Why Pooja kabir love story won't be wrong -Important

vaishuarshi123 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#1

No more janavi only Pooja Sharma. Janavi marriage to Dhruv us not considered marriage as her identity is wrong so marriage certificate becomes invalid. May be to show it even more right they might show as if shrwnu will divorce Dhruv. So there is no wrong in showing a love story later on between the leads. As now kabir and Pooja are not connected. They are 2 different indiduvals.

Created

Last reply

Replies

73

Views

12.8k

Users

12

Likes

103

Frequent Posters

AnnStyles thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#2

Its ok dear there is no use of making any post. Lol now plp will get a new post to rant about devar bhabhi thing 😂😂

Uff itna moral policing 😂 Especially just for a damn fictional show. People are acting as if this is the first time something like this is happening. Some of them are still not able to digest the fact that a certain couple did not work so the makers are trying their last resort. Even makers and star plus will think about themselves 🤣 Its all about money babies. 😂😂

Anyways don't rant to me about your frustrations because totally not interested. 😁✌️ Will keep watching the show because I like Shrenu from IPKKNDEBP days and zain after seeing him in ishqbaaz. 🤗

trinitodebone thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: vaishuarshi123

No more janavi only Pooja Sharma. Janavi marriage to Dhruv us not considered marriage as her identity is wrong so marriage certificate becomes invalid. May be to show it even more right they might show as if shrwnu will divorce Dhruv. So there is no wrong in showing a love story later on between the leads. As now kabir and Pooja are not connected. They are 2 different indiduvals.

I don’t know much about India soap operas . Some people on this forum have been mentioning that the love story between a brother in law and sister in law has been portrayed before in several india soap operas and these shows were popular.

However here the context seems different fromwhat they were describing . You are speaking of a technicality. The marriage is legally invalid ( what about from a religious perspective though ? I am not sure) and the name of the individual may be different but it is still the same individual who the family and society considered the daughter in law of the Mittal family for years , who Kabir’s elder brother (who Kabir presumably loves and respects ) consider his wife who he presumably loved and who Kabir considered his elder sister in law. Jhanvi also viewed Kabir as the brother of the man she “ married” for the purpose of getting revenge on the whole family including innocent bystanders like Kabir

After Kabir finds out about her betrayal no matter if some of her actions are understandable he can hate her but eventualky empathize with her and even forgive her and even try to make amends for what his father did ( make sure she and Ishani are secure financially look out for them etc) but to fall in love with her seems a bit of a stretch Like seriously there are no other women in the world without all the awkward baggage . Besides won’t most viewers who have followed the show from the beginning, know the reason for the revamp feel manipulated knowing that they deliberately changed the storyline and are forcing this change without rhyme or reason to get ratings . But maybe people don’t mind being manipulated as long as they can get their romance fix no matter how scripted forced and illogical . Indeed I have heard you should check logic at the doir when looking at an indian soap opera

Maybe those who have not looked at the show from the beginning , or those who look at a show for actors as opposed to the storyline or characters may not have a problem . They just care that their favs or 2 attractive actors who have a friendly relationship offscreen and “ chemistry” onscreen are paired. And of course indian soap opera audiences have to see a romantic relationship because that is fundamentally all they look at these shows for anyway although some constantly say they want content driven shows showing social issues work issues no family drama etc

trinitodebone thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: AnnStyles

Its ok dear there is no use of making any post. Lol now plp will get a new post to rant about devar bhabhi thing 😂😂

Uff itna moral policing 😂 Especially just for a damn fictional show. People are acting as if this is the first time something like this is happening. Some of them are still not able to digest the fact that a certain couple did not work so the makers are trying their last resort. Even makers and star plus will think about themselves 🤣 Its all about money babies. 😂😂

Anyways don't rant to me about your frustrations because totally not interested. 😁✌️ Will keep watching the show because I like Shrenu from IPKKNDEBP days and zain after seeing him in ishqbaaz. 🤗

This is not about moral policing but a forced illogical storyline with the audience knowing it was deliberately changed from the original script to improve ratings but I guess audiences din’t mind being manipulated .

