Chandra Nandini 86-90: Sylvan idyll - Page 25

Created

Last reply

Replies

344

Views

24.1k

Users

28

Likes

1.3k

Frequent Posters

loveislife1991 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
Been a week since I visited the forum, been busy, will catch up with the stuff going on in a while, but drom what I can see, Aunty and Shailaja thought the crying scene was OTT. Thank God , the two of you pointed this out, I felt the exact same way, but thought I wont say this aloud otherwise RT fanatics will jump on me 😆.
Although, I think why they showed Nandini insisting on Chandra tk cry, was a way to let him go of his inhibitions. Because he has never ever opened up or shown his vulnerability to anyone before, not even to himself. And today his emotions stand naked in front of Nandini which is hard for himself to believe. I liked the concept of that scene, esp the way Tear thing was shown in slow motion, but I would have preferred if left out the HRIDAY dialogue again. Also, at this tragic moment there was a faint smile on Nandini s face discovering Hriday of chandra. That was totally inappropriate. A mother lost her child, abhi Hriday ki padi hai.😕
Also, regarding Durdhara s over reaction about Nandini in the promo, I feel, Durdhara has witnessed Rupa pushing Chhaya from the stairs, which probably she will recount in today s episode thinking that was Nandini, hence she is blaming Nandini for the poison. Also, I agree with someone (Amina?) who said Rupa will come out and say she is the real one while Nandini is is the fake one.(How long will this go on?😡)
But hopefully, as soon as CGM interacts with Rupa, some discrepancy with pustak or something will happen, CGM will discover the real truth and save Nandini before she dies in the wall.
But let's see how much more CVs stretch this track
sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
My dear Pratiksha,

First of all, I am sorry I have not responded to your warm comment at the beginning of this thread. I was worn out after doing the post, and was then creeping backwards with my responses, from the end, that is. I got to page 3 or so when my hand began stiffening again, and I could not complete them for you and a few others. But I appreciated your post a lot.

Here, it is not just me and Shailaja who did not like that lachrymose scene, but also, and most vigorously of all, Sandhya, and we are all three great admirers of Rajat - the two of them in the fan category (not fanatics, my dear, not on my threads at least!) and me in that of an objective analyst, though I am very fond of him and proud of him.

I did not object to the idea of a man crying. Nor is it Breaking News that Chandragupta Maurya was crying. He has done it several times already, as Sandhya has pointed out. And as Jalal weeping and praying for a dying Jodha he was gut wrenchingly magnificent. Only, he did those scenes much, much better, even when he let go completely.

Here, one could not make out what he was saying most of the time, and the whole performance was unnecessarily OTT. Also, the reason - that he was blaming himself for not having protected Chhaya and her baby was ludicrous, to say the least. So I found it all very irritating. And all this to prove - to whom, pray? - that Chandra has a hriday. 😡 I only wish he had a bit more of functioning cerebral matter!

Finally, as I have pointed out last night, there is NO way Roopa can carry it off even for a day as Nandini. That is a non-starter.

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: loveislife1991

Been a week since I visited the forum, been busy, will catch up with the stuff going on in a while, but drom what I can see, Aunty and Shailaja thought the crying scene was OTT. Thank God , the two of you pointed this out, I felt the exact same way, but thought I wont say this aloud otherwise RT fanatics will jump on me 😆.

Although, I think why they showed Nandini insisting on Chandra tk cry, was a way to let him go of his inhibitions. Because he has never ever opened up or shown his vulnerability to anyone before, not even to himself. And today his emotions stand naked in front of Nandini which is hard for himself to believe. I liked the concept of that scene, esp the way Tear thing was shown in slow motion, but I would have preferred if left out the HRIDAY dialogue again. Also, at this tragic moment there was a faint smile on Nandini s face discovering Hriday of chandra. That was totally inappropriate. A mother lost her child, abhi Hriday ki padi hai.😕
Also, regarding Durdhara s over reaction about Nandini in the promo, I feel, Durdhara has witnessed Rupa pushing Chhaya from the stairs, which probably she will recount in today s episode thinking that was Nandini, hence she is blaming Nandini for the poison.
Also, I agree with someone (Amina?) who said Rupa will come out and say she is the real one while Nandini is is the fake one.(How long will this go on?😡)
But hopefully, as soon as CGM interacts with Rupa, some discrepancy with pustak or something will happen, CGM will discover the real truth and save Nandini before she dies in the wall.
But let's see how much more CVs stretch this track

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
Never mind, my dear Sarika, there has got to be something, occasionally, on which you and I do not see eye to eye!😉

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: skamunugama

Yes, crying is not prohibited for men, if they want they can and they will. After watching yesterday's crying scene again I could not find anything unbearable except the last 15 second self talking scene of Chandra as Aunty mentioned.If they could have skip that tiny self talking dialog entire scene would be meaning full.
She asked him not to cry like king but to cry as a brother and let all the dissimulated sorrow and agony to be flattened. So he yowls, as he too wanted to, by letting himself being just as a normal boy.
Exploiting Chandra's heart through his tears and the hidden happiness of that constant invention was shown in nadini's slightly summon up smile at the end. That was ok for her but showing chandra discovering his own heart at that moment was unnecessary.

