Better Dancer: Aish or Rani? - Page 5

Rani. I can't imagine Aish doing an Aga Bai at the age of 35.

Originally posted by: JodhaBai

[quote]Hrithik I can't compare to Ash at all be/c he's leagues ahead. [/quote]

Leagues ahead?? Come on now.

I know its hard to compare actors to actresses but Ash has done more diverse work than HR has done.

Originally posted by: Mighty-Zeus

With regards to the comparison i drew between Hrithik & Aish - i was only talking about the way these two have honed their craft over the years , moreover , i do find a similarity between their respective approach to their work ..you dont see it , fine no issues , thats your opinion .. and yes i do agree that hrithik is far better than aish .. Aish is unable to let go off her pretentious lady-like personality in front of camera , which inturn affects her comedy ..

I disagree when people say Aish's acting prowess is underrated .. i think she has always been given her due - be it her beauty , dancing ,acting talent, grace , elegance or even the fake-pretentious aspect of her personality .. same goes for Hrithik ..i dont think either of these two are underrated .. cant speak for IF though.. 😆

Originally posted by: Mallika-E-Bhais

The only similarity between the 2 is their perfectionist attitude & student like discipline, if that's what your talking about then youre right. Yes she is horrible at comedy but in general she's very under rated by everyone b/c of the one attribute she is always been lauded & held in awe of - The very blinding beauty as you put it. B/c of which every other quality & her work is dashed to the ground. Yes, I know it's my opinion just as this is yours.

Dont know why its become about acting prowess but a very few actors who have tried comedy succeeded. Juhi is prob one actress who almost never fails in comedy. Rani went OTT here and there in bunty aur babli as well as some other movies. Kareena has succeeded sometimes when under good direction and at times done poorly with a poorly written role. Its one of the hardest tasks. I for one never believed Karishma proved herself to be a comic actress. She was basically used in govinda films as his love interest. I can't remember one scene where she was the one making me laugh. And Aish has hardly attempted comedy under good direction. So its unfair to judge her skills there. And their are other actors who do not attempt comedy as well and have even given poor performances at times ands still considered good actors. Aish is no different. I do feel she isn't completely given her due at times.

Originally posted by: Mighty-Zeus

Yes , thats precisely the similarity that i was talking about ..

And i can see why people would feel Aish's blinding beauty takes credit from her acting talent but i beg to differ , she was lauded everytime she attempted artsy type roles .. the fact that she is a faulty actor was never so much a hindrance there ..for an actor , who sucks at comedy , i would say she is perfectly rated as an actor..no actor who cant pull off comedy convincingly after attempting it multiple times deserves appreciation for the so called acting talent .. and yes this is my opinion just as you have your own..

Oh dear lord! I was just asking about dancing. 😆 We've done a hundred acting polls on Rani vs XYZ and Aish vs XYZ.

Hetsi! 😡 🥺 How could you? Tara thi expect na karyu mane. 😒

So twice is not enough ?..OK..😆.. see this why i think Sri Devi is one of the best if not the best actor the country has ever seen.. yes certain actors have their pros & excel at something while barely hold on to a string in certain other departments ( dancing ability comes to mind ) but when they so suck at something as essential as comedy they barely qualify as good actors IMO .. the examples given by you - Tabu & Vidya - true they may not have tasted notable commercial success in comedy but that is hardly the measure of their comic talent .. If they arent convincing enough in their act , they are bad actors , box office pull is a different matter ..and I have no doubt in my mind that Vidya & Tabu can pull off comedy convincingly irrespective of the commercial success of their act ..the same cannot be said about Aish .. she just lacks something very essential to pull off comedy .. and so , she is not as much of a talented actor as some people say she is..if there is a popular perception that Aish is really not that great of an actor , i totally stand by it since its totally justified IMO..

Originally posted by: grumpydwarf

Dont know why its become about acting prowess but a very few actors who have tried comedy succeeded. Juhi is prob one actress who almost never fails in comedy. Rani went OTT here and there in bunty aur babli as well as some other movies. Kareena has succeeded sometimes when under good direction and at times done poorly with a poorly written role. Its one of the hardest tasks. I for one never believed Karishma proved herself to be a comic actress. She was basically used in govinda films as his love interest. I can't remember one scene where she was the one making me laugh. And Aish has hardly attempted comedy under good direction. So its unfair to judge her skills there. And their are other actors who do not attempt comedy as well and have even given poor performances at times ands still considered good actors. Aish is no different. I do feel she isn't completely given her due at times.