Why a mother would give up her child?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

-Pj-

@-Pj-

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#31

Originally posted by: sabeeha

That would actually make a lot more sense if he had a son from an affair or something because it would tie in with the break up to the marriage.

But still, why would this kid have a vendetta against Swamz? I know she like irritates the hell out of everybody, but what the hell did she do unless her ex was a complete psycho who churned out a psycho son.

@Munni: rofl, ❤️ the ganga ghat

My reasoning could be that if the son was from an affair and Swamini left her husband. The father could have then ruined either is own life or the mother's life. So being the son he takes revenge on Swamini who he could think is the reason behind it all. It is a rubbish idea about revenge and something I do not really wish to see ever on any show, but it is something.

Quote

sennareni

@sennareni

Voyager

Posted: 12 years ago

#32

I dont think Karan is SB's son... In a episode last week when SB was hurt over Virens behaviour and was telling Vanshika about it, she made a dialogue telling "Agar mera apna khoon hota to aisa karta kya?"... So i dont think its her son... But cannot tell abt the writers, they go back on their own dialogues many a times...And also she is never seen thinking of her child if she had any...

But as Munni has said, he might be the Son whom SB never knew...

Or he might be Someone related to the Guy whom she was in a relationship with...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

-Pj-

@-Pj-

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#33

Originally posted by: sennareni
I dont think Karan is SB's son... In a episode last week when SB was hurt over Virens behaviour and was telling Vanshika about it, she made a dialogue telling "Agar mera apna khoon hota to aisa karta kya?"... So i dont think its her son... But cannot tell abt the writers, they go back on their own dialogues many a times...And also she is never seen thinking of her child if she had any...

But as Munni has said, he might be the Son whom SB never knew...

Or he might be Someone related to the Guy whom she was in a relationship with...

When did she say that? She was upset with Viren? I'm really not paying attention

Quote

Munni

@munnihyderabad

Trailblazer

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#34

Pooja,,,

as I keep saying Indian audience brain is so tuned to a set of character..

ok female lead - Adarsh, sacrificing, mature, sane, submissive, benevolent, keep a sad face,.she should laugh her heart out... she should be worried about her family 24x7 even if there is nothing to worry and more importantly she has to SHED buckets and buckets of TEARS

and if any of the trait is not seen in the lead .. the lead is no longer perfect - fans are annoyed react violently if the character is changed a bit

Male lead - family man, always successful with no failure, always respectful, mature, loving and caring .. and never be rude to anyone... if anyone of the traits is missing fans go berserk .. ohhh there is so much of inconsistency in his character. the CVs are ruining his character.. heck man,.. wish the real life is as smooth as reel life...

these set expectancies of the leads from the audience will not let the CVs dare to change the characters or explore the human flaws in these couples ...

Quote

sennareni

@sennareni

Voyager

Posted: 12 years ago

#35

Originally posted by: -Pj-

When did she say that? She was upset with Viren? I'm really not paying attention

She told it the day she came to return the things she had of Viren from his childhood to Vanshika.. And yes she was upset with Viren cos she was hurt when Viren thought SB guilty for jeevs running from home..

Edited by sennareni - 12 years ago

Quote

Munni

@munnihyderabad

Trailblazer

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#36

Originally posted by: -Pj-

When did she say that? She was upset with Viren? I'm really not paying attention

Anne that statement from SB holds quite a weight ... but again the writers can go back on the dialogue.. who am i talking about ..

but Anne,.,, if what i say is right about SB not knowing about her son.. does that imply applying Ekta formula here - about the still born child 😲

Quote

delete1234

@delete1234

Navigator

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#37

Originally posted by: sennareni

She told it the day she came to return the things she had of Viren from his childhood to Vanshika

I watched that epi but didn't see the relevance of it at the time. Something like the difference between a mother and an aunt. For some reason, it kinda foreshadows her own pain of not being able to bridge that gap, maybe because she had a child and lost it, or gave up a child? 😕😕

Quote

sennareni

@sennareni

Voyager

Posted: 12 years ago

#38

@Munni: Dadaji being a honest and righteous man would not have stooped low as to have lied to his daughter abt the baby...(But then CVs may butcher any character so why not dj) But yes the guy she was involved with might have... And yes if this happens then again it goes the EKta way which is so predictable and lame

Quote

-Pj-

@-Pj-

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#39

Originally posted by: munnihyderabad
Pooja,,,

as I keep saying Indian audience brain is so tuned to a set of character..

ok female lead - Adarsh, sacrificing, mature, sane, submissive, benevolent, keep a sad face,.she should laugh her heart out... she should be worried about her family 24x7 even if there is nothing to worry and more importantly she has to SHED buckets and buckets of TEARS

and if any of the trait is not seen in the lead .. the lead is no longer perfect - fans are annoyed react violently if the character is changed a bit

Male lead - family man, always successful with no failure, always respectful, mature, loving and caring .. and never be rude to anyone... if anyone of the traits is missing fans go berserk .. ohhh there is so much of inconsistency in his character. the CVs are ruining his character.. heck man,.. wish the real life is as smooth as reel life...

these set expectancies of the leads from the audience will not let the CVs dare to change the characters or explore the human flaws in these couples ...

I understand this Munni but why does every male and female lead have to be like this? That is what irks me the most. They can have some traits but not all. That would actually makes more interesting Tv and drama. Self righteousness and perfectness actually highly irritating to watch.

I don't need to see real people on tv, but at least with human traits and qualities.

Quote

Munni

@munnihyderabad

Trailblazer

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#40

Originally posted by: sabeeha

I watched that epi but didn't see the relevance of it at the time. Something like the difference between a mother and an aunt. For some reason, it kinda foreshadows her own pain of not being able to bridge that gap, maybe because she had a child and lost it, or gave up a child? 😕😕

even i felt that the scene was more of SB's pain over being an Aunt and Viren doubting her because she is his aunt and not mom - by blood ...

but the statement which Anne pointed out .."kash mera apna khoona hota " is very crucial statement .. which should be brought up with Karan's revelation

Quote

1 2 3 4 5 6 ... 13

Why a mother would give up her child? - Page 4

Related Topics

Explore Topics