Even today I could hear a perfect voice modulation of Rajat right at the moment he calls unconscious chaya. But he coudn't convey that through out the crying scene may be because he was crying, indeed :)

sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
But he has never spent any solid amount of time with Roopa, whether here or in Pataalgram. Once she is seen to be unable to read those books of Nandini's, the cat will be out of the bag. Let us see how they close this can of worms.

One more thing, my dear. I am very old fashioned, and my threads are generally G rated, or PG-12 at the most. My legion of nieces and nephews here know that, and out of regard from my sensibilities, they avoid the kind of language that does not sit well with me. Of course I cannot compel you to do likewise, since this, including my threads, is a free forum, but if you could keep this point in mind for the future, I would appreciate it a lot.

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: .Avengers.

How can he be exposed just like that when from ages nandini is switching between good Adarsh DIL and the lusty girl who has big nails and after Malay/Chandra. She was named worse, did worse things yet somehow Chandra went past it. I agree with roopas characterization. She is wild and not plotter like say Helena or that parental woman of her (I am rubbish with names). Maybe she can join her and both can pull this off. If she wants Chandra she needs to get rid of Helena as well cz she's also a strong contender. The problem is roopas horny type expressions around Chandra. Maybe he will chalk it up to some woman issues or real loou😛


Last scene well same rehash. Nandini wanting to see his hriday and boy did he show some with the crying. Of course the trademark questioning of how can chanakya be wrong since he does have feelings. Duh. I think C should have been clearer in childhood that he needs to say away from his wife or lover, not the feeling of affection or love towards his rest of family. Just the woman he would have sex and make kids😆 btw is it me or rajats biceps looks like they were shot up with hormones??? How did he go so big?


Lmao durdharas death. Yu know what if she came to know about roopa and it was her who was pushed down staircase it would have made sense. Chaya could overtake whole anti nandni squad but coming from.durdhara who defended Nandini that she could never have feelings for Malay ...Ugh it didn't feel right.

sp108 thumbnail
Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
Aunty, about yesterday's scene I sort of agree with you. It started off fine. But midway I couldn't get Rajat's dialogues, even on a repeat viewing he seemed to be swallowing all the words and was in a blubbering mess at the end of it. And I got too irritated by the end of the scene when both of them realise that Chandra has a heart. They clearly weren't taught science 😡.
The one part I liked is when Nandini pulled him close. And also the forgiveness scene in the beginning of the episode.
The story is really going nowhere, not that it has made any sense after the grand wedding. Roopa and Malayketu couldn't really create any huge misunderstanding between Chandra-Nandini. So I don't understand the point of all these misunderstandings or even these characters. And Chandra-Nandini are hardly bothered about these misunderstandings. They seem to be living in some other world. Yet I don't seem to be giving up on watching this show 😆
shailusri1983 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: loveislife1991

Been a week since I visited the forum, been busy, will catch up with the stuff going on in a while, but drom what I can see, Aunty and Shailaja thought the crying scene was OTT. Thank God , the two of you pointed this out, I felt the exact same way, but thought I wont say this aloud otherwise RT fanatics will jump on me 😆.

Although, I think why they showed Nandini insisting on Chandra tk cry, was a way to let him go of his inhibitions. Because he has never ever opened up or shown his vulnerability to anyone before, not even to himself. And today his emotions stand naked in front of Nandini which is hard for himself to believe. I liked the concept of that scene, esp the way Tear thing was shown in slow motion, but I would have preferred if left out the HRIDAY dialogue again. Also, at this tragic moment there was a faint smile on Nandini s face discovering Hriday of chandra. That was totally inappropriate. A mother lost her child, abhi Hriday ki padi hai.😕
Also, regarding Durdhara s over reaction about Nandini in the promo, I feel, Durdhara has witnessed Rupa pushing Chhaya from the stairs, which probably she will recount in today s episode thinking that was Nandini, hence she is blaming Nandini for the poison. Also, I agree with someone (Amina?) who said Rupa will come out and say she is the real one while Nandini is is the fake one.(How long will this go on?😡)
But hopefully, as soon as CGM interacts with Rupa, some discrepancy with pustak or something will happen, CGM will discover the real truth and save Nandini before she dies in the wall.
But let's see how much more CVs stretch this track

Big surprise, isn't it Pratiksha? It rarely happens that I criticize Rajat or his acting. This was wholly not Rajat's folly either. The dialogues, the way the scene was shot, a very desperate attempt was made to din in without even an iota of doubt which anybody might harbor regarding Nandini's initiative in helping Chandra find his missing Hriday.

