieces of broken glasses broken by a deliberate push, shattered everywhere and all she sees is Maan in reflection in those broken pieces. she doesn't want to step on those pieces and take any step forward, for she wants not to step anywhere where Maan's image is reflected. And she wants not that his image get tarnished.
b. Maan lifting her and taking away from the glasses symbolises that he's ready to offer her a new path, devoid of those broken pieces. A safe path to tread.
c. He swaying the swing loudly tells the fact that he's ready to offer himself, his big, broad and safe arms to her even if she tries to run away no matter what, she's to come to him. What goes around comes around, so the harder she tries to be away from him, she's bound to get back to him. He's ready to sway her in this 'Zindagi ka Jhoola' and steadfast it as well, should it go astray or go out of control. Isn't it something a husband does for his bride too.
d. Of the Moon : Not many see shooting stars but our protagonists are lucky enough and kyun na ho, is pyar ke saamne to khuda bhi jhuk jaaye.
Well said enough by Vrush and Nargis. The dark clouds and bright Moon go together night after night and so will Geet and Maan. With Maan's and Geet's dark past, Maan's like the strong and bright moon engulfing the darkness. Vice verca we see, the same logic seems befitting for Geet too.
e. The chase : Beautifully done. It says no matter what she tries to run away from the world and is afraid to take on challenges and change her life, there will come a time when she'll have to stop, reflect and take a new course.

I so loved the fact that the CV's showed his pragmatical and watchful side when with his dialouges with NT. Cool episode.

Pretti....thanks for your comments ans symbolic examples...they are too good. Its really amazing that there can be so many interpretations of the same scene.....that just reinforces that Variety is the spice of life....we all come form different backgrounds and hence we bring a prospective that is all our own!!! Love it!!!

Pretti...we would love to have you join the IDIOTS family as a regular updater on our thread....we do so enjoy your analysis!!! What say...are you game??

Originally posted by: Pretzels

Thoughtful Analysis Nags, Vrush and all. Symbolism personified. And to some extent the lead characters seem to be completing some of the rituals of a married couple. My comments too :)

a. Of the broken glasses: Her life is presently like pieces of broken glasses broken by a deliberate push, shattered everywhere and all she sees is Maan in reflection in those broken pieces. she doesn't want to step on those pieces and take any step forward, for she wants not to step anywhere where Maan's image is reflected. And she wants not that his image get tarnished.
b. Maan lifting her and taking away from the glasses symbolises that he's ready to offer her a new path, devoid of those broken pieces. A safe path to tread.
c. He swaying the swing loudly tells the fact that he's ready to offer himself, his big, broad and safe arms to her even if she tries to run away no matter what, she's to come to him. What goes around comes around, so the harder she tries to be away from him, she's bound to get back to him. He's ready to sway her in this 'Zindagi ka Jhoola' and steadfast it as well, should it go astray or go out of control. Isn't it something a husband does for his bride too.
d. Of the Moon : Not many see shooting stars but our protagonists are lucky enough and kyun na ho, is pyar ke saamne to khuda bhi jhuk jaaye.
Well said enough by Vrush and Nargis. The dark clouds and bright Moon go together night after night and so will Geet and Maan. With Maan's and Geet's dark past, Maan's like the strong and bright moon engulfing the darkness. Vice verca we see, the same logic seems befitting for Geet too.
e. The chase : Beautifully done. It says no matter what she tries to run away from the world and is afraid to take on challenges and change her life, there will come a time when she'll have to stop, reflect and take a new course.

I so loved the fact that the CV's showed his pragmatical and watchful side when with his dialouges with NT. Cool episode.

September 7, 2010 Episode.

My most favorite scene from today's episode was the conversation between Mann and NT, WOW! 😃

I liked when Geet was calling him Cutie and when Adi came in the office.

CVs, why do you wish to keep Geet 12 years old when she is 18 years old. 18 year olds do have some level of maturity.😡

Furthermore, when you look back at the beginning episodes of Geet HSP, Geet was not as immature as she is in Delhi. Especially the day when she confronted her family about what they had down to her. So why is she behaving so immature in Delhi, even people in love do not behave so immaturely. Why is Geet behaving so silly about the kiss on her hand and doing tauba, tauba gesture with her hands?😡

Also keep in mind that you are pairing her with a business tycoon. How old is Mann anyway? Hope not more than 20 or 21.

Engagement scene:

Because of the way this scene was executed Geet better not be pregnant. Here is why:😡

If Mann had given her the ring during the engagement party scene yesterday and she accepted it would have been ok because nothing heartfelt was said or shown.

BUT' After Geet's "teeny bopper" way of getting her confirmation of Mann's feelings makes her acceptance of the ring today question her integrity because she has not told him the truth. 😡

On top of knowing Mann's true feelings for her. In today's episode Mann's proposal to Geet was true in every sense, it came from his heart as his words and actions proves this and Geet knows this, yet she accepted the ring without telling him about her past, which will question her integrity if she is pregnant and therefore the CVs should not make her pregnant because Geet's INTEGRITY is very important in this story. 😡

Really CVs, you guys have missed the pregnancy track a long time ago.

Hello 3 Idiots.... lol...

Originally posted by: yasu09

Hello 3 Idiots.... lol...

todays episode was marvellous...

i don't really have much to add..

seeing as you have covered everything.....

just want to say that you three galz have done a brilliant job with the analysis...

Thanks Yasu...glad that you enjoyed it...the episode and our analysis!!!