The Hippocratic Oath and Sanjeevani Docs - Page 10

Created

Last reply

Replies

122

Views

11.9k

Users

36

Likes

308

Frequent Posters

naadanmasakalli thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#91

Originally posted by: Amishi25

mods plz close this topic

why should they close it jsut because it doesn't agree to ur POV
Dhw@ni thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
#92

Hahahaaa.. ! Your talking about the Hippocratic Oath over here.. ? Seems like you saw 3 Idiots. :) :P

Forget the Oath.. Even on a human level, did Shashank, Riddhima or anyone for that matter go to help Armaan when he was re-cuperating all ALONE in a mental asylum.. ?
And Armaan was MENTALLY INSTABLE at the time.. ! I don't think he even realised she was suffering for hypothermia.. So the whole thing of him helping her out or arranging for help doesn't even arise.. !
Maha_Sid-dewani thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#93

Originally posted by: Dhw@ni

Hahahaaa.. ! Your talking about the Hippocratic Oath over here.. ? Seems like you saw 3 Idiots. :) :P

Forget the Oath.. Even on a human level, did Shashank, Riddhima or anyone for that matter go to help Armaan when he was re-cuperating all ALONE in a mental asylum.. ?
And Armaan was MENTALLY INSTABLE at the time.. ! I don't think he even realised she was suffering for hypothermia.. So the whole thing of him helping her out or arranging for help doesn't even arise.. !



for shanshank.. they didnt show if he was in touch with arman or not.. but i guess he might have been.. arman himself told shashank that he wanted to go away from ridhima so ridhima didnt know abt armans illness...
as soon as she found out she went mad in going searching for him n nearly lost her life a couple of time.... how can u blame ridima for not going to arman...

n another thing.. how can he not realise that she was suffering from hypothermia.. like some1 has already mentioned.. he was in a stable mind when he took off her jewellery n wrote that note to her..
bary thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 15 years ago
#94
well he did cover her with bedsheet if u watch it again once the old where they used body double u will find it,it is riddhima who ran behind him by waking again and then the whole thing happen,i think u should recheck again,its not like he throwed her out or left her in middle of forest,he left his house for riddhima
i wish some one makes team ARS...lol
i like SR a lot but that doesnt mean we can blame some one,i am totally irritated by ridhz who is weeping and blaming armaan 24 hrs
just felt like saying
well talking about medical oath i really feel they forgot that ppl who wear white lab coats are called as doctors and the building which is yellow painted🥱 is a hospital named sanjeevani,as all their relations enter they dont find difference in hospital and house,riddhima has her father,once her mother,her husband,ex-boyfriend,once her sister,so called jeez,her friend RM n AN,her saasuma as patient,her husband's friends,she really got confused betn hospital and house,poor girl,same with sid and armaan,pity them,i feel all of them should have different time of duty so that we could actually see some scenes,rather ''senior'' doctor riddhima only checking BP which could be done by any medical student
well ppl say that it is dill mill gayye not doctors mill gayye then why the hell they used stethoscope around dill mill gayye,it always remind me that ok now i am watching a medical show but again some saas bahu scenes make me feel like,ok i think i am watching the wrong channel
good post by the way
Edited by bary - 15 years ago
RM_megs thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#95
hi...ok first of all...nice post...i enjoyed reading it...:)

but...

guys...it jus a show...a fictional show...they put a disclaimer all the time before it starts saying thats its all fake and so on...

plus this is CV were talking about...do you reli think they know evry single detail on medical science?? lol...about this oath???...they probs dont even know about this oath...and most likely heard it for the first time when watching 3 idiots that too only if they have seen the movie...

so whats the point of arguing about it...

jus relax and enjoy the show...:)

Edited by RM_megs - 15 years ago
Meeko thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#96

Originally posted by: -Fizzylicious-



NO he wasn't if he was mentally unstable than how did he knew how to remove her jewellery and right a goodbye note that too one which made total sense in terms of hindi and grammer and than leave? sorry but mental unstability excuse is not gonna work



he wasnt mentally unstable.. he was fine then.. but wen he was around it was just tht ridz was unconcious, tht wldnt take her life.. aswell as he knew sid was around with her... acc to him tht was a help!!
mysterieux thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#97
Good Post Fary👍🏼....as usual I am on the tail end........
Being a medical student and taking the oath is not the be all and the end all...it is understanding the sanctity of that oath.
My Prof once told us that if we all thought that the medical profession was like all others then we all might as well quit now.
That does not mean that all that the professions are not worth it....they are..... everyone has their own importance...anywhooo
When the oath says "do no harm" it means that as a doctor you are not to take a life...- referring to things like abortion, euthanasia.
Medical profession is just not about books and internet...its is about valuing human life. Having taken the oath and using it for the purpose of justifying a doctors actions...is not right. The oath to a medical student/Doctor is very sacred.
The essence of the oath:
May I care for others as I would have them care for me.
Coming to DMG: it may be a story set in a hospital and about doctors but its really whacked🤪
The two characters in reference: Doctors....well....I would rather not go there...
As human beings...yes Sid definately stands out ...and I am sure so has Armaan in the past... but when he saw Ridhima lying there on the ground....he should have shown her some humanity...by making sure she was ok....
justifying that he knew sid was there, had gone to get help....mental instability......really... I am sure none of us have insights into his mind...so contemplating that would be pointless....
its as simple as ...he saw her lying there...he could have done something.... why wait for someone else......atleast a blanket ...sprinkled some water on her ....made sure she was breathing ok..you dont need a medical degree for that just common sence and a little humanity....
This is my opinion .
Cheers
Edited by moviebuff05 - 15 years ago
naadanmasakalli thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#98
i agree baffy agar aap sadak pe kisi ko problem main dekhte ho then u go and ask them if u r ok even if they r complete stranger than how can Dr Armaan leave his life like this shivering on floor

or maybe he just thought she's taking her beauty sleep

mysterieux thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#99

Originally posted by: -Fizzylicious-

i agree baffy agar aap sadak pe kisi ko problem main dekhte ho then u go and ask them if u r ok even if they r complete stranger than how can Dr Armaan leave his life like this shivering on floor

or maybe he just thought she's taking her beauty sleep

yeah beauty sleep on the floor....in that awkward position 😆😆
naadanmasakalli thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: moviebuff05

yeah beauty sleep on the floor....in that awkward position 😆😆



lol remember we r talking about "mentally unstable" armaan 😆



Edited by -Fizzylicious- - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".