Are We Proud of Our Identity? -- Pls Read - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

48

Views

3.7k

Users

15

Likes

106

Frequent Posters

714873 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#31
@cherryberry: ur replies are always treat to answer. Will be quoting you as soon as i log in back. Thanks for comment. I'll love you answer :-)
@skepblun: will be quoting you too as soon as i log in from lappy. Thanks for devoting precious time writing such a thoughtful reply
Edited by Pari117 - 12 years ago
Dear10 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#32
i think tv par indian kings ke jyada serial aaye hai chandragupt , prithviraj , shivaji , jhansi ki rani n now pratap isliye i m not agree ki tv par sab mughal ko dikha rahe hai .
and i dont know why you people thing akbar is out sider kya usne bharat ko loot kar dusre mulk ko abaad kiya or kya saboot hai ki usne kitne hindu ko mara jabki usne 9 ratno main 3 hindu hi the.

Edited by -dear10- - 12 years ago
714873 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: -dear10-

i think tv par indian kings ke jyada serial aaye hai chandragupt , prithviraj , shivaji , jhansi ki rani n now pratap isliye i m not agree ki tv par sab mughal ko dikha rahe hai .

and i dont know why you people thing akbar is out sider kya usne bharat ko loot kar dusre mulk ko abaad kiya or kya saboot hai ki usne kitne hindu ko mara jabki usne 9 ratno main 3 hindu hi the.



bat wo nahi h, bat hai ki indian lady ko ek tarah bolte h bahut strong hoti hai.. Dusre taraf usi indian lady ko itna kamzor bta rahe hain, ek raja jodha k father ki lachari k karan usse shadi krta h... Jodha na chahte hue shadi krti hai.. Aur akhir me usi raja se pyar karti h.. HD me forced marriage pr kitna bawal hua tha, forced marriage accept krte hue ekta dikha rahi h.. Ye womanhood pr kaala daag h, mai is show ko galat ni kehti agr isne humare sanskaro ki tauhin na ki hoti. Akbar achha tha, baki mughals se bahut thik tha, pr show dekh k sharm aa jayegi.. Akbar ko jaanwar bana di h ekta. Aisa galat show dekhna mazak hai.. History se naam le kr show banana aur galat bate dikhana ek tarah se tiraskaar hai humare history ka
Edited by Pari117 - 12 years ago
Dear10 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: Pari117


bat wo nahi h, bat hai ki indian lady ko ek tarah bolte h bahut strong hoti hai.. Dusre taraf usi indian lady ko itna kamzor bta rahe hain, ek raja jodha k father ki lachari k karan usse shadi krta h... Jodha na chahte hue shadi krti hai.. Aur akhir me usi raja se pyar karti h.. HD me forced marriage pr kitna bawal hua tha, forced marriage accept krte hue ekta dikha rahi h.. Ye womanhood pr kaala daag h, mai is show ko galat ni kehti agr isne humare sanskaro ki tauhin na ki hoti. Akbar achha tha, baki mughals se bahut thik tha, pr show dekh k sharm aa jayegi.. Akbar ko jaanwar bana di h ekta. Aisa galat show dekhna mazak hai.. History se naam le kr show banana aur galat bate dikhana ek tarah se tiraskaar hai humare history ka

why you taking about ekta maiya ka akbar 😆 wo history ke naam par dhabba serial hai uski baat kyun karti ho . wo to naam change karne ko bhi tayaar hai 😆
714873 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: -dear10-


why you taking about ekta maiya ka akbar😆wo history ke naam par dhabba serial hai uski baat kyun karti ho . wo to naam change karne ko bhi tayaar hai😆


mujhe akbar se problem nahi h, pr show thoda dekh k nafrat ho gai thi akbar se.. Itna bura dikha rahi h ke sharm ayega ki hum isi akbar ko respect krte h... Mujhe problem us show se h jo badnaam kr raha h history ko.. Sach me kekta ka show usi ko mubarak 😆
Marathi_Mulgi thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#36
lolz leave kekta's akbar n jodha
akbar was not that bad
evenif she shows female lead as imp but her leads had to go thro rape, forced marriage, extra marital affairs and as weak who need to bend all time against all situations.
enjoy MP
its going gr8
all actors character are really good
if you want gr8 historical show then watch Raja ShivChatrapati
but its in marathi.
Wish Zee bring that with dubbing it in hindi
Edited by Marathi_Mulgi - 12 years ago
debasree04 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: Pari117

i appreciate your spirit that in spite of non historical background you are history lover and worshipper of originality, my salute for you đŸ€—
ahhh yes i too tried watching it and few things disappointed me
1. behavior of akbar, i too felt he was a nice man but watching it diluted everything and every respect i owned, Hritik in JA movie was such a genuine heart... here portrayal of akbar is done in bad light.. i dun like akbar if the things ekta is showing is true
2. akbar married jodha as kind of amer surrendered, i mean jodha's father is shown bechara, laachaar... had someone married me at sich circumstances i wouldnt have accepted that person ever, its better to accept death dan falling for a man who married you out of ur laachaari

i just wrote in a post copying dat here, its real trait of rajput princess do read ----

if we talk about bravery, rajputs can kill themselves but can't put their self respect on stake. I don't know if you all heard about rani padmini or not, alaudin khilji came to know about beauty of hers, he was anxious to keep the queen in his harem so went to raja ratan singh to allow him to look upon her beauty telling lie that he consider padmini as his sister. After seeing padmini, he got mesmerized to marry her and keep her in harem (as akbar felt for jodha) but unlike jodha, brave padmini didn't surrender, when alaudin khilji attacked the fort and entered palaces what he found was only ashes and bones of that brave lady. Padmini died but proved that woman isn't so weak to let her get used by someone for his lust.. My salute for such woman, seriels must be made on rani padmini to glorify her bravery, but they make shows on the woman who surrender themselves and embrace forced marriages. I feel proud our India has woman like Padmini


