/ Saffron Fields/ Thread#17// AN Teaser Pg 132/ Link thread 18 Pg 1. - Page 32

Created

Last reply

Replies

1k

Views

84.9k

Users

293

Likes

6.8k

Frequent Posters

IPK007 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: kclovearshi



@Bold: This is interesting..I guess no body questioned Arnav's fidelity when he made love to Khushi (I won't say sex, gives me bad vibes) when technically he was still married to Lavanya..

Now he is not married to Khushi, she is not his girlfriend who gave him millions of reasons to not to be with him and who agreed readily to the breakup which means they are not committed to each other..so how is the question of fidelity arising now?

[DIV][/DIV]

Which is exactly why it will be addressed using Arnav's POV :) (Rationalist/Liberal)
Edited by IPK007 - 10 years ago
vks11 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: canapoem




I have a bad feeling that Sujatha has something to do with it. I dont know but I feel that Sujatha might have called Aastha and spoken rudely to her or she might have done something through Madhu which did reach Aastha and Arnav ultimately. Does Arnav think that Khushi supported her mom?

Coming to the blonde, maybe it was a date and he did take her home but I am sure he did not have sex with her. Maybe he realised that he can never cheat Khushi and asked the girl to crash in the guest bedroom since it was late and she might have been drunk.

Now I hope this misunderstanding clears quickly.



Kavi Loved your comment👏 👏. Especially these 2 points. As you rightly said this is not the Arnav we know. So something else has happened for him to behave this way😭. Will wait with Sabr for Jenny to reveal it.
Coming to blonde I too strongly believe that this is what would have happened. We trust our Jenny and her Arnav.

Edited by vks11 - 10 years ago
A_BA thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: canapoem


Kavita, indeed a very valid point you have raised about fidelity/infidelity.

Ok here is my take on what Arnav feels.

According to Arnav, after he separated from his wife, mentally he was single again. He felt due to some rules of Ohio State he is not granted a divorce on paper, but emotionally, mentally and physically he was single. He felt relationships are only valid when they are bound through hearts and emotions which was not there for him with La.

So I think his conscience did not prick when he slept with Khushi (thrice).

But coming to the present situation, I am not able to say anything in his defense or against him as I do not know the entire picture.

The above views is only my understanding of Arnav's mind and I am not generalizing anything here.



Kavitha, as you said, Arnav's conscience did not prick when he slept with Khushi because he was completely detached from Lavanya. Maybe in this scenario, Arnav did take home this woman, and his conscious hit him with the fact that he is committed to Khushi, at least in his heart if not in reality - to him, sleeping with this woman would be considered infidelity even though he and Khushi aren't together officially?? I'm just making assumptions now, but I can't stop thinking about all this now!!!! I need Arnav's POV chapter, ASAP Jenny😆
kclovearshi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: canapoem


Kavita, indeed a very valid point you have raised about fidelity/infidelity.

Ok here is my take on what Arnav feels.

According to Arnav, after he separated from his wife, mentally he was single again. He felt due to some rules of Ohio State he is not granted a divorce on paper, but emotionally, mentally and physically he was single. He felt relationships are only valid when they are bound through hearts and emotions which was not there for him with La.

So I think his conscience did not prick when he slept with Khushi (thrice).

But coming to the present situation, I am not able to say anything in his defense or against him as I do not know the entire picture.

The above views is only my understanding of Arnav's mind and I am not generalizing anything here.


Yes..you are right about Arnav..What he did was right back then because he already filed for divorce and what he is doing now may still be construed as right as he has broken up with Khushi.


But I wasn't questioning him..

I was questioning the readers who are questioning his character..And if he indeed dated/had sex with another.. that it is unacceptable for them..

If I understand the western culture of dating & relationships correctly, what Arnav did in both cases is considered fidelity..but according to Indian culture it is infidelity in both cases..

so we cant pick and choose what we want just so it favors the protagonists..
pixiegirl thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: MEsw


just literally dying to understand Arnavs pov. what will explain, and justify this anger, this behavior of his??
i totally understand Arnavs this characteristics are making him more of a human...same grey character as others with all the flaws...and we love Arnav with warts and all...but than wart is a wart...isnt it...we just don't like the wart...but we love Arnav.

that is the thing of a story isn't it? that you love characters with all the flaws...they appeal to you in their realistic avatar...sometimes super human or super hero kind of characters feels like a fairy tale...a childs story...yes we love happy ending and there are elements in story which kind of escapes the reality of real life. but more realistic they are, more better..

i am so waiting it to be his "sabra" and not her "sabra".


I so loved your whole comment but especially what you said in bold.

Yes, we love all the flaws & everything about our Arnav... We know he is not perfect and don't expect him to be so either, but please don't make him a heartless brute!!! 😭
canapoem thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: kclovearshi

[

Yes..you are right about Arnav..What he did was right back then because he already filed for divorce and what he is doing now may still be construed as right as he has broken up with Khushi.


But I wasn't questioning him..