The scene would have definitely worked better if it had been understated, with minimum dialogues, sans this excessive encouragement and cheerleading by Nandini asking him to cry. The chap was anyhow going to bawl where was the need for her to urge him cry, cry, you will feel better.

In my opinion, Rajat should have spoken very less, his face a picture of absolute shock, incomprehension, a numbness, disbelief, inability to come to terms with the reality, etc. And as for Nandini, she shouldn't have spoken much except perhaps holding his hands in hers and allowing him to speak if he was willing to speak, if not, just be there for him in his testing times.

The dialogues should have been more on the lines of "I just can't believe this happened! Just a while back the baby was fine, my sister was hale and healthy. Now her baby is no more and my sister. (He could cry a bit at this point before continuing) For all my power, I am helpless."

This dialogue had to stop here. I just could not imagine why Chandra had to go on and on that everybody would laugh at Magadh Naresh that he could not take care of his sister properly or save her baby. I am a bad brother and stuff. It was an accident or so everybody thinks. He isn't going to get a dream that Chaaya will have a fall and he is going to stand beside with nets ready to catch her if she falls, and smelling salts ever ready in his pocket if she faints.

Edited by shailusri1983 - 8 years ago
sashashyam thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
@blue.😆😆😆

Shyamala Aunty

Originally posted by: shailusri1983

Big surprise, isn't it Pratiksha? It rarely happens that I criticize Rajat or his acting. This was wholly not Rajat's folly either. The dialogues, the way the scene was shot, a very desperate attempt was made to din in without even an iota of doubt which anybody might harbor regarding Nandini's initiative in helping Chandra find his missing Hriday.

The scene would have definitely worked better if it had been understated, with minimum dialogues, sans this excessive encouragement and cheerleading by Nandini asking him to cry. The chap was anyhow going to bawl where was the need for her to urge him cry, cry, you will feel better.

In my opinion, Rajat should have spoken very less, his face a picture of absolute shock, incomprehension, a numbness, disbelief, inability to come to terms with the reality, etc. And as for Nandini, she shouldn't have spoken much except perhaps holding his hands in hers and allowing him to speak if he was willing to speak, if not, just be there for him in his testing times.

The dialogues should have been more on the lines of "I just can't believe this happened! Just a while back the baby was fine, my sister was hale and healthy. Now her baby is no more and my sister. (He could cry a bit at this point before continuing) For all my power, I am helpless."

This dialogue had to stop here. I just could not imagine why Chandra had to go on and on that everybody would laugh at Magadh Naresh that he could not take care of his sister properly or save her baby. I am a bad brother and stuff. It was an accident or so everybody thinks. He isn't going to get a dream that Chaaya will have a fall and he is going to stand beside with nets ready to catch her if she falls, and smelling salts ever ready in his pocket if she has

loveislife1991 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
Aunty, you taking the time to respond to us here is itself great motivation. And your takes on the episodes actually lifts the standard of the serial we all are watching. Esp. with your health So one post being left out is anyways a non-issue.😊
I have just gone through 2 last pages in this thread so didn't know about Sandhya also finding the scene OTT. And aunty, never called you and Shailaja fanatic, you guys are too mature for that, but there are few I have come across😉. But frankly, in front of my husband even I act like one when he cribs about me watching CN😉. But my continuous trust in RT irrespective of the material , has converted even him into a regular watcher.😆
And I agree on this, using the same dialogues as JA - DIL to Hriday is getting quite on the nerves. Now that they have realised he has one, be done with it and stop with the drama😡.
As far as Rupa posing as Nandini is concerned, I guess that charade is possible for some hours ,till Pustaken come into th e picture but then in the footage Chandra was getting Nandini walled as Nandini and not as Rupa. So I guess that plot is out of the window. The only silver lining is heroine cannot die so, the truth will be out relatively soon(may be within next week) after she is walled. Unless Nand's people have some plan hatched to get her out from some soorang hence stretching this more.😡

Originally posted by: sashashyam

My dear Pratiksha,

First of all, I am sorry I have not responded to your warm comment at the beginning of this thread. I was worn out after doing the post, and was then creeping backwards with my responses, from the end, that is. I got to page 3 or so when my hand began stiffening again, and I could not complete them for you and a few others. But I appreciated your post a lot.

Here, it is not just me and Shailaja who did not like that lachrymose scene, but also, and most vigorously of all, Sandhya, and we are all three great admirers of Rajat - the two of them in the fan category (not fanatics, my dear, not on my threads at least!) and me in that of an objective analyst, though I am very fond of him and proud of him.

