Search of Truth Part 40 updated page 149 - Page 50

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

84.4k

Users

53

Likes

4.2k

Frequent Posters

anshvi thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: lepchajagat1

Ayaan didnt just give a slight shove. She cursed her and if anyone had not seen what Maya had done earlier it looked more like Ayaan is the criminal & Maya innocent victim. He even pulled a pregnant woman to the terrace & constantly said Arjuns gonna leave her for Saanjh. He's saying he doesnt want to harm the baby ...but sorry he was harming the baby way too much. Its said a pregnant woman should be kept away from mental as well as physical stress for the well being of a baby . But Ayaan was stressing her both ways . And Arjun too added to it.
Maya is Maya .. shes a mentally obsessed person who has no understanding between right and wrong. But it seems this so called normal beings too lose their senses. Vandana said shes happy that her son is out & she warned him not to do anything foolish.. But that didnt stop him.



Ahh...we clearly have different opinions in that case

As i said claiming that Maya is mad and bad so she is excused from committing all crimes but others should be careful and will be held accountable for even slightest of mistakes is not right in my opinon, she could drive a car in high speed and killing a person brutally while being pregnant but her victim has no right to seek justice to prove to his brother that Maya was dangerous even for the baby which she herself admitted.

So, Ayaan shoving her is a big crime while Maya literally trying to murder him is also his fault and not Maya's coz Maya is mad and bad and she can murder people left right and center while others can't even stand against Maya or seek justice against her.

If Maya is mad and bad and can commit murders then others are also humans and not saints who have no right to make any kind of mistake and if they do then they deserve getting killed.

In my opinion others have committed mistakes and paid a bigger price for them while Maya has committed crimes as i have already mentioned

Since we clearly have opposite views, it is better to agree to disagree

Edited by anshvi - 7 years ago
HadhSeZyada thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: manya_roy

Arrey yaar! Whenever I come to this forum, one thing is absolutely constant- people belittling each other.
For God's sake, please stop picking on each other. Thodi na isse show ki story logical ho jaayegi.
If you don't agree with each other fine, why do you have to comment on each other's opinion?
Just chill people it's a fictional show.

On point!
👏😆
Japrilforever thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: HadhSeZyada

Also, if I recall right, Maya was undergoing treatment before she fell for Arjun. And knowing the S1 Maya, she'd have been doing her part in the treatment without cheating.




Oh, can u tell me when they showed this. Genuinely asking coz If I remember rightly, it was shown that she takes pills for depression and even the doctor said in court that Maya was absolutely fine and had no mental illness.
lepchajagat1 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: anshvi


Ahh...we clearly have different opinions in that case

As i said claiming that Maya is mad and bad so she is excused from committing all crimes but others should be careful and will be held accountable for even slightest of mistakes is not right in my opinon, she could drive a car in high speed and killing a person brutally while being pregnant but her victim has no right to seek justice to prove to his brother that Maya was dangerous even for the baby which she herself admitted.

So, Ayaan shoving her is a big crime while Maya literally trying to murder him is also his fault and not Maya's coz Maya is mad and bad and she can murder people left right and center while others can't even stand against Maya or seek justice against her.

If Maya is mad and bad and can commit murders then others are also humans and not saints who have no right to make any kind of mistake and if they do then they deserve getting killed.

In my opinion others have committed mistakes and paid a bigger price for them while Maya has committed crimes as i have already mentioned

Since we clearly have opposite views, it is better to agree to disagree



Maya has been facing difficulties since childhood. She had to fight to get her ways since she was small. Her dad used to throw her among her friends and made everyone say Maya pagal hai maya pagal hai .. hope you have not forgotten those FB scenes. Shes suffering pain since long & these normal human beings are suffering it just now. So naturally there will be a difference. But now its showing when you are cornered or wronged or not getting what you want your animal instincts precedes your thoughts , just like these normal human beings are behaving now . ,Manipulating bribing & Arjun now even ran to kill Maya to save Saanjh .

