Why a mother would give up her child?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Munni

@munnihyderabad

Trailblazer

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#111

Originally posted by: -Pj-
Yeh that is one reason another being it's also an actor in the shows name so it can get annoying and confusing

I am more confused between Karan SS(character) and Karan T (Actor)

Quote

-Pj-

@-Pj-

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#112

I know Munni. That is what I mean I don't know who they are talking about when people make topics on Karan.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Lubabah Rahman

@ChurriBurri

Rocker

Posted: 12 years ago

#113

there will always be some glitches, its a show

Quote

sennareni

@sennareni

Voyager

Posted: 12 years ago

#114

@ munni: Oops just logged in... But then again Munni why is it tat we think it is Karan singh shekawath... If we think it in Ekta style it can also be the dad of Karan SS(who looks like karan) with whom SB is with... Or even it may be misquoted.. Instead of writing maanvi finds Karans photo in the possession of SB, they might have written it as Photo of SB with Karan... And may be tat guy is not karan but his dad... Again karan was also having a photo of SB from her younger self...

Edited by sennareni - 12 years ago

Quote

maham

@...Maham...

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

#115

The auction thing was pretty silly yes. Forget Google, if you remember the time when Virat took Maanvi to Hrishikesh so that she could meet Jeevika he clearly told Viren that he had been driving for 6 hours and they wanted to rest. Suddenly a 6 hours journey manages to stretch into.. okay how many hours? 😆

Downright silly.. or maybe that traffic jam lasted for half a day. 😕

Oh well.. I try not to look for logic in Indian shows. Its pretty rare anyway. 😆

The issue over Swamini and her son is a bit bizarre.. don't really care for it.

The writers seriously need to buck up, forget the overall track.. the writing and overall execution these days is incredibly half-baked. Miss the level of writing the show used to be capable of. *sigh*

Maham.

Quote

Virmanishal

@Virmanishal

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

#116

omg..quite an interesting thread.. i dint follow it after 2nd page before.got to read now.. consider the comments 'liked' lol.

dont have much to say here,cos everything has been said lol.

Some weeks back, i mentioned the same in a different thread, people are mostly obssessed with perfection for some reason,and its a weird sort of perfection.

Indian tv ends up having either black or white.

like not being biased,but i used to consider Virat and Manvi flawed in a nice way,still on the white side though, but Vadheras come up with maturity crap every now and then,unnecesarily,and they are being forced more into white side

i want Virat to stay impulsive and angry,and mooh-fat and a bit passionate,Manvi to stay bindaas and nose-poking and interfering and everything.

Would llove to see problems b/w them in ccareer track,but not insecurity,cos Virat/VM wasnt insecure of death, jealousy stands nowhere..

Tired of waiting for Viren to react, i felt bad for him for a longer time than he himself did,when J left lol.Abortion thing could have been used but then again, adarshness came in.. Accident track was lovely that way..

Edited by Virmanishal - 12 years ago

Quote

Virmanishal

@Virmanishal

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

#117

Making a separate comment for this,Jeevs running away,i am being contradictory here, but i feel though it was totally illogical, atleast it made J a bit humane.. its natural to feel guilty,guilty of decieving your in-laws, this is the only positive thing i found in that track, although i never felt a thing cos the guilt per se ,as an emotion wasnt explored or potrayed...one scene with J being shown superguilty and NOT thinking about Sazaa,or SB or anything, just pure guilt could be fine imo, and then being selfish by choosing to get over own guilt instead of thinking about others. but it was made to look like she is doing another balidaan and giving herself a punishment...that selfish feeling of trying to get over own guilt wasnt explored..

and also, we all also fell prey to what we are complaining, somewhere down the line, by not liking and criticising J's move and calling it inconsistency as she went gray..but yeah, she was made to look dumb instead if gray.

I know its easy to criticise, but its easier when this same show has given you some amazing sequences..

Edited by Virmanishal - 12 years ago

Quote

Munni

@munnihyderabad

Trailblazer

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#118

ok here is the latest bite on SB

Also, the track in Ek Hazaaron… is proceeding towards the point where Maanvi who has seen the photo connects the threads and tries to get close to the truth. Amidst this, Swamini (Seema Kapoor) will overhear Karan's (Sehban Azim) conversation and will get to know that he is her son.

http://www.tellychakkar.com/news/virat-gifts-maanvi-alto-karvachauth-ek-hazaaron-mein-meri-behna-hai

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

so girls .. what is the theory now.. does the still born theory still hold good

she will get to know about her son 😲

Quote

Munni

@munnihyderabad

Trailblazer

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#119

Originally posted by: sennareni
@ munni: Oops just logged in... But then again Munni why is it tat we think it is Karan singh shekawath... If we think it in Ekta style it can also be the dad of Karan SS(who looks like karan) with whom SB is with... Or even it may be misquoted.. Instead of writing maanvi finds Karans photo in the possession of SB, they might have written it as Photo of SB with Karan... And may be tat guy is not karan but his dad... Again karan was also having a photo of SB from her younger self...

Anne... looks like the Karan and his dad are double action .. and this is what I felt on the day she saw karan from the back

and her dialogue "WOH wapis ayaa" - here WOH means not son .. it is either husband/lover

Quote

gems4sana

@gems4sana

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

#120

Originally posted by: sabeeha
Okay first is first, Karan Shekawat (whatever the hell his name is), if he was indeed Swamini's son, why would she give him up?

It pretty much would explain her maternal instinct towards Viren, but what reason would there be for her to give away her own flesh and blood.

(I hope they don't bring in some Ekta-ish plot point in that she gave birth to the kid and then was told that the baby died when her husband actually took him away...)

The other thing was that I've been catching up with the show as I haven't watched it in a couple of weeks so I'm currently up to the whole house auctioning fiasco. Erm, does it really take all night to get the Hrishikesh if Viren, Virat, Manvi and Jeevika have set off from Chandigarh at eight in the evening to get there for the next morning?

A simple google mapping it shows something like a three and a half hour journey from the Choudhary's to the Vadhera's. A bit of logic writers :P

For the journey - in India what's supposed to be a three and a half hour journey takes alot longer.

My dad's friends live in Aurangabad in Maharashtra. When we visit India, to get from the airport in Mumbai to Maharashtra takes around 9 hours by car (once it took us the whole day..12 hours - but tht's because we stopped to eat) when on google maps it says only 6 hours.

idk thats what I thought - it can be realistic sometimes. But yeah three and a half hours translated to almost 10 hours?

thats crazy ahahah