TB: CID goes regional- starts Nov 12 pg 5

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Swapna Das

@goatg

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#51

aap log cid kolkata bureo dekh rahe ho kya?

Quote

SAGNIKA

@Shagnika

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#52

It just went out of my head ! 😡 I wanted to see it, it was the episode jiska shooting maine dekha tha ! Bhakk ! I forgot... Tab yaad aaya jab Deba di ka msg aaya at 11 🥱

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

deltadas

@deltadas

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#53

saw the first episode of cid kolkata bureau, dialogues were good, less action. The case is of a girl kidnap.

Quote

sania_58

@sania_58

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#54

CID Kolkata Bureau My Review,

Well, saw the First case, Impressive kuch nahin laga mujhe.Ordinary Storyline, upar se presentation bhi kuch khaas nahin hai.Dialogue to bohut hi ajeeb laga, Bengali main sunne main kaafi ajeeb lag raha tha, thoda poetry karke bhi bol rahe the,accha nahin lag raha tha, upar se ACP Vir Singha ka ek marte hue criminal ke samne yeh dialogue bolna "main tumhare payar(legs) padhta hoon bol do bacchi kaha hai" bohut zyada khatka.
Performances ki baat karu to ACP sirf woh hi mujhe thoda bohut accha laga.Ranojoy okay, woh Lady Officer bohut hi irritating tha, baaki bhi bilkul accha nahin laga. Side performances woh bhi bohut ghatiya tha. but Still, yeh First Episode tha kuch bhi assumption karna jaldi hoga.lekin mujhe doubt hai shayad CID Kolkata Bureau click nahin karega.
aur sab se baadi baat CID Kolkata Bureau CID Mumbai ki copy karke kyun banayi gaayi hai???? jab bhi dekk rahi hoon main mujhe CID mumbai ki kuch features dikh rahe hai, & of course yeh log uss level ko match nahin kar paa rahe hai.

Quote

SAGNIKA

@Shagnika

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#55

Originally posted by: sania_58
CID Kolkata Bureau My Review,

Well, saw the First case, Impressive kuch nahin laga mujhe.Ordinary Storyline, upar se presentation bhi kuch khaas nahin hai.Dialogue to bohut hi ajeeb laga, Bengali main sunne main kaafi ajeeb lag raha tha, thoda poetry karke bhi bol rahe the,accha nahin lag raha tha, upar se ACP Vir Singha ka ek marte hue criminal ke samne yeh dialogue bolna "main tumhare payar(legs) padhta hoon bol do bacchi kaha hai" bohut zyada khatka.
Performances ki baat karu to ACP sirf woh hi mujhe thoda bohut accha laga.Ranojoy okay, woh Lady Officer bohut hi irritating tha, baaki bhi bilkul accha nahin laga. Side performances woh bhi bohut ghatiya tha. but Still, yeh First Episode tha kuch bhi assumption karna jaldi hoga.lekin mujhe doubt hai shayad CID Kolkata Bureau click nahin karega.
aur sab se baadi baat CID Kolkata Bureau CID Mumbai ki copy karke kyun banayi gaayi hai???? jab bhi dekk rahi hoon main mujhe CID mumbai ki kuch features dikh rahe hai, & of course yeh log uss level ko match nahin kar paa rahe hai.

They havent actually copied it... Its after all the same people making it. The style remains the same thats why 😆 As far as the dialogues are concerned, I agree it was sounding odd at times. It seemed as if kisine translate kar diya ho Hindi to bengali ! 🥱 The comedy scenes in the forensic lab were added forcibly... although I kind of liked the doc ! Their cast is a big negative point. Other than ACP no one is really an established actor... and not even good at acting it seems. Lets see how it goes...

Quote

tusu

@tusu

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#56

being a bong, i was really excited about the cid kolkata bureo but after watching the first episode i really feel disappointed. diolouges were too wired and it was sound like they didn'y reharse before the shooting

Quote

DEEPIKA BANERJEE

@deepikabanerjee

Rocker

Posted: 12 years ago

#57

This was expected...They are trying to replicate Mumbai CID in Kolkata. BP Singh should find some local directors and try to create a scenario which matches Kolkata.

Quote

441597

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#58

The worst part of it were the dialogues and the carbon-copied facial expressions of the officers. Horribly artificial and piled-on. I hope the PH shakes off its Mumbai hangover as soon as possible or else this'll go off air in less than four months.

Quote

visrom

@visrom

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

#59

I am not sure what you all think about this...I saw part of last night's Bong CID. I didn't understand much...but I didn't find them trying to imitate Hindi CID or anything...maybe because I didn't understand much of the dialogues. 😆 I couldn't even grasp the names of the characters. 🤣 I could find the equivalent of Kajal...from the lady cop's attire.

It was actually a nice story...a chori, a murder and a kidnap...and something to do with a witness protection programme. I don't think they have made such intelligent stories in the near past in Hindi CID.

I think the present Hindi writers should be sacked immediately and they should remake the bong episodes in Hindi.

I also noticed the normal middle class set up where the victims were living...not in posh bungalows. I loved that. It reminded me of the Asha era...or maybe the Aditi era. This was the best part.

The lady whose daughter was kidnapped was wearing a plain white saree with less make-up and jewellery...unlike Hindi CID where they'll come dressed as if they are going to a party...when the daughter is kidnapped.

Edited by visrom - 12 years ago

Quote

tusu

@tusu

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#60

but don't u think that the character of acp in bengali is wired. woh bade hi asani se criminal ke samne bhi hath jod lete hai aur lagta hai ki ronojoy ke siba unhe koi dikhta hi nahi hai. 😕