Parallels between Ek Hasina Thi and Bepannah

shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
Guys I dont know, it has been quite some time I have been getting Durga vibes in Zoya. Ek Hasina Thi was also a show by Cinevistaas and it was a thriller and it will always remain one of my favorites. But EHT had a love story as its parallel track. Love story of Dev and Durga. I had always felt that love story somewhere was left adhura because the show closed in 8 months. It had its moments, but then the focus of EHT was the female protoganist and male antagonist. The hunter and prey syndrome between Shaurya Goenka and Durga Thakur.
For the past sometime when I watch BP I feel that love story of EHT is repackaged with amazing leads in BP. In EHT Shaurya does a crime and Dev mistake, a gross mistake. But Dev's mistake burns the girl Nithya and her belief more than the crime Shaurya does. So when she comes back as Durga with the face of a girl who is already dead in her smile is a charred woman.A woman with burning fire inside to burn everything around her. She hates everything about Nithya who she treats a failure and her favourite hobby is burning Nithya's picture everyday. Dev runs around searching his Nithya wanting to correct his mistake. He makes friendship with Durga who decides to marry Shaurya as for her mission is important and also Dev's safety as her plot has resulted in him having life threat. During those days I use to mention Durga cannot win, only Nithya can win the battle. The girl needs her self belief and the person who can give her that is Dev himself because of whom she lost it as she had trusted him blindly. Dev had to walk on fire to reach her. There is a scene where he is beaten up in lock up mercilessly. He chases her, he suffers like mad, the straight forward Dev Goenka even agrees for a deal marriage with Durga for his Nithya. He takes out the poison in her and she stops him from self destruction giving proof that of course his Nithya is there. He finds out finally Durga is Nithya.

If you look at BP though Zoya is not Durga as she is not manipulative she has lot of pent up feelings in her. Her anger at Yash which she had never expressed in true sense. She closing the doors of love is also because if she opens them the first thing that will come out is not nectar, but poison. Her pain that is locked. Aditya had ranted and raved at Pooja, at Yash but Zoya has not really. She has not talked about her relationship with Yash,the way Aditya has opened up to her. She is burned, scarred and more than half dead.

She is treating this half dead state as life with a smile. Her emotions, her feelings she has locked them up never wanting to acknowledge them and friendship offers a safe zone for her to be normal, sane. With his confession tomorrow Aditya is going to throw open the doors of her rage, her pent up emotions and more or less killing her soul. Whatever she couldnt do with Yash with her pent up rage she is going to go for Aditya comparing him with Yash. Yash did a crime, Aditya a mistake in love. But for the criminal Yash, Aditya will have to take the poison. We used to shout during EHT marriage track, what is wrong with Dev Goenka, one more time he speaks Nithya we will switch of television. But that was Dev's penance for getting once chance with his Nithya to correct his mistake.

Same will be Aditya. He will be mad running around, because he needs one chance to prove himself but Zoya is not going to give him due to past though she herself will be disturbed as Durga was. Just like Dev took the punishment, Aditya will also take her indifference as his punishment. Because the poison in Zoya has to taken out. She needs to be a better judge of character. She needs to know she cant be good with everyone, she cant be bad with everyone. None is God. Everyone is human and humans make mistakes and they need to be given a chance. Because if you dont give a human a second chance humanity will cease to exist. Yes a Yash has to be punished, but a Aditya can be forgiven and given a chance to improve himself.

Created

Last reply

Replies

10

Views

1.4k

Users

7

Likes

59

Frequent Posters

anjaanichudi thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
I hope it doesn't go dt way coz most here r Aditya fans n if Aditya is in pain or if Zoya is indifferent to him n punishes him, dn Zoya will get roasted in dis forum. Jen is already getting enuf hate. Moreover no lovey dovey scens between Adiya wud be a dampener