I did not object to the idea of a man crying. Nor is it Breaking News that Chandragupta Maurya was crying. He has done it several times already, as Sandhya has pointed out. And as Jalal weeping and praying for a dying Jodha he was gut wrenchingly magnificent. Only, he did those scenes much, much better, even when he let go completely.

Here, one could not make out what he was saying most of the time, and the whole performance was unnecessarily OTT. Also, the reason - that he was blaming himself for not having protected Chhaya and her baby was ludicrous, to say the least. So I found it all very irritating. And all this to prove - to whom, pray? - that Chandra has a hriday. 😡 I only wish he had a bit more of functioning cerebral matter!

Finally, as I have pointed out last night, there is NO way Roopa can carry it off even for a day as Nandini. That is a non-starter.

Shyamala Aunty

Edited by loveislife1991 - 8 years ago
loveislife1991 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
The scene as suggested by you is perfect for the situation actually. Unfortunately, if the CVs were as talented and creative as you are, this would not have been a Balaji serial.😊

Originally posted by: shailusri1983


The scene would have definitely worked better if it had been understated, with minimum dialogues, sans this excessive encouragement and cheerleading by Nandini asking him to cry. The chap was anyhow going to bawl where was the need for her to urge him cry, cry, you will feel better.

In my opinion, Rajat should have spoken very less, his face a picture of absolute shock, incomprehension, a numbness, disbelief, inability to come to terms with the reality, etc. And as for Nandini, she shouldn't have spoken much except perhaps holding his hands in hers and allowing him to speak if he was willing to speak, if not, just be there for him in his testing times.

The dialogues should have been more on the lines of "I just can't believe this happened! Just a while back the baby was fine, my sister was hale and healthy. Now her baby is no more and my sister. (He could cry a bit at this point before continuing) For all my power, I am helpless."


This was hilarious 🤣 🤣 🤣

Originally posted by: shailusri1983


He isn't going to get a dream that Chaaya will have a fall and he is going to stand beside with nets ready to catch her if she falls, and smelling salts ever ready in his pocket if she faints.

Sandhya.A thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: shailusri1983

Big surprise, isn't it Pratiksha? It rarely happens that I criticize Rajat or his acting. This was wholly not Rajat's folly either. The dialogues, the way the scene was shot, a very desperate attempt was made to din in without even an iota of doubt which anybody might harbor regarding Nandini's initiative in helping Chandra find his missing Hriday.

Rajat too was much below than his usual self. He is quite adept at overcoming the flaws in the script. But here his expressions were a big let down too. Esp in the closing shot where he looked like Alice who had just seen the talking white rabbit take a watch out of his pockets. And he was bawling like a kid who had lost his bubblegum than an Emperor who was on the verge of losing a sister.

The scene would have definitely worked better if it had been understated, with minimum dialogues, sans this excessive encouragement and cheerleading by Nandini asking him to cry. The chap was anyhow going to bawl where was the need for her to urge him cry, cry, you will feel better.

Mere samaksh tum ro sakte ho...really...he weeps everybody's samaksh.😡 it was such a out of tune dialogue.

The dialogues should have been more on the lines of "I just can't believe this happened! Just a while back the baby was fine, my sister was hale and healthy. Now her baby is no more and my sister. (He could cry a bit at this point before continuing) For all my power, I am helpless."

Exactly.

This dialogue had to stop here. I just could not imagine why Chandra had to go on and on that everybody would laugh at Magadh Naresh that he could not take care of his sister properly or save her baby. I am a bad brother and stuff. It was an accident or so everybody thinks. He isn't going to get a dream that Chaaya will have a fall and he is going to stand beside with nets ready to catch her if she falls, and smelling salts ever ready in his pocket if she faints.

😆

But he had to ensure that he had deployed enough daas daasis around the expecting women. And here Dhurdhara who is carrying the heir to the throne, is running around all by herself like that rabbit in Alice in Wonderland, with none to attend her and the senior ladies are busy in playing cupids between Chandra and Nandini.😡 Even after the mishap he doesn't order that Dhurdhara be surrounded by black cats and bouncers. He is least bothered about her whereabouts and is busy weeping over Nandini and crying 'Eureka! My hriday is here'. The very agony of the situation was sort of ridiculed by this 'i have a heart' discovery.

Even Chanakya has not stressed on Durdhara's safety. The entire Magadh Madhouse has only one objective - fevicoling Chandra and Nandini 24*7. Whence the Mukhya Maharani rules. Won't these dullheads think on how else to save Chanakya putri if not by bartering Nandini. Instead Chandra is overwhelmed with the necessity to apologize to Nandini. What did Chanakya get Nandini married to Chandra if not use her as a trump card in dealing with Nand??

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".