Macedonian Queen writes Hindi ??

AshtaVasus thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
Helena wrote letter in impeccable Hindi (even though she speaks certain Urdu / Mughal words) to Malay in the name of Nandini.
It is assumable that Helena, out of possessiveness and love for chandra, learnt to speak, read and write Hindi.

But Aparna the Macedonian Queen, writing letter to Malay on behalf of Nandini - in Hindi ?? and without any spelling mistake ?? with good handwriting ?? and read aloud by Chandra to Nandini ??

Hell, Aparna wasnt even in India when her daughter got married to Chandra. And she learnt to write Hindi in a few visits to India ? Amazing !!

Created

Last reply

Replies

4

Views

985

Users

5

Likes

11

Frequent Posters

Shobhna23 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
EK vamps are so talented! They can do anything! Superwomaniya 🤣
immaawesome thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3
Well good point!😆

But many people are there who likes to have knowledge about various languages. If some foreigner wants to rule here then they must know how to communicate with the commoners which includes reading and writing. Kind of the reason why they are showing Helena and Aparna to have an accent.



Originally posted by: rajatshweta

Helena wrote letter in impeccable Hindi (even though she speaks certain Urdu / Mughal words) to Malay in the name of Nandini.
It is assumable that Helena, out of possessiveness and love for chandra, learnt to speak, read and write Hindi.

But Aparna the Macedonian Queen, writing letter to Malay on behalf of Nandini - in Hindi ?? and without any spelling mistake ?? with good handwriting ?? and read aloud by Chandra to Nandini ??

Hell, Aparna wasnt even in India when her daughter got married to Chandra. And she learnt to write Hindi in a few visits to India ? Amazing !!

Vr15h thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 8 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: rajatshweta

Helena wrote letter in impeccable Hindi (even though she speaks certain Urdu / Mughal words) to Malay in the name of Nandini.
It is assumable that Helena, out of possessiveness and love for chandra, learnt to speak, read and write Hindi.

But Aparna the Macedonian Queen, writing letter to Malay on behalf of Nandini - in Hindi ?? and without any spelling mistake ?? with good handwriting ?? and read aloud by Chandra to Nandini ??

Hell, Aparna wasnt even in India when her daughter got married to Chandra. And she learnt to write Hindi in a few visits to India ? Amazing !!



Is Aparna what they are calling her in this serial? It would make sense, since her marriage and conversion would have resulted in a cultural transformation.

We discuss the actual history of the people involved in this thread


One of the things that came out is that she did learn Sanskrit and the classical Indian arts

One of my real beef w/ most of these serials these days is that they make no effort to go shudh Hindi, which is why you result w/ Urdu words being used, which is really anachronistic. Like Alexander would never have been called 'Iskander' or 'Sikander' in any of the prevailent Indian languages then - be it Sanskrit, Prakrit or anything else around at the time, yet one sees it being used. Also, it's not clear that Devanagiri was the script of choice by then to write Sanskrit or other languages - maybe it was. But it is jarring when they use Urdu or Mughal terms.

If the real Helena had indeed been this devious, then she would have had one of her maids write this for her, so that no such error would have happened. And one would think that she'd have Nandini's handwriting pat down either herself, or by the maid.

In the above thread, we point out that not only was the 'Nandini' character fictional, but that Helena wouldn't have had the scope to plot against anybody. After she married, it wasn't too long before Chandragupta abdicated and went south and became a Jain. While she did dedicate her life to learning about Magadhan culture, that would not have given her a scope to do all this.

It's also hard to believe that such operations would have happened w/ Chanakya - one of the ultimate Machiavellian schemers - in the picture
ANNA90ALEX thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: .Vrish.



Is Aparna what they are calling her in this serial? It would make sense, since her marriage and conversion would have resulted in a cultural transformation.

We discuss the actual history of the people involved in this thread


One of the things that came out is that she did learn Sanskrit and the classical Indian arts

One of my real beef w/ most of these serials these days is that they make no effort to go shudh Hindi, which is why you result w/ Urdu words being used, which is really anachronistic. Like Alexander would never have been called 'Iskander' or 'Sikander' in any of the prevailent Indian languages then - be it Sanskrit, Prakrit or anything else around at the time, yet one sees it being used. Also, it's not clear that Devanagiri was the script of choice by then to write Sanskrit or other languages - maybe it was. But it is jarring when they use Urdu or Mughal terms.

If the real Helena had indeed been this devious, then she would have had one of her maids write this for her, so that no such error would have happened. And one would think that she'd have Nandini's handwriting pat down either herself, or by the maid.

In the above thread, we point out that not only was the 'Nandini' character fictional, but that Helena wouldn't have had the scope to plot against anybody. After she married, it wasn't too long before Chandragupta abdicated and went south and became a Jain. While she did dedicate her life to learning about Magadhan culture, that would not have given her a scope to do all this.

It's also hard to believe that such operations would have happened w/ Chanakya - one of the ultimate Machiavellian schemers - in the picture


Seriously.. They just want Trp so they butcher up History as they like it.. I really don't get it how Roopa could walk freely in the palace and Chandra even got that nail difderence btw two of them but he doesnt even want to think about it.. Is he really a samrat.. A samrat would have sharp knowledge about whats happening around the palace.. its just that he cant even control his home.. how he is going to rule the people.. More over everything happens in front of watchful eyes of the great Chanakya.. i really hope those younger ones who watches this crap in the name of history of india will engulf all this without knowing the actual history of India..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".