I knew I loved IF for a reason. Do you know you are the first people to agree that maybe KKHH wasn't so 'brilliant'. No doubt the force of SRK and Kajol was electrifying but the characterizations and the plot. Divya I agree with every sentiment of yours. See, i told you we are more alike in substance than form. :P
For me after amnesia tracks I hate stories where the girl for a guy, pines over him, the idiot, suffers and cries and after a lot of commotion, as a reward, she 'gets' the idiot! This irks me to the point of insanity! KKHH being the most famous, but then I just watch HDDCS and I begin to feel so much better!
DDLJ is a classic, again agreeing with your points Divya. However due to the limitations of film, I feel that there was so much more that could have been explored in terms of East meets West cultures and manners. DMG did a wonderful job of bringing to the front those issues that plague many today, with Sidma but killed that off for just the offensive!
My top Aamir films, in terms of his acting would be Ghajini, for he played a more subdued character than before and just shone! Rang de basanti where he was just a star, 'yeh hindi jaante hai!' Classic. Dil chahta hai for his natural 'confidence' NOT arrogance becoming! Rangeela again for that 'innocent' masti (that banana scene, that police scene, that heartbreak small ring) and Taare zammen pe for just fine acting!
In terms of films overall, probably the same again, but I would add, Andaz apna apna, Lagaan, and 3 idiots.
I don't think Aamir boycotted for that reason. Personally he seemed uncomfortable with the whole notion of 'awards' and publicity on the whole, so that when he did not get them anyway, he maybe thought well they won't miss me anyway, so I won't offend anyone if I don't attend. Just my opinion of him. As I said he is Guru Dutt' heir more than Dilip Kumar, that their legacy are those characterizations and films that we carry in our affected hearts as opposed to an awe inspiring body of work that leaves its mark in film history. It is wanting to mark a change within people rather than leave a mark in the world, in that way inciting revelations within people, so that slowly, eventually they result in revolutions in the world. They may not be 'remembered' but their actions' consequences and intentions live on regardless.
That is how I see it. An actor as an entertaining artist rather than an actor as an entertainer alone.
The difference is subtle but significant for me and in my opinion the world.
Love Sabah