Created

Last reply

Replies

49

Views

4.3k

Users

24

Likes

171

Frequent Posters

Nash.. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#21
Reformation and realisation is all good but to be judgemental, this all can't erase the crime committed.

I understand that only punishment is not good enough for an evil person, his mindset needs to be reformed and I want Shaurya to be a better person but falling in love with Durga, being accepted by her just because he changed, being forgiven by Payal and etc are Highly unacceptable.

Just because its a show most of us are waiting for Shaurya to be forgiven at the end but taking it as a reality note, Would we ever want the Rapists involved in Damini rape case forgiven on the account of reformation?? Never, none of us would!

A crime is always a crime and a criminal always remains a criminal...their transformation of mindset isn't gonna change the worst that they have done. And if they did worst then I want the worst to happen with them, just the way I want Shaurya to suffer.

larimel22 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#22
I support your view of Dev and Payal making a good pair. He loves her like a good friend and does everything to make her happy. In fact, with him around, she had begun to remember and had started showing a lot of progress in her treatment. So I do believe Dev is a very positive person for Payal, both as a friend or even as a life partner.
Shaurya, on the other hand, is not.
A person who speaks harshly can be reformed.
A person who is violent can be reformed.
A person who has a disillusioned mindset can be reformed.

But a person who rapes a woman, who can't even set his own limits on a helpless person CAN'T BE REFORMED.
Pairing him up with any girl is out of question!!
ipkfrnc thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#23
So Sad to see People's attitude to a rapist..
Kukkakaali thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#24
Shaurya is a rapist, a monster. He needs to be get hanged like 100 times to get his redemption and people are allowed to reincarnate only 7 times. So there goes the hope for Durga waiting for Shaurya.
butterfly15.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: dey.bh

Why should Durga fall in love in Shaurya ? Because he is a reformed person or because he is a paralyzed person ? Btw she is already in love with Dev na ?😆



Agree with you. I've watched many shows were people believe a criminal or evil person should be given a second chance by the female lead, but why? Why would Durga owe Shaurya a second chance even if he became an angel? Who gets off with the man that raped their sister, that would kill the story completely.


642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#26
Payal calls Dev "bhaiya". He treats her like a kid sister. So stop calling them a jodi!
No woman should or would marry a guy who raped her sister, got her family killed and even btried to get her killed.
Anurulz thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#27
i sincerely wonder whether all the pro durga-shaurya jodi gang has actually ever met or even seen a rapist? or even known/met/passed-on-the-street a rape victim..am assuming they have not..and i hope they dnt in the future either..coz i have seen and met both..and trust me, the pain i have seen in these women's eyes is NEVER going to go away..no amt of so-called remorse or turning over a new leaf by the rapist is going to take it away..do u know what the age range of rape victims i have seen?? i will tell u in very blunt words -- its from 3 n 1/2 yrs to 65 yrs..the child of 3 n 1/2 years had been admitted with a 4th degree perineal tear (meaning her vagina and her rectum had been perforated in non-medical terms), the bas***d who raped her was 14 yrs old and very conveniently got off due to the fact tht he had 4 more years to treat all females as his property to tear open..u think REMORSE is gonna change the disgust i felt for this inhuman creature who was not even an adult yet? u think remorse or sum stupid community service is going to change the terror in the tiny child's mind who is not even old enugh to understand what happened to her? is it enugh to take away the pain of having her insides torn thru and thru? is it enugh to decrease the pain of her parents who cudnt fathom how anybody cud do this to a mere child?
the other extreme was this 65 yr old widow who had gone for an X-ray to a hospital for her pneumonia..she was raped by the X-ray technician while she was coughing blood..this fellow who was young enugh to be her grandson..all she kept asking me during counselling was " did he not see my age? am not even pretty anymore..what am i to tell my son and DIL when they ask me how i feel? i dnt even understand how this happened"..the rapist in question was thankfully not brought in front of me otherwise i might just have kicked him in his nuts myself..
do u people know what other prisoners in jails do to rapists?? they rape them themselves..even among criminals rapists are counted as the worst of the scum..they are sodomised to make them feel the pain of what it feels to have sum1 tear into u in the worst manner possible..
so again, its my very humble request to all those who believe such people can change, to understand, there are degrees of crimes and of punishments..sum1 who has stolen to eat due to poverty is on a different level from one who has defiled a woman for the mere reason of being able to do so..
shaurya goenka belongs to the latter category..have we seen concern in his lustful eyes for any other human being till date? not even his mother who has committed murders for him..what indication has there been of him turning into a saint, pray tell me.. this man talks to going to a place like vaishnodevi to rape his fiance and dump her..this man is as good as a soulless devil who wud go rape his own mother if he had the opportunity to..and we are talking of love? i dnt think durga or any other female can have any feelings except disgust for leches like him..
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#28
Thank you for your incisive, detailed and poignant post Anu.
Shocking how people ignore the sheer heinous nature of rape.

Also does anybody realise what it means to have your entire family eliminated? What it means to lose your face and identity as you narrowly escape a murder bid?

Shaurya's family tried to kill Nitya. He still wants to only rape her and then dump her. Yet the superficial fans who cannot go beyond looks of actor, start looking for a non existent saint in a devil like Shaurya.
Perfect100 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#29
One word for this post..
"Pathetic" 😡
3serialfan40 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#30
That is a sick thought - a rapist and a murderer as a woman's husband. No wonder atrocious crimes are committed on woman the world over. Are you serious - would you marry one and spend your life reforming such a person. These type of folks but be thrown into a lion's den to die a slow death.

If anyone can reform I think Sakshi must reform, Kangana must be placed in a precarious situation (nothing happens to her - I would not wish this on an imaginary person even) and then Sakshi must be made to realize what happened. As her world is shaken and she is fairly traumatized at the idea of what could have happened, she catches Rajnath in the act. No fury matches a woman scorned - she provides the evidence to have Shourya convicted for the crime and since she is so smart, she can pin rajnath for aiding and abetting him. She spends the rest of her life spending her wealth on woman's issues!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".