HadhSeZyada thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: lumos_31




Oh, can u tell me when they showed this. Genuinely asking coz If I remember rightly, it was shown that she takes pills for depression and even the doctor said in court that Maya was absolutely fine and had no mental illness.


Depression is also a mental illness babe.
And it's the S1's doc's fault if it was misdiagnosed.
Bleh.
Also,in legal matters, as far as I know, a team of psychiatrists, psychologists and other experts like forensic analysts work together to come to a conclusion. It's not a solitary diagnosis by a single doctor - we ain't even sure that the doctor who was shown to deem Maya mentally healthy, is a psychiatrist or not - who gives a report. There are several specializations too,when it comes to psychiatrists and psychologists.
I don't know why you have that much faith in the CVS that they'd diagnose Maya (or even saanjhs fatal anxiety attack which can only be cure by Maya's death and no therapy or medications) properly.
Since the beginning, they've got almost every diagnosis very blurry and there have been millions of contradictions,(the contradictions have been more than the characteristic traits tbh). They've never once been accurate when it comes to legal and medical matters.
Bloopers over bloopers, it's nauseous. It's not that hard to get a few facts right,if not all of em. But nope. The can't even do that.

Edited by HadhSeZyada - 7 years ago
Japrilforever thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: HadhSeZyada

Depression is also a mental illness babe.
And it's the S1's doc's fault if it was misdiagnosed.
Bleh.
Also,in legal matters, as far as I know, a team of psychiatrists, psychologists and other experts like forensic analysts work together to come to a conclusion. It's not a solitary diagnosis by a single doctor - we ain't even sure that the doctor is a psychiatrist or not - who gives a report.
I don't know why you have that much faith in the CVS that they'd diagnose Maya (or even saanjhs fatal anxiety attack which can only be cure by Maya's death and no therapy or medications) properly.
Since the beginning, they've got almost every diagnosis very blurry and there have been millions of contradictions,(the contradictions have been more than the characteristic traits tbh). They've never once been accurate when it comes to legal and medical matters.
Bloopers over bloopers, it's nauseous. It's not that hard to get a few facts right,if not all of em. But nope. The can't even do that.



When did I disagree to depression being a mental illness, am a doctor myself so u can be assured I know what depression and other mental illnesses are. Looking at Maya now, I don't even think she's a psychopath, let alone a patient of depression. I used to think she was a victim of borderline personality disorder earlier, but nope, now I just feel she's a cold blooded criminal.

U shouldve specified she took treatment for depression, then I wouldn't have asked u that question, coz u came across as saying that she was undergoing treatment for whatever so-called mental illness she had that drove her to kill.
Edited by lumos_31 - 7 years ago
anshvi thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: lepchajagat1



Maya has been facing difficulties since childhood. She had to fight to get her ways since she was small. Her dad used to throw her among her friends and made everyone say Maya pagal hai maya pagal hai .. hope you have not forgotten those FB scenes. Shes suffering pain since long & these normal human beings are suffering it just now. So naturally there will be a difference. But now its showing when you are cornered or wronged or not getting what you want your animal instincts precedes your thoughts , just like these normal human beings are behaving now . ,Manipulating bribing & Arjun now even ran to kill Maya to save Saanjh .


Doesn't this apply for others as well
When u get wronged and cornered and your whole life gets destroyed then u also have the right ti seek justice which Ayaan did

Maya suffered in childhood , that is understandable, she was a victim of Ashwin and thus killing him was understandable to a point but she turned into a criminal while others became his victim

Just like Maya had right to seek justice against Ashwin same way Ayaan had the right to seek justice against her...Here Maya went on to the extent of killing Ashwin while Ayaan wanted to prove his innocence.

Maya's childhood trouble doesn't give her the right to murder people in the name of love

All these people never tried to murder Maya like she tried to do to them.

