Let's settle the Kat-Kareena BO fight !!!

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

668201

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: IamaXXXstar

How do you explain the New York hit, Kurbaan flop phenomenon then? Both had basically the same plot. Katrina emerged as the winner at BO with two average actors by her side while Kareena tanked despite the Saifeena publicity dominating the press everywhere.

I never talked about those films you mentioned above on first page now did i? I only mentioned about the ones listed by topic maker which were only five films. If we talk about whole career then it would be a different argument...

Quote

360297

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

#12

Kareena and Kareena both have the x-factor necessary to survive in bollywood.They are a treat to the eyes. Both also have lots of substance; Kareena's being her expressions and Kat's being well, her substance, literally 😆.

As a viewer, I'd prefer to watch Katrina in glamorous item numbers because she has a smokin curvy hot bod and dances awesome, but thats about it. When it comes to acting, I'd prefer to see Kareena, she makes even the most unrealistic characters believable.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

64515

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

#13

I'd say Katrina. Bebo's done about 38 films since 2000 to get to this point whereas Katrina understood the business with about 22 films since 2003...Katrina has essentially formed her own fan following while Bebo has been playing catchup despite the fact she's done twice the amount of films. That's why Katrina's films do decent at the box office with less recognizable co-stars...and that explains why Kareena is trying amp up her image to the audience with these Khan movies.

If Bebo can prove that she can be a hit machine consistently without the Khans (with Saif, Imran, etc), then she can get the title...but looking at KI, MAMK, and WAF, I think it's still with Kat

(I found this on Wikipedia...I counted the films they have done, with no guest appearances)

Edited by koolchick - 13 years ago

Quote

31609

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

#14

Kurbaan was a different ball game altogether..lots of things added up there..

firslty, there was the exhaustion of the terrorism theme...Fanaa, New York, Allah ke Bandey all came b4 kurbaan and so ppl got sick of watching the similar themed film over and over again.

Secondly, kurbaan was marketed as a serious film, replete with sex scenes and stuff...tht puts off a major chunk of the audience, underages and families who wont go watch the film thanx to the evidently adult content. With New York, it was marketed as a yuppie college friendship theme with Hai Junoon, Mere sang videos being streamed continously everywhere...and even in the promos, which stars off as a candy floss entertainer... obviously, it would have a bigger audience.

Lots of other things added up to one being a hit and the other being a flop...i'll give it to katrina tht rajneeti was a hit majorly because of her because they used her and ranbir in the marketing and the promos...similarly with APKGK...but i disagree abt NY.

Quote

J tiger Barbie

@wat_up

Achiever

+ 7

Action Alliance

Posted: 13 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: eraser
Kareena and Kareena both have the x-factor necessary to survive in bollywood.They are a treat to the eyes. Both also have lots of substance; Kareena's being her expressions and Kat's being well, her substance, literally 😆.

As a viewer, I'd prefer to watch Katrina in glamorous item numbers because she has a smokin curvy hot bod and dances awesome, but thats about it. When it comes to acting, I'd prefer to see Kareena, she makes even the most unrealistic characters believable.

Totally Agree. Actually its boring topic now I think she should just Marry Salman and quit 😆😆

Edited by wat_up - 13 years ago

Quote

386904

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

#16

Missing Xeta in this thread a lot... She was also obsessed with New York movie, har baar katy ke support mein wohi film aage le aati thi 😊

Quote

668201

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

#17

I think next year we will get all our answers. If Kareena's films like EMAET, Heroine, Agent Vinod would become HIT then we would know tht she also has that pull. And if Katrina's films with the Khans become ATBBs then we will know who is the BOI Queen...

Quote

31609

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: IamaXXXstar

The point of Kurbaan-NY example was that they were in the same league(plot wise) but the consequence was drastically different. I am leaving all the fluff you mentioned aside because if we sit here and explain why every film becomes a hit or a flop, it might take days.
I call it fluff because you being a Kareena fan will go to any lengths to prove a haterzzz point wrong. If I had given credit to Katrina for Rajneet or APKGK, you would have argued with that too by bringing in some other fluff. Since I did not, you used those as examples to redeem yourself.

Kthxbye.

yeh way to dodge all the arguments and make personal judgements...👏

suit urself...

Quote

386904

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

#19

Originally posted by: Heat
I think next year we will get all our answers. If Kareena's films like EMAET, Heroine, Agent Vinod would become HIT then we would know tht she also has that pull. And if Katrina's films with the Khans become ATBBs then we will know who is the BOI Queen...

Sawaal hi paida nahin hota...😆

Katrina's Next 3 Films with Salman, Srk & Aamir === No Way that u cud give 1% Credit to KATRINA KAIF, coz in this FORUM, None of BEBO's film with these KHANS are consider as her success, so same way keep KATY out of this... coz even Widout KATY These 3 films are ATBB for sure... 😆

Quote

386904

Suspended

Posted: 13 years ago

#20

Katrina Kaif did New York and film became HIT, so now Her BO Success is Untouchable 🤣

New York

Good

46,02,00,000

61,75,00,000

22,54,00,000

Hit

People Forgetting to See What the Movie New York Was About, and What Contribution does Katrina Kaif ji given in it... Movie's Subject, YRF Production, Fresh Pairings and Above all it was JOHN ABRAHAM's Performance which Won Appreciation for this Movie...

Before DHOOM -1 , Abhishek n Uday were also not having any BO Records... it was JOHN ABRAHAM's ROle KABIR which Give DHOOM SMASH HIT Title...

Movie dekh ke baat kiya karo jaaron, hawaa mein fundey nahin maara karte 😆