Shahid v Ranbir: the better actor? - Page 6

Originally posted by: sammywammy

ranbir isn't even my favurite amng the two I chose him as better. I made the poll as these two have attemptd unique, challenging roles. No hidden agenda.

And Shahid ain't my favorite either and nor have I seen many Shahid fans on the forum. Like you, many chose whom they find better in terms of unique attempted/challenging roles. No need to cry when poll doesn't go the way you intended.

TM is claming Kangna won all polls post queen and forum has a habit of overhyping 😃 But the irony is he/she is barely 2 and a 1/2 months old here.. speaks a lot about so called #facts. 😛

I am really curious to know about ek lauta person who voted for the 3rd option ... May be a Dev patel fan 😛

Originally posted by: IamAditya

TM is claming Kangna won all polls post queen and forum has a habit of overhyping 😃 But the irony is he/she is barely 2 and a 1/2 months old here.. speaks a lot about so called #facts. 😛

this is my new account. I had an old one so yes I have been here for much longer than 2 months. 😉

Originally posted by: Fiery.Phoenix

LOL really ? 😆

I just replied back in your own style. I can't help that you didn't like when the same got dished back to ya. Or may be it's your hideous DP...😆

it appears my DP is giving you sleepless nights,.

Originally posted by: sammywammy

it wasn't my intention to start arguments. I didn't expect shahid fans to get upset with me. Surely I'm allowed to give my own opinion on a poll which I've opened. 😕

Yes, i understand you.
But for the fairness of the poll, one shouldn't open it and be skeptical about the vote results when it goes against your view. You can give your opinion about Ranbir being the better actor. But you shouldn't judge the result --------- ''This forum has a habit of overhyping an actor when a film is hugely critically successful.'' Other members can write this on the thread but not the TM because you opened the poll yourself and you are questioning the members' conscience.

cheers😆 don't take anything to heart

TM ask this again when BV releases, Haider is still fresh in everyone's mind😆

Originally posted by: IamAditya

TM is claming Kangna won all polls post queen and forum has a habit of overhyping 😃 But the irony is he/she is barely 2 and a 1/2 months old here.. speaks a lot about so called #facts. 😛

So typical for IF.. last month Shahid was a flop actor and now that he has only given ONE hit with a brilliant performance, I-F is on the "let's praise the star who has given mindblowing films" ride 😛 happened with Kangana, Rani, Shahid, Deepika, basically everyone.. am sure, it's gonna happen with Kareena and Parineeti, too. lol.

I can't decide, tough question. Love both acting skills. Could Shahid do a 'Barfi' and could Ranbir do a 'Haider' or 'Kaminey'?

Shahid has Kaminey, JWM, Haider, Mausam, etc. While Ranbir has Barfi, Rocket Singh, Rockstar, WUS, etc.. and I'm sure he's gonna rock in BV.

Couldn't decide but voted for Shahid just because for variety in role and versatility.

Have yet to watch Haider..but before that Shahid is not even comparable to Ranbir...a mediocre actor who have been always projected to be the next big thing but have given very limited and mediocre performances...but if Haider changes my mind then its entirely different thing