I was questioning the readers who are questioning his character..And if he indeed dated/had sex with another.. that it is unacceptable for them..

If I understand the western culture of dating & relationships correctly, what Arnav did in both cases is considered fidelity..but according to Indian culture it is infidelity in both cases..

so we cant pick and choose what we want just so it favors the protagonists..


You know Kavi, here I want to share something with all the readers what I had read a few years ago.

We all know that Bollywood director/producer Boney Kapoor is married to actress Sridevi and she is his second wife.

When his first wife died of cancer a couple of months ago, I read a article about her on one of the news websites.

It was quoted that she had not signed the divorce papers yet and then she came to know that Sridevi is already pregnant with her husband's baby. Thats when she thought that what is the reason for prolonging her signing the divorce papers if the other woman is already pregnant with her husband's child.

What surprised me was according to her was, no one said a peep about the entire issue including their family members and today Boney Kapoor and Sridevi are quoted as a couple so much in love and so ideal etc.

But what if these people were some regular people, then everyone would have said and written a lot about them.

The point I want to make is, people's opinions about fidelity/infidelity are so different from couple to couple that I want to ask how do we judge what is wrong and what is right in everyday lives???
Edited by canapoem - 10 years ago
jduke thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago

What are the plausible reasons for Arnav's prolonged anger for months?

1. Arnav came across happy Kushi and Aman together on multiple occasions and places ever since their Gazebo fight?.

2. Sujata / Madhu / Some one else hinted Astha about Arnav and Kushi breakup and possible new alliance of Kushi immediately after break up (April itself ??????) and this news got carried to Arnav and he is extremely mad and upset with Kushi and didn't even bothered to check her messages?


3. Arnav really meant what he said at gazebo fight and dating other people to understand what he really wants and not bothered to check Kushi's messages?


Edited by jduke - 10 years ago
archnahardik123 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
First of all let me scold arnav for being such a jerk.😡
Now I will be little calm and think differently. May be he was angry to see Khushi with another man just like Khushi got hurt to see arnav with another women. But seriously arnav you can come with other and not Khushi. This is not fair. If you can see other so can Khushi. Secondly I really trust you jenny that you will not let down arnav's character and make us hate him. I believe he can't be with another woman so soon. There must be something else to the scene. Listening a girl picking his phone from his room did break my heart just like Khushi. Hope this could be clear in future.

Coming to Khushi. She is doing everything she can but arnav is not understanding her point. We know that he is hurt by Khushi by the also had to understand her position too. A girl can't think from mind like boy. She use her heart and she has to keep in mind several things. Like society, parents and their thinking. She can't leave everything and be with arnav which he want. My heart break to see her hurt and thinking about arnav.

Now we come to know from where Sujata got her nature. It's from her father. Always thinking from her point of view. Glad that they are not coming for the marriage, now arnav can peacefully win Khushi without any interference from Sujata.

Loved the way you write their old home and childhood masti. I too miss my childhood. Please jenny we want second part soon. Make it quick.

Thanks for marvellous update and big hug From me too . Love you. Thanks for the scrap you sent.
bkamber thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 3 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
Oh my...14 pages already since the chapter was posted. I wonder what is going on. 😲

I am off to make a large pot of coffee for me since I just came back from cocktail hour...let's see what our wonder boy and wonder girl have been up to...I am guessing lot of sides today. I will read the chapter, make my comment and then read other comments.


kclovearshi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago

Originally posted by: canapoem


You know Kavi, here I want to share something with all the readers what I had read a few years ago.

We all know that Bollywood director/producer Boney Kapoor is married to actress Sridevi and she is his second wife.

When his first wife died of cancer a couple of months ago, I read a article about her on one of the news websites.

It was quoted that she had not signed the divorce papers yet and then she came to know that Sridevi is already pregnant with her husband's baby. Thats when she thought that what is the reason for prolonging her signing the divorce papers if the other woman is already pregnant with her husband's child.

What surprised me was according to her was, no one said a peep about the entire issue including their family members and today Boney Kapoor and Sridevi are quoted as a couple so much in love and so ideal etc.

But what if these people were some regular people, then everyone would have said and written a lot about them.

The point I want to make is, people's opinions about fidelity/infidelity are so different from couple to couple that I want to ask how do we judge what is wrong and what is right in everyday lives???


I do not think the question of infidelity and people's opinions's about it change based on the couple. The example you quoted is clearly an example of infidelity and it was hushed by Power & Money of the celebrity couple. Why the family didn't talk about it? I guess they are ashamed and the first wife's side of family may not have been successful even if they went to press..

Same thing happened with Shilpa Shetty & her husband too (his first wife did not want to give him divorce).. it is all because of their celebrity status..

Even if people talk they will forget it after couple of days..its not something people remember indefinitely and it does not mean there was no infidelity..

Related Topics

Fan Fictions Thumbnail

Posted by: Koeli

5 years ago

Comment Migration Request Thread #1

Hey guys, This is the place where you can request for comment migration. Please know that FFEs are going to migrate your comments. Rules - You...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".