When Shukla denied captaincy to Asim today, its because he truly looked like a potential winner. He has had a few winner moments in the show already, but now, even Shukla has understood where Asim stands. Paras is a total dumbass (which made the katputli task lots of fun to watch so no complaints! ), but Shukla is smart enough and must have noticed these things this week:
- Asim won the task CLEARLY on top because he was the only person who gave a letter, got a letter, and became a captaincy contender.
- With the absence of a captain in the house, the housemates were automatically going to and listening to Asim/Rashmi for duties division. Asim was also sorting out a dishes issue with Vishal in the bathroom for Mahira. That's true leadership.
- Shukla spends all his time with Sana/Mahira/Paras who all think Asim is a total loser. In the secret room, he could listen in on everybody for the first time and he realized Asim is actually well-liked and respected in the house, and has separate friendships with everybody in the house outside the Shukla bubble. In fact, socially he is much stronger because Shukla's whole world is his group, whereas Asim has different levels of friendship with everyone.
- Asim gave the letter to Aarti. Shukla visibly appreciated it. Everybody knows how sensitive Aarti is, and if anyone would truly appreciate the gesture and cherish the letter, it would be her.
- Even though there were plenty of opportunities, Asim never bitched about anybody.
So, I think when Sid comes back now, we will see a completely new and transformed relationship between him and Asim. I'm sure they won't patch up, but personally, I feel like they will be cordial now. Asim's main problem with Sid is that he didn't respect him as an equal. I think that has changed. That's also the reason why Shukla denied Asim the captaincy straight away. Shukla's state of mind was "This pakao guy is trying to be a hero." Now, his state of mind is "This guy has the potential of being a hero, so I need to stop it at the root."