I mentioned another show Aade Adoori in another thread which was about a brother in law sister in law relationship but there was a clear realistic reason as to why this could develop and it was the original script of the show not randomly introduced in desperate attempt to improve ratings . Anyway to each their own . Can’t account for lack of taste and discernment

shruzzy thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#5

Call me a blind fan as many of the forum article says but let me clear some perspectives

1. That i had accepted Yabir and Janruv but i m fan of shrenu-zain and if the channel i providing what i love i dont see any harm in it

2. She only called kabir bhaiya for a reason tht people dont ask them as pair from starting itself otherwise there were many times fans said kill kavya-dhruv nd make shrezain a pair otherwise this would have been done long ago

3 Right now they are just showing their tashan and love dhruv and ishani are still in show and kavya is going with open ends so still havnt their love story.

4 Even if they show i dont mind because its their pain and betrayal they got from each other both of them knows loosing someone dearer to them they can understand each other and understanding is one base of a relationship which i didnt find in yabir or janruv its just they supported each other

5 You people are right they are showing something not right someone even went to give example of laxman ji and sita maa. . people see that this is just fiction so dont match it nd once bhaiya is foreva bhaiya then we all call every indian is my brother/sister one indian would never be able marry to other indian

6. When we see something everyone has there on perspective we all liked janhvi at the same time many didnt find it right they she was grey so it is possible to make her white or black and if she is white i dont mind.

7. Definitely I will miss tanvi and ayub sir and dhruv's perspective is what i will be waiting for. . .

vaishuarshi123 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#6

@Annstyles so true people should see fiction as fiction enjoy it.

vaishuarshi123 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: shruzzy

Call me a blind fan as many of the forum article says but let me clear some perspectives

1. That i had accepted Yabir and Janruv but i m fan of shrenu-zain and if the channel i providing what i love i dont see any harm in it

2. She only called kabir bhaiya for a reason tht people dont ask them as pair from starting itself otherwise there were many times fans said kill kavya-dhruv nd make shrezain a pair otherwise this would have been done long ago

3 Right now they are just showing their tashan and love dhruv and ishani are still in show and kavya is going with open ends so still havnt their love story.

4 Even if they show i dont mind because its their pain and betrayal they got from each other both of them knows loosing someone dearer to them they can understand each other and understanding is one base of a relationship which i didnt find in yabir or janruv its just they supported each other

5 You people are right they are showing something not right someone even went to give example of laxman ji and sita maa. . people see that this is just fiction so dont match it nd once bhaiya is foreva bhaiya then we all call every indian is my brother/sister one indian would never be able marry to other indian

6. When we see something everyone has there on perspective we all liked janhvi at the same time many didnt find it right they she was grey so it is possible to make her white or black and if she is white i dont mind.

7. Definitely I will miss tanvi and ayub sir and dhruv's perspective is what i will be waiting for. . .

. So true agree let people think how they want. Even iin future if they show Pooja kabir love story nothing wrong in it.
vaishuarshi123 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: AnnStyles

Its ok dear there is no use of making any post. Lol now plp will get a new post to rant about devar bhabhi thing 😂😂

Uff itna moral policing 😂 Especially just for a damn fictional show. People are acting as if this is the first time something like this is happening. Some of them are still not able to digest the fact that a certain couple did not work so the makers are trying their last resort. Even makers and star plus will think about themselves 🤣 Its all about money babies. 😂😂

Anyways don't rant to me about your frustrations because totally not interested. 😁✌️ Will keep watching the show because I like Shrenu from IPKKNDEBP days and zain after seeing him in ishqbaaz. 🤗

. So true, I agree with wat u said. Best example in many daily soaps they show groom or bride exchange were the girl will love one brother but will get married to other. For example than is that not wrong. Janavi married is invalid as said, so pooja sharma is single so is zain even he 2ould have divorced kavya. After sometime people who are having problem will forget and will like the story and zain shrenu chemistry. 😊
trinitodebone thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: shruzzy

Call me a blind fan as many of the forum article says but let me clear some perspectives

1. That i had accepted Yabir and Janruv but i m fan of shrenu-zain and if the channel i providing what i love i dont see any harm in it

2. She only called kabir bhaiya for a reason tht people dont ask them as pair from starting itself otherwise there were many times fans said kill kavya-dhruv nd make shrezain a pair otherwise this would have been done long ago

3 Right now they are just showing their tashan and love dhruv and ishani are still in show and kavya is going with open ends so still havnt their love story.

