Sonam in Neerja or Deepika in Piku?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Poll

Whose performance was better?

Frequent Posters

lalita

@laly

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#51

Originally posted by: tulsi003
Deepika! Although, I liked Sonam in Neerja. Deepika was able to hold her own in front of stalwarts like Amitabh and Irfan. Whereas, Neerja did have Shabana, but Sonam didn't have many scenes with her. I also think Sonam had to portray a character that was real, and kind of had a briefing in regards to the role. Whereas, Deepika had to start afresh. However, that does mean that Deepika had less restrictions as to how to portray the character of Piku, in comparison to Sonam's portrayal of Neerja. I would also like to add, the audience was so invested in Neerja and her heroic actions, that the portrayal of the character took a backseat. Whereas, Piku was more about the give and take between the characters. To draw a big picture, Neerja was driven by the situation, and the travesty that took place. Piku was driven by the characters.

That's too easy, the thing is that Neerja would not have worked without Sonam! and Deepika had some help..

Quote

1017676

Hibernated

Posted: 9 years ago

#52

Thank you for the laugh guys .

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

LapinLaCocotte

@MostlyHarmIess

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 9 years ago

#53

It's this sort of ridiculousness that follows every good performance in Bollywood, that makes it really difficult to appreciate it for what it is...

I hope Sonam doesn't suffer the same fall as Alia 😆

Anyhow Piku was one of the few films last year from Bollywood that I genuinely liked and a lot had to do with Deepika... Piku could have been a terribly unlikable character or worse a total mess in the hands of someone like Sonam...

Neerja on the other hand was a patchy performance and the awesomeness that the real Neerja does positively alter opinion of this reel Neerja 😆

Quote

Nora

@CineFanLuver

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 9 years ago

#54

The HURT!

Sonam Kapoor fans right now.

Quote

JustMySelf

@JustMySelf

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

#55

Sonam ..
right from Saawariyan she showed grace just that
i love the actress bt rejected the personality due to her
blabbering...😆

Quote

1053501

Suspended

Posted: 9 years ago

#56

Originally posted by: BollyFanLuver

The HURT!

Sonam Kapoor fans right now.

🤣

😆😆

Quote

Larae

@Larae

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

#57

Who'd have thought Sonam would actually beat DP on IF? Had this poll happened a few months ago Sonam would have been called all sorts of names. Classic case of success changing people's perception😉.

Quote

965891

Suspended

Posted: 9 years ago

#58

Originally posted by: sandiab
Abit unfair to compare the 2 since neerja is based on a real life story

yup she had to play the real life character but it could have gone wrong too.

Quote

965891

Suspended

Posted: 9 years ago

#59

Originally posted by: monu_tan
Piku was not only a Deepika movie, it was an Amitabh movie, it was an Irffan movie too.

Neerja was an out and out Sonam movie.

Don't compare apple with oranges. Let deepika do a movie without any strong cast and carry the movie on her shoulders to success, then we compare.

You mean Neerja didn't have a strong.Shabana Azmi?

The poll is not on the success of these two films,it's on the lead actresses performances.

Quote

JustMySelf

@JustMySelf

Rocker

Posted: 9 years ago

#60

Originally posted by: Onyx.
Who'd have thought Sonam would actually beat DP on IF? Had this poll happened a few months ago Sonam would have been called all sorts of names. Classic case of success changing people's perception😉.

did u not hear the hny dialogue?😉
kismaat badi kutti chiz hain kabhi bhi palat sakti hain 🤣

n to be practical i have a feeling dilwale's defeat has turned
deepika disadvantage to some extent here in IF as well 🤣