--TUM BIN 2 REVIEWS-- - Page 11

SPOILERS.

The movie was sooo slow in the beginning. I dont know why I found Amar so good-looking on TV. On screen, he had whatsoever no charm.

It only picks up when Shekhar enters and the actor is really good in his role. He emotes really well and his chemistry with Taran is better.

Taran is one CONFUSED lady. She insisted on being with Shekhar. Then why couldnt she be adamant on her feelings for Shekhar? Just because Shekhar, who is on some guilt-trip, says that she loves Amar more than she will ever love Shekhar, she agrees? As if. Pft.

UGH. I am just so disappointed. After such a long time, I thought hmm finally Bollywood releases an out-and-out love story and I will finally leave the theatre feeling all mushy and gooy inside. Instead all I wanted to do was throw my popcorn tub at the screen.

2/5 - 2 for Shekhar. Loved you. Wish the girl had ended up with you. Wish you hadnt been so stupid to sacrifice your love though. -_-

I was looking forward to watching this film, but I am in two minds now. I find all this talk about someone having more of a 'right' on a woman (something we see quite often on TV and in films) to be quite regressive.

SPOILERS

Saw the movie was Okayish but had potential to be good.Bollywood rarely makes movies in which a girl is actually in love with two guys.Love triangles are normal but usually in a love triangle its clear whom the girl loves, the other guy is some one whom parents choose or the girl's friend etc.In this movie the heroine is actually torn between two guys she does love.So it had good potential to be different had only the heroine been allowed to take her decisions.Whatever they might have been it should have been her's

I dont mind the ending just that the decision should have been completely hers and not some one else telling her while the heroine just nods her head along.If end game was to be Amar and Taran then that should have been Taran's decision.Basically whatever Shekhar said should have been Taran's dialogues that i was just trying to do the right by being with you but i actually love Shekhar.It had potential but was ruined

the family understands why shekhar went away leaving taran but the lady who is deeply in love with shekhar doesn't bloody know why he did that...and just nod her head for all the nonsense he was talking abt

Mages, I think the opposite completely. Shekhar clarified at the end that the reason why Taran chose him in that Gurudwara scene was because she thought it was the RIGHT thing to do. Shekhar hadn't done anything wrong so she had a tremendous amount of guilt towards him.

The biggest weak point of this movie is Taran & I don't know if that's why Neha's performance was really weak but what a disappointment! Pia was far stronger than Taran & that movie was made 15 years back! Here they didn't even bother giving the woman have the final say & that was a big letdown. I ended up laughing during the climax because it was so corny and plain stupid.

I barely felt for any of the characters. Tum Bin is one of my all time favourites & the second instalment was a far cry from it.

Always knew it was a stupid move to revisit the original.

^totally agree! But no I do not think neha's performance suffered due to weak characterisation! If one is a good actor their acting will be good regardless of the characterisation! And Neha clearly is not a good actress! I personally do not find any of them good looking either! Especially Neha and the guy who played Shekar! The movie made 15 years ago was a million times better! And I feel it is an insult to even compare it with this movie!

Originally posted by: *Reemz*

Mages, I think the opposite completely. Shekhar clarified at the end that the reason why Taran chose him in that Gurudwara scene was because she thought it was the RIGHT thing to do. Shekhar hadn't done anything wrong so she had a tremendous amount of guilt towards him.

The biggest weak point of this movie is Taran & I don't know if that's why Neha's performance was really weak but what a disappointment! Pia was far stronger than Taran & that movie was made 15 years back! Here they didn't even bother giving the woman have the final say & that was a big letdown. I ended up laughing during the climax because it was so corny and plain stupid.

I barely felt for any of the characters. Tum Bin is one of my all time favourites & the second instalment was a far cry from it.

Always knew it was a stupid move to revisit the original.

Agreed i think the ending clarified that it was Amar that Taran truly loved and was with Shekhar because she was trying to do the right thing.Only problem this should have come from Taran herself and not some other person making her realize it.It just made Taran seem weak.

nice reviews guys...i felt she loved shekhar...he did the right by taking her back to her first love...a love that she loose becos of him...after comeback...she cares abt amar but there is no one moment she thinks amar...it was always shekhar in her heart and mind...when amar comes closer to her...she maintains a distance...she is not even letting shekhar go away..

Finally watched the film last night. To be honest this could have been a great movie but it disappointed big time, more so because it had the potential. First of all the movie is slow but also becomes pretty irrelevant at times due to placement of scenes. Like Taran and Shekhar's drive when they go to meet Shekhar's friends for the patisserie work. Its the first time they are out and she is freely talking about why she loved Amar, giving him long loving stares and then getting drunk...all that made little sense for the fact they had met alone for the first time. Later how quickly Taran starts getting attracted to Shekhar is again too rushed and seems out of the place.

Terrible!
Walked out of interval first time.. wasted 200 bucks..
Will write detail review later..