145665 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#1
Dont u think guys vip and swapnil only do mimicry and acting and their punches r not strong enough.Even though if VIP wins and if he gets his seperate show like raju on star one ,he will only do mimincry or acting or what in his show.No one will watch his show.Shows like that doesn't require mimicry.Even i have seen many stage shows of shakeel and i have never seen that he is repeating his jokes except 4 few ,which is acceptable.But what about vip only doing mimicry i have never seen him performing as VIP but only as ashok kumar,nana patekar ,dharmendra,rakhi sawant and any other actors.I have read in one of the topic that shakeel is a comedian and he should be in this show.But all of them in this show are comedians only.And i have seen them in many different movies.According to me shakeel and urvashi shhd win.Because of his mimicry and acting he was out of comedy ka badsha hasega india(VIP).

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

1.1k

Users

9

Frequent Posters

Fashion_2005 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#2
completely agree with u 👏 i am so tired of vip mimicry 🤢
dilkiaawaz thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#3
no r u kidding. every body have choice to do their own style comedy. he is really good at it. ok for example if u r a nurse and u r job is to keep the patient ok. r u gonna get tired of it no right. than his job is to make people laugh and people do laugh when he do mimicury. so y should he stop it. sorry but i dont agree with u. and if my example was not that good enough than sorry about that too.
dr_bugs thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#4
mimicry is ok till one extent, after that it just gets annoying. no doubt that he is amazing at it but u cant jsut use it all the time and expect urself to go through to the finals. It was absolutely ridiculous on the July 28th episode where Swapnil forced him to continue on with his mimicry which made me cry of boredom. It was not funny.
ups1 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#5
well in that case u all are forgeting how swapnil did the 'rakhi sawant act' & the 'chakkas' act................they are the best...........shakeel is just repeating his old jokes that he has performed on the stage shows numerous times(he is so stale)........and karishma n her partner also don't offer anything new.........
145665 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: dilkiaawaz

no r u kidding. every body have choice to do their own style comedy. he is really good at it. ok for example if u r a nurse and u r job is to keep the patient ok. r u gonna get tired of it no right. than his job is to make people laugh and people do laugh when he do mimicury. so y should he stop it. sorry but i dont agree with u. and if my example was not that good enough than sorry about that too.


I don't think so because of vip mimicry most of the people laugh (including me).As u gave examlpe of the nurse its right but nurses do change their behavoiuos towards differnt patient.For ex-If there is a child patient the nurse treat the child as a child.Therefore nurses keep on changing their moods based on the patients attitude.And if the nurse is treating all the patients with the same kind of attitude i m sure the patients would hate her.(Just like VIP)
dilkiaawaz thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: ups1

well in that case u all are forgeting how swapnil did the 'rakhi sawant act' & the 'chakkas' act................they are the best...........shakeel is just repeating his old jokes that he has performed on the stage shows numerous times(he is so stale)........and karishma n her partner also don't offer anything new.........

so agree. well shakeel always fight with her partner with old jokes to make us laugh. i mean get something else. and karishma and khyali, they too talk about their height difference in every episode. those r whom i m tired of not swapnil and vip.

dilkiaawaz thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: maha786


I don't think so because of vip mimicry most of the people laugh (including me).As u gave examlpe of the nurse its right but nurses do change their behavoiuos towards differnt patient.For ex-If there is a child patient the nurse treat the child as a child.Therefore nurses keep on changing their moods based on the patients attitude.And if the nurse is treating all the patients with the same kind of attitude i m sure the patients would hate her.(Just like VIP)

kk as u said "nurse do change their behaviours towards differnet patient. for ex-If there is a child patient the nurse treat the child as a child." but vip have to do it for all at once. he cant just go to each person in audience and ask " hw would u like me to do the comedy" and the ex- i gave before of nurse i meant her main duty is to take care of all the patients. and VIP main duty is to make people laugh by doing mimicury.

umairdbest.18 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#9
I cant believe how you people can say that shakeel is performing with old jokes....ek baar jhonny lever ne kia kehdia tum log to peechay hi pargaey yaar....actually the problem is that you people dont understand shakeel jokes thts why you people say that he is saying old jokes....he is a professional comedian and he cant say old jokes...the proof is that the other team Ali Asghar and Kashif Khan are improving day by day and it is due to shakeel....as Ali Asghar said that he is now days under shakeel's training....so how can a guy train others with new jokes and perform himself with old jokes....and as far as VIP is concerned..his mimicry is very good but everything looks good in limited extent..i mean you have to versatile...so VIP has to perform different in order compete with others...
145665 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: umairdbest.18

I cant believe how you people can say that shakeel is performing with old jokes....ek baar jhonny lever ne kia kehdia tum log to peechay hi pargaey yaar....actually the problem is that you people dont understand shakeel jokes thts why you people say that he is saying old jokes....he is a professional comedian and he cant say old jokes...the proof is that the other team Ali Asghar and Kashif Khan are improving day by day and it is due to shakeel....as Ali Asghar said that he is now days under shakeel's training....so how can a guy train others with new jokes and perform himself with old jokes....and as far as VIP is concerned..his mimicry is very good but everything looks good in limited extent..i mean you have to versatile...so VIP has to perform different in order compete with others...


I completely agree with u.And the people who are telling that shakeel is telling old jokes.Till now thy din't prove.What are the old jokes and from which show(name them).,Cuz i have also seen many of his stage shows and i didn't find any old joke.Except 4 1 day.And VIP may be telling old jokes,as he is doing mimicry from 14 years on many stage shows.So know one actualy saw his video.Therefore who knoows he might be also using the same mimicry acts ,what he did on many stage shows.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".