If the news about ChCh Under SCANNER is true...

Koeli thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Well what can i say...

honestly very honestly i dont see any interesting element in the show... the show was promised to be something else and we got something else. Before any mis understanding happens i would like to say... the show was promised to be khoobsurat if i am not wrong... If you guys havent seen that movie i would suggest go and watch it... ChCh is not even 1% of khoosurat.

Khubsoorat had right amount of drama, comedy and light hearted romance between the leads. even thought it was more of a comedy movie but still i loved the cute romance between rekha ji and rakesh roshan.

Coming back to CC honestly i didnot see any khubsoorat element till date.

Even the romance before building it up they rushed to few things which we would have loved to see gradually. Suddenly there was a change of characterization in manav... from a chirpy teeny guy he was suddenly portryaed as a matured husband. I understand there was a change in actor but still there should have been some similarities between manav then and manav now... it was absolutely lack of script and horrible direction.

Sanaya was not given any scope to perform as per her caliber. And Supriya ji was wasted showing a grey character. She is just too much grey. Honestly now a days we have many shows like chhanchhan which are executed well.

I think there is a huge fault in the back end team rather than actors as they have been wrong from the very beginning... There was no umph factor no special element. the subject was too predictable and those which were not predictable was horribly executed.

The very first thing which went wrong was the choice of male lead against sanaya. I am not critisizing him though, it is a directors job to look after the minus and the plus points. but putting him against such a seasoned actresses like sanaya and supriya ji was a nose drop.

When anuj was taken in the group suddenly the whole character was changed. I wonder why? Anuj has so much potential in him that he could have easily done happy go lucky guy role instead of a matured husband. I would have loved to see his Manav's faults initially then gradually he would have changed.

Coming to sanaya's character, even it was changed drastically. Where is that challanging girl? it is lost somewhere and she is portrayed as a stupid bahu (think about it before bashing for this line) she is modern, she is educated still she cannot understand the complexities of uma ben? its hardly believable.

There is no direct fight between uma ben and chhanchhan, every thing is done peet peechy... and ultimately neither MIL nor SIL wins... its weird.

Even Uma Ben's character has changed.

Honestly very honestly... no matter i love to see chanman romancing... but sigh! there is nothing else to show in the serial other than both of them romancing time to time... i wonder till how long they will be able to pull it off.

Very sad indeed.

I have kept on telling time to time whenever i have posted in this forum that the script needs to improve no matter now many good actors you have in your basket you need good story, script and direction for make a show last long.

~ Thanks Koeli

P.S. Its a request please let us discuss the matter rather than fight... we are different individual our views are bound to vary... i would respect it if this thread remains peaceful.
Edited by appy_indy-KD - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

35

Views

4.1k

Users

20

Likes

130

Frequent Posters

Anamika100 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
You have articulated this so well. I too have seen and loved that movie with Dina Pathak, Rekha and Rakesh Roshan.

In the movie, they did not marry the leads ...in fact I do not think they showed the wedding but it was such a refreshing frothy fun movie with a social message that was well developed and the Rakesh Roshan role was a doctor so he had a responsible job but he and Rekha character kept playing pranks on each other and then moved into romance...very cute.

In CC...I felt like I was on Disney space mountain...with the speed from happy go lucky young people meet, get attracted ...to rush into marriage in a week and then evil saas and brave bahu crap starts. In that genre, there are much better shows on SP.

Anyone who has common sense can not buy the viability of this show.

The sad part is that they are wasting SI and Supriyaji's talent. Manav character did suddenly become too serious and no matter how many rain drenched scenes they do, it does not make up for lack of story. IF there is no story to tell...the show will be history.
Edited by Anamika100 - 12 years ago
Koeli thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Anamika100

You have articulated this so well. I too have seen and loved that movie with Dina Pathak, Rekha and Rakesh Roshan.


In the movie, they did not marry the leads ...in fact I do not think they showed the wedding but it was such a refreshing frothy fun movie with a social message that was well developed and the Rakesh Roshan role was a doctor so he had a responsible job but he and Rekha character kept playing pranks on each other and then moved into romance...very cute.

In CC...I felt like I was on Disney space mountain...with the speed from happy go lucky young people meet, get attracted ...to rush into marriage in a week and then evil saas and brave bahu crap starts. In that genre, there are much better shows on SP.

Anyone who has common sense can not buy the viability of this show.

The sad part is that they are wasting SI and Supriyaji's talent. Manav character did suddenly become too serious and no matter how many rain drenched scenes they do, it does not make up for lack of story. IF there is no story to tell...the show will be history.


honestly it is not at all working for me... good to see chhanman thought but if the romance is stretched beyond limits i am sure the elastic will break... so honestly i dont have any hope in the show anymore.. was excited about the new lead initially and they showed it pretty well that time... but later it was again same old ghisa pita drama... with few romantic scenes here and there.
hira_arnie thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
Totally agree with u Appy
Great post...👏
Barun_Fever thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Wow you have really put it together👏👏
I agree with you
Chahchan was supposed to be smart and today's girl but I don't see it, she is shown dumb as all 3 other bahus..specially she knows how umaben was in past..so not once that thought cross her mind..
and Manavs character also I agree that changed drastically form irresponsible n childish to mature overnight with actor replacement..

Most ppl won't agree with you here because many thinks that if you love Sanaya you only have to praise her n her shows, n can't be stating facts
If you do you instantly become sanaya hater.

edited
Edited by Sano88 - 12 years ago
Anamika100 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Barun_Fever

Wow you have really put it together👏👏
I agree with you
Chahchan was supposed to be smart and today's girl but I don't see it, she is shown dumb as all 3 other bahus..specially she knows how umaben was in past..so not once that thought cross her mind..
and Manavs character also I agree that changed drastically form irresponsible n childish to mature overnight with actor replacement..

Most ppl won't agree with you here because many thinks that if you love Sanaya you only have to praise her n her shows, n can't be stating facts
If you do you instantly become sanaya hater, so just warning you :) but I hope ppl respond in mature way n not act like blind fans


So true. Even the same people who are calling for constructive criticism so quickly degenrate into name calling that most posts get closed.
.Brooke. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
Could not agree more Appy.

My disappointment with CC is only because of this

fact that they did not deliver what they promised

with viewers at the launch of the show.

Everything is so out of place in CC that could not

connect with any character.

In today episode CC the modern,independent,professional

girl accepted all the punishments and insults like other DILs

of Borisagher family.


Lifeistooshort thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
i agree to what you say yar!! even i made a post today saying umaben is too grey..and for a girl like chanchan i don understand how she still cant figure out her MIL's SUgar coated words!! and yeah manav is shown a bit too matured now!! but still and he knows what his mom is capable off.. like he saw her mess with purvi's wedding and with chanchan with her tablets drama and he believed her blindly when she said i think of her as a daughter and she does not!!! that was too weird!!
the show was to be modern bahu and the conflicts between a todays girl and a traditional mentality!!but uma ben is almost been shown like a vamp and she herself is like a DON controlling her house more than following traditions!! and trying to get them sepertaed and fixing a girl well before...

and no direct conflicts either which is what is being the most expected as they started well on ahigh note with umaben and chanchan clashing straight away!!! i wish we could see something like that!!

but yeah anuj is doing a fabulous job!! i adore his work as manav!! chanman makes me watch the show!! but yeah he was expected to be a promising supportive husband and yes he is! that is lovely to see!!!

i hope they spice the story more in a healthy way!!

ipkkndfan21 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
You have mentioned every thing, totally agree with you 😊
dhindsa_raji thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
I totally agree with the post.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".