Why Talaash Should Be Renamed-SPOILER - Page 5

brilliant piece here.

"itni veli bhoot, by god, maine kaabhi nahin dekha" ...epic. 🤣

Originally posted by: ronitroy_ria

So, then Rosie sits in the taxi and maaro-es a dialogue to Shashi, knowing well that the latter wouldn't hear her! Kyun? Itni velli bhoot, by god, maine kabhi nahi dekha! Well, Rosie / Simran being a ghost, didn't have to earn money for her living alright, but why go around talking and whiling away, for no reason. Then, in another scene Tehmur and Nirmala are discussing their escape plan and Simran / Rosie is seen eavesdropping. Isn't she a ghost? Why does she need to hide eavesdrop on conversations ' and why does she need to know their escape plan?

LOL...😆..The write up is fantastic.

I was actually really looking forward to this movie but after all the cold turkey response I gave up and just read the spoilers. Somehow my expectations become 10 fold from Aamir Khan movies since he has such a great track record, but Talaash seems to have dampened the good run. Bhootni vying for revenge...I simply cannot believe Aamir saw potential in such a story? 😕

Originally posted by: ronitroy_ria

Nawaazuddin Siddiqui is undoubtedly the most brilliant portrayal in the film.

Maybe there is an explanation to all the time pass that Rosie was doing over the years. Because she was Simran, and she knew she had to get into the skin of Rosie, she was practising hard, knowing well that she would meet Aamir Khan ' who believes in practice and research!

Well, Rosie / Simran being a ghost, didn't have to earn money for her living alright, but why go around talking and whiling away, for no reason. Then, in another scene Tehmur and Nirmala are discussing their escape plan and Simran / Rosie is seen eavesdropping. Isn't she a ghost? Why does she need to hide eavesdrop on conversations ' and why does she need to know their escape plan?

Hence, to make it a psychological story, it would have been mandatory to have Kareena only in scenes with Aamir. Though they did the car and elevator gimmick, it was just not enough ' because Kareena was made visible to the audience even in scenes where there was no Aamir. That's blasphemy of the entire genre! You can't have the imaginary character visible to audience because then you are making it exist. When you show a Rosie standing behind a wall and listen Tehmur and Nirmala converse, you are belying not only the entire fundamental of the genre but also what you told the audience yourself.