Shahid v Ranbir: the better actor?

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Poll

Shahid v Ranbir: the better actor?

Frequent Posters

-AppleOfMaEye-

@-AppleOfMaEye-

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 11 years ago

#31

and just noticed th votes,..not surprised at all,..

THIS ONLY HAPPENS ON IF,.. where SM/FK may defeat SRK n Salman,.. and shahid may defeat RK with double # of votes! 😆

Quote

CeaselessBanter

@CeaselessBanter

Dazzler

Posted: 11 years ago

#32

Ranbir.

Though he has acting in his DNA,forr me, he stands tall among all the younger actors for two reasons it has a lot to do with how he was trained in Lee Strasburg, the school that produced the likes of De Niro and Jolie. Secondly, this training showed right from the beginning and he stood out in not so impressive movies before hitting his stride. He cannot dance to save his life, but there is something about the way he acts that makes him disappear into the character.

Ranbir and Shahid are almost the same age, but though Shahid made his debut earlier, I always found him, not memorable, even boring. Even in JWM, the one film he made a slight impression on me, it was Bebo's film f. She thoroughly dominated scenes even where she was quiet and reserved. After the image change, I liked him more for his dancing. Haider was the film that changed my opinion of him as an actor.

Edited by CeaselessBanter - 11 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

sammywammy

@sammywammy

Explorer

Posted: 11 years ago

#33

Personally I think ranbir is better. This forum has a habit of overhyping an actor when a film is hugely critically successful. Same thing happened with kangana and queen. Shahid is good but no1 can touch BArfi!! Ranbir was flawless in that role. Shahid has kaminey and haider in his decade long career. Ranbir has barfi, WUS, and rocket Singh in his 7 years. Ranbir has a long way to go yet and I'm sure we will see bigger and better things from him.

Quote

Zoha Sadaqat

@zohasad2.0

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#34

tough one but I would still say Biru...I doubt if Sasha could do Barfi

Quote

vssaras

@vssaras

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#35

Originally posted by: sammywammy
Personally I think ranbir is better. This forum has a habit of overhyping an actor when a film is hugely critically successful. Same thing happened with kangana and queen. Shahid is good but no1 can touch BArfi!! Ranbir was flawless in that role. Shahid has kaminey and haider in his decade long career. Ranbir has barfi, WUS, and rocket Singh in his 7 years. Ranbir has a long way to go yet and I'm sure we will see bigger and better things from him.

Then my question to you is why did you create this poll!...if you do not like the way a poll goes..why give silly justification for it...😆

Quote

sammywammy

@sammywammy

Explorer

Posted: 11 years ago

#36

Originally posted by: vssaras

Then my question to you is why did you create this poll!...if you do not like the way a poll goes..why give silly justification for it...😆

I created it because I wanted to. What's your issue with it 😲 . That's not a silly justification, in just pointin out the facts.

Quote

Zoha Sadaqat

@zohasad2.0

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#37

Originally posted by: vssaras

Then my question to you is why did you create this poll!...if you do not like the way a poll goes..why give silly justification for it...😆

THIS👏

I voted for Biru but just coz ur choice isn't the fav one here ppl start saying IF polls amuse them.😆 IF polls do tend to amuse but this one seems genuine.

Quote

vssaras

@vssaras

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 11 years ago

#38

Originally posted by: sammywammy
I created it because I wanted to. What's your issue with it 😲 . That's not a silly justification, in just pointin out the facts.

Hardly!...people polled as they wanted to!...don't try to find reasons if people don't agree with what you think!...

Quote

982969

Suspended

Posted: 11 years ago

#39

Originally posted by: vssaras

Then my question to you is why did you create this poll!...if you do not like the way a poll goes..why give silly justification for it...😆

😆

Probably it was made thinking Shahid will be slammed, but too bad, it took a complete 180 😆

----------

OT: Definitely Shahid. The shy boy Vivah, the "Fa" boy Kaminey, the crazy boy Haider, the serious boy JWM, the tapori RR, the teen in his first movie, etc etc. I can go on, he has done varied roles and more or less done justice to them. He is one underrated actor. Ranbir only has Barfi under his belt, while Shahid has many to be remembered.