4 Even if they show i dont mind because its their pain and betrayal they got from each other both of them knows loosing someone dearer to them they can understand each other and understanding is one base of a relationship which i didnt find in yabir or janruv its just they supported each other

5 You people are right they are showing something not right someone even went to give example of laxman ji and sita maa. . people see that this is just fiction so dont match it nd once bhaiya is foreva bhaiya then we all call every indian is my brother/sister one indian would never be able marry to other indian

6. When we see something everyone has there on perspective we all liked janhvi at the same time many didnt find it right they she was grey so it is possible to make her white or black and if she is white i dont mind.

7. Definitely I will miss tanvi and ayub sir and dhruv's perspective is what i will be waiting for. . .

1. I am from the west and mainly look at western shows though recently dabbled in a few indian soaps . I always look at a show for content that is a strong logical interesting storyline regardless of the actors and it certainly does not have to be morally acceptable . But I guess I cannot relate to someone who has fav actors and want to see them paired together romantically onscreen ( why must it be romantic btw?) no matter how much the storyline has to be twisted and nanipulated to do this

2) Are you serious ? You think the the writers are constantly stalking social media and listening to the rants of fans and changing the story minute by minute to suit the whims of fans on social media, who by the way may not be the whole trp audience .The general story was crafted months before the first episodes were filmed the promo was done and the show went on air . Since the begining before the show went on air in the promos and interviews Zain said it is a revenge thriller and he will be playing an army man who would love and respect his sister in law Jhanvi played by Shrenu but all will not be as it seems. The perfect daughter in law will have an ulterior motive Even the initial promo and title of the show implied that . So she called him bhaiya ( which I assume is brother in law) because that was the original storyline not so that fans would not ask them to be paired from the beginning lol

4 Yes understanding is key to a relationship People who have gone through similar hardships ( but not caused by the other person ) like both coming from broken homes can relate to each other etc But to fall in love with the very person who deliberately caused the hardship tried to destroy you and your family for whatever reason is extremely farfetched at best so this is an extemely weak argument imo

5 I have no idea about laxman and sita but I understand in Indian culture you call and consider those related to you ( including those related by marriage to your family member ) brother and sister if in the same generation . Some people also casually call people they are unrelated to in the same generation as brother and sister even good friends but that certainly does not preclude them from marrying each other Also No one is saying you can never fall in love with your former or current brother in law or sister in law But it is an extremely awkward thing in any culture and there really has to be a strong backstory to justify it which I don't see here . It is not like Jhanvi and Kabir liked each other before but she was forced to marry Dhruv or Dhruv ignored her abused here was constantly absent while Kabir listened to her supported her and understood her so they developed a connection which eventually turned romantic . The woman is deliberately trying to destroy Kabir’s family and does not care if Kabir is collateral damage Kabir’s trust and respect for her will be shattered esp as it is not just targetting him but his family - oh but somewhere down the road they will fall in love because they are literally the last man and woman on earth - maybe even a twisted soulmate connection. Seriously there is no other unattached woman out there without all this baggage related to Kabir’s family . After all Kabir has a fetish for sloppy seconds of guys he knows not even strangers first Kavya and then perhaps Jhanvi lol


Anyway no point discussing this further . Just stick to your first point perhaps that you just look at shows for your favourite actors to see them romance onscreen - content and logic be damned

Edited by trinitodebone - 6 years ago
trinitodebone thumbnail
Posted: 6 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: vaishuarshi123

@Annstyles so true people should see fiction as fiction enjoy it.

Wow coming from the west I now understand the mindset of many indian soap opera viewers and how they put up with the drivel that seems to be most itv shows . Seems just thirsty for “romance” however you can get it Might I suggest a universal classic like Casablanca or the more contemporary the Notebook then ?

Fiction which shows real world issues can deviate from logic reality as long as you get to see your favs romancing onscreen is that it .

Most with taste and discernment all over the world would say if it is fiction of the supernatural genre well it does not need to follow reality but if you are dealing with relationships and issues that you find in real life there should be some basis in logic and reality actual content .

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".