Now also Maya is trying to murder Saanjh even when she is in jail...Yes you are right Arjun tried to kill Maya to 'save' Saanjh

Maya on the other hand had ill intentions when she tried to murder AYaan , when she killed Vandana, when she murdered Mansi...Here I am not even including Samay and Ashwin.

aekiel thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 500 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: HadhSeZyada


Depression is also a mental illness babe.
And it's the S1's doc's fault if it was misdiagnosed.
Bleh.
Also,in legal matters, as far as I know, a team of psychiatrists, psychologists and other experts like forensic analysts work together to come to a conclusion. It's not a solitary diagnosis by a single doctor - we ain't even sure that the doctor who was shown to deem Maya mentally healthy, is a psychiatrist or not - who gives a report. There are several specializations too,when it comes to psychiatrists and psychologists.
I don't know why you have that much faith in the CVS that they'd diagnose Maya (or even saanjhs fatal anxiety attack which can only be cure by Maya's death and no therapy or medications) properly.
Since the beginning, they've got almost every diagnosis very blurry and there have been millions of contradictions,(the contradictions have been more than the characteristic traits tbh). They've never once been accurate when it comes to legal and medical matters.
Bloopers over bloopers, it's nauseous. It's not that hard to get a few facts right,if not all of em. But nope. The can't even do that.



HSJ- there was one major question Lumos asked in her previous post, and your reply did everything but answer that part.

The only evidence I can think of is that pill and medical report from the insurer refusing to give insurance that she planted for Saanjh to find out. In hindsight though, Maya used that to drive another wedge between Saanjh and Arjun, and got her mother to admit the pills were for her.

I have no idea whether she actually underwent the treatment, or it was all part of a large plan to send Saanjh on a wild goose hunt and prove her wrong in front of Arjun. Given her lying nature and her omniscient presence all through S1, I'd be sorely tempted to think the latter, but I'll give the benefit of doubt and say it was the former. Evidently though, it didn't have the effect required.

HadhSeZyada thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
I never said you said so, lumos_31. I'm a psychiatrist myself. Nice to know you're a fellow doc.
The S1 Maya had distinct traits which normally overlap with quite a few disorders. There have been times I've debated w myself if she's got narcissistic personality disorder or borderline personality disorder or OCPD. But since most of h er traits along with those which fell in the NPD and BPD zones, overlapped in the spectrum of OCPD, i stuck to the theory that she suffered from OCPD. But, we're on the same page that she's very cold-blooded when it comes to the crimes committed by her.
It's not my job to decide what's wrong and what's right. I'm not here to do so either. I just happen to look at the cause and the course of action which lead to a reaction. I merely state that. Because for the past 8+ years, in the medicinal field, I've been taught to that. I used to look at maya as a patient. but it's been a long while I've stopped. It's indifference that I feel.
HadhSeZyada thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago

Originally posted by: aekiel



HSJ- there was one major question Lumos asked in her previous post, and your reply did everything but answer that part.

The only evidence I can think of is that pill and medical report from the insurer refusing to give insurance that she planted for Saanjh to find out. In hindsight though, Maya used that to drive another wedge between Saanjh and Arjun, and got her mother to admit the pills were for her.

I have no idea whether she actually underwent the treatment, or it was all part of a large plan to send Saanjh on a wild goose hunt and prove her wrong in front of Arjun. Given her lying nature and her omniscient presence all through S1, I'd be sorely tempted to think the latter, but I'll give the benefit of doubt and say it was the former. Evidently though, it didn't have the effect required.


Uh, do you recall her overdosing on pills and slitting her wrists in the bathtub in the initial episodes? That she fainted while driving jhanvi back from the beach after the latter hung out w Arjun? A doc had come to see her then. And it was implied numerous times in the initial episodes that she was undergoing treatment. It was way before she fell for Arjun. How can it be an elaborate scheme then?
Sure, the depression one was a plot to separate dusky duffer.
But what I'm talking about is it the initial episodes. Before she fell for Arjun. I think it was before episode 30? I'm not sure.


Edit: it'd been also implied that she was seeking help for her insomnia.
Edited by HadhSeZyada - 7 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".