Originally posted by: zainab25
Internet helps huh? 😛😛😛I tell you, great source of information it can provide you.I would buy this explanation of yours (I may still do,a bit of it), but I find it extremely tuff to believe that he was mentally unstable when three weeks later he was rocking at concerts to find a cure for cancer....oops I mean psychotic illness. It doesn't make a difference anyways...cancer, hypothermia, Alzheimer's, they are all the same in CMG. Anyways, it really would be a miracle for him to get treated in a span of three weeks and conveniently go on a world tour for awareness purposes during that time. Was he in emotional turmoil? Yes, I believe that, and hence he left a letter for his ex - fiance who was laying unconsciously on the floor. Earlier I said as well, with or without the oath, just as a human being, he should have at least checked her state before deserting her but maybe his own state of mind couldn't handle the trauma of witnessing his lover again. Also somewhere someone said that he had noticed Siddhanth with Riddhima, thus he conveniently left her unconscious and numb in hopes for Sid to recover her. The point is that he left her, and I do not believe his mental state was incompetent to treat a patient. It seems eerie to know just in three weeks, he was able to self heal his psychotic illness, and even arrange a tour for that cause.
Sid was suppose to be the hero? Erm. Well he is regardless of Armaan, but then why would KSG state that his return was planned by the CVs before his infamous exit from September? Don't tell me he lies too now. Examining that statement of his, the CVs then should not have portrayed Armaan as a selfish prick. Tsk. Tsk.
On a lighter note, no where did the 'Practicing Doctor' after treating the patient with body heat due to hypothermia force her to marry him due to that incident. Our vulnerable Riddhima first accused him of rape as she wasn't aware of the concept of body heat, thus complications rose for her. Not the other way your mentioned. Last but not the least, she chose to marry him in such a hurry, because as far as I recall, her father and Siddhanth had questioned her hasty decision but she decided to nod and smile thru the plan.
I do still buy the trauma explanation by aangelis....it seems the most appropriate in this case and doesn't let Armaan appear as a total jerk, so all's well.
PS- Armaan was a 'practicing' doctor, because when Siddhanth - Riddhima were tracking him down, they questioned a man regarding Amraan, and the man answered back with terms, 'Doctor Saahib?' So even when he lived in the woods, he apparently was still a doctor healing others, and just later 3 weeks he returned to Sanjeevani as a Practicing doctor. It also may be that everyone in the village referred to him as 'Doctor' due to his title but I'd believe my first assumption to support my points. It's not our fault though that the CVs take their audiences are mere morons.
Yup! Internet sure is a great source of information and so are books (actually better) that we use in schools which give us way more thorough information about things than on the internet. 😃 If you want I can list a few AMA related books here for reference too. 😉
Anyways...
Coming to the show... I was merely stating the medical and ethical aspect relating to The Hippocratic Oath. Whatever happened with KSG's entry, exit, CVs plans etc. is best known to KSG and the CVs. No matter how many articles or reports come out, we believe only what we choose to believe.
Why did Armaan leave an unconscious Riddhima? Were we shown anywhere in the show at that point that Armaan was "treating" patients? Just b/c a guy refers to Armaan as a "Doctor Sahib" doesn't tell us that he was treating them or was competent to treat people. Yes! he had the degree of a Doctor hence making him a doctor. I am sure you have been to India or Pakistan. Once a doctor or an engineer, people refer you with that title for life! But that's besides the point.
We were told however that he developed the strength to get better after he saw Ridz. So, since he had seen her with Sid, he knew she will be safe. We weren't told that Armaan knew Ridz got hypothermia. Shanky and Billy knew everything about Sid being there and so did Armaan.
BTW, psychological conditions are very tricky. A lot of these disorders depend on an individual's ability on how soon they can develop strength. The time frame between recovery and rock concerts maybe minimal, but that's the flaw in scripting.
The 'logical' reason as to why we weren't shown Armaan treating or attending to Ridz in teh show is quite simple... KSG wasn't in the show at that time. Whatever deal there was between them about KSG's return, the fact is that either they made teh story to play out like this from before or they didn't know if they could get KSG back. Who were they supposed to show helping her? His body double? That my dear is the flaw in the story and script writing.
All this has NOTHING to do with Armaan's ability to save Ridz from hypothermia and bringing The Hippocratic Oath in between.
CVs don't even care what the Oath is or says as long as they get their TRPs...
Hindi TV Shows
Web Series
CID
