Was Nakul at fault? (Badhaai ho) - Page 3

Originally posted by: Paachaa

Why should one apologize or beg for forgiveness for something said in private? It is Renee's mother who said this who anyways had a problem with her dating Nakul. She never said all those bitter words to Nakul or his family to shame them. It was a private conversation between a mother and a daughter in their home. You can't stop someone from discussing about you in private. That's none of your concerb of what the other person thinks about you or your family in private. Now if what Renee's mom said would have happened in say a wedding, in front of people then it's a different thing but what two people talk about in private is none of your business even if they are talking about you or your family.

He was neither supposed to be there or hear what her mom said.

Originally posted by: Paachaa

No re,he was there, Sanya suddenly looks at him behind because she has been looking at her mom's face for a while. I just checked that scene on hotstar before writing my post.😆Also if he has reacted the way he did, he must have heard it from a long time only na?

Originally posted by: krystal_watz

He never had any intention of eavesdropping; he just happened to catch snippets of their conversation and stopped to listen to the whole thing out of curiosity.

If what Renee's mom said was not wrong, then nakul was also not wrong in giving it back to her. Are you trying to say that he should've just left without saying a word after hearing so much shit spewed about his family?

Originally posted by: Paachaa

Yeah, to me he was definitely wrong in reacting the way he did for a private conversation, the keyword here being 'private'. And he himself was embarassed about the same family that Renee's mom was saying shit about a while back in the film so he should've known where Renee's mother is coming from instead of being this aagyakari beta all of a sudden.

Originally posted by: Paachaa

Yeah, to me he was definitely wrong in reacting the way he did for a private conversation, the keyword here being 'private'. And he himself was embarassed about the same family that Renee's mom was saying shit about a while back in the film so he should've known where Renee's mother is coming from instead of being this aagyakari beta all of a sudden.

Originally posted by: Paachaa

Anyways I think so many viwepoints on this particular scene and many more such scenes in the film made Badhaai Ho what it is rather than the humorous parts. It was very realistic in it's approach with the same kind of shit happening everywhere in real life so I guess this is what made the film click with the audience.