Y werent Govinda's step Condemned? - Sharmila T - Page 9

Sharmila is contradicting herself. Does she or does she not agree that item songs objectify women?
@desigal90: Her statement about Govinda being not condemned is factually untrue, so its naturally being pinpointed.

Originally posted by: krystal_watz

Sharmila is contradicting herself. Does she or does she not agree that item songs objectify women?
@desigal90: Her statement about Govinda being not condemned is factually untrue, so its naturally being pinpointed.

Yes and no.
She's saying they are to an extent, but so do most dance numbers, which are a large part of hindi film culture. Wedding sequences, advertisements, where do you draw the line? They all to an extent objectify. She adds that men are also being objectified in films but no one has a problem with that. Mostly coz men can get away with a lot.
Then she also says that if an actress chooses to be an object of desire, you shouldn't put restrictions on her. I support her stance in the sense that she's basically saying, stop restricting the women, coz that won't solve anything. It's highly simplistic to assume that rising violence against women is due to Bollywood dance numbers.




And yes, you can pinpoint that her example is not accurate.
But again, where does that tie into the comments of Saif being a douche?

Originally posted by: krystal_watz

Sharmila is contradicting herself. Does she or does she not agree that item songs objectify women?
@desigal90: Her statement about Govinda being not condemned is factually untrue, so its naturally being pinpointed.

Members were targeting Saif for the first few pages until I began to question what any if it has I do with the topic.

Go through the first few pages.


But that said, appreciate your comments on the topic at hand and not on irrelevant matters.

Originally posted by: tannipartner

Edit: nkapoor, just because u choose to disagree with what sharmila says does not mean you can go on and call her dumb. please keep your dislike restrained in criticism only[/COLOR]

exactly, Sharmila is anything but dumb.
It's one thing to disagree with a woman's statement but the fact that she can coherently speak on this issue clearly speaks volumes about her mind.
And anyone who chooses to TA her stupid is kidding themselves.

@desigal90 the mods have told u to stay away from me!! So stick to it! Stop ur stupid obsession with me

Also Sharmilla is not a all coherent in her argument

Taanipartner, since I was speaking to you, I'll await for your comments. 😉
I dunno why people are under the impression that I give a damn about em when I clearly addressed your quote.

Originally posted by: Nkapoor3

Also Sharmilla is not a all coherent in her argument

Maybe she was drinking 😉 😉 😉