MRP is awesome show connecting us with reality
thumbs down for others who sell fake stories in name of history




Akbar married rajput princess but she is jodha or someone else thats the matter of huge confusion...but apart from that what i heard Akbar tried to win rajputanas & for that he married rajput princess...its kind of mutual understanding...but never heard that he is such cruel type of person what this serial is showing...
I agree with u @Pari...there should be show on characters like Lakshmibai, Shivaji,Rani Padmini, Maharana Pratap, Asoka, even Akbar [not his love life rather whole life]---there are lots of thing which we can learn from them...But this kind of show MUST SHOW ORIGINAL HISTORY, NO SPICY ADDITION IN IT...their bravery, life is itself great inspiration for us...
Intrepida thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#38
What I dont get is that if Akbar was not that "bad" then why didnt he let the people of Chittor live in peace? why did the third jauhar of Chittod happen if Akbar was not that bad!!! 😡

OK so for all the people who love history or want to learn cool facts which will create more interest in Indian history go to this blog, it has some of the coolest info ever!!!


and

714873 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: Skepblun

@Pari


The 10 PM slot is not bad. Earlier shows like Kahani Ghar Ghar Ki and Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai have attained popularity in that slot only. That Pyar Ka Dard Hai show is also doing well in this slot.
Problem is slow paced story, lack of advertising and general dumbing down of our society due to which a show without masala and tadka finds it difficult to keep afloat.

They are confused with Pratap IMO. At times he is perfect and way wiser and daring beyond his age, and at times he is clumsy and overestimates himself, and underestimates the gravity of the situation. Pratap does not even look like an adolescent yet so that audience understands his confusion. Earlier he was a child prodigy for audience. Now he is just a confused or overconfident kid. And the worst part is that the so called Guru does not even guide him. He only scolds and punishes him. The Guru guy is not inspirational. He is not even a great actor to begin with. So it is irritating.

And for some time now, useless people like Shakti and Bhaatiyani are getting their own way, while Pratap and Jaywantabai get scoldings. So it becomes kind of frustrating.

Shams Khan was a crazy villain and even a sort of comic relief. The new assassin is a bore. He does not look as menacing as he ought to.

If the guru guides Pratap and actually makes effort to polish him rather than just punish him and put him down and if Pratap shines, then also it will be interesting.

Regarding the Kekta maiya show, I do NOT consider it a historical. Akbar must be turning in his grave if his spirit knew about this show and how it is portraying him.đŸ€Ș It's like he was totally evil and useless and even slimy till Jodha (who we do not know even existed or not!) made him "human"!đŸ·

But I have to say that show is promoted in a huge way and SBS/SBB/E24 have segments on it almost daily. While, MRP's promotion is very weak and next to nil! Even SP's yet to be launched Mahabharat has more publicity than MRP!


i am really blank at this position to discuss about history, i did too much of research work today, and we usually read lots of great chants of mughal king akbar but turning the pages of history i felt that akbar was not such a modest king in terms of expanding his territory, yes, unlike other mughal king he didnt assasinated or butchered other kings but he had strategies to win over whole india, he never adopted violent means, instead he collaborated peacefully.. and maharana pratap was the one who never fall into his trap and he never surrendered to mughals.. akbar tried to win over him by friendly means, but pratap was of the view that he wont bow down to them... and even akbar wasnt able to kill him, he died by natural death.. i wonder why even CBSE books dont boast about nation warriors like maharana pratap.. but they are coloured with chapters of mughal empire!!!
I am really proud of such a brave warrior who struggled and was winner as no one could bow him down ever 👏
714873 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: cherryberry293

Nice post nd liked to read different opinions.
I'm following this show since start. This show has a gr8 potential , the only prob is the PACE ... They shud speed up a little wid d story line

I agree Guru's role is not clear. He seems to b interested to punish than to polish his students. For example, 108 Suryanamskar at one go that too on a very first day of training without any previous practice of the same... I feel that was too much

Im not comparing but d similar training was shown in Chandragipta Maurya. There Acharya was strict but wasnt rude... CVs shud watch d videos of CGM which cud help here.

And yes, d marketing of this brilliant show has done on poor level. And for this channel is to b blamed. Today v have a trend JO DIKHTA HAI, WAHI BIKTA HAI... Y they r not promoting it, God knows.
Sony only promotes KBC nd Indian Idol. Which affects on their daily soaps. Sony TVs rankings were always low Bcoz of their this attitude or there cud b some probs in trp counting wid this channel...

Contiloe had produced many shows. They did gr8 at JKR times wid Zee tv.
Veer Shivaji was gr8 nd I personally loved it. Paras nd other actors were too good but just like Mp that show started loosing its viewers Bcoz of slow direction nd finally got scrapped...

I dont wanna see this happening wid Maharana Pratap . Actors r doing gr8 job on their part, here d responsibility lies wid PH nd Channel.

thanks a lot.. i want to know your name, your replies are always genuine!!

i am worshiper of Indian Warriors, i make small and big efforts to know about indian warriors, i applaud writers for bringing forth true warriors of nation, even our history books of CBSE never lets us know about them, there are more mentions about mughals, world histroy and british empire in india, television provide us small means to know about our indian fighters but certain things even dont let it bloom! i agree MRP is flat story sometimes, but till it is revealing golden history of ours to us, i wont mind watching it. i badly wish people to follow this show, it will make them know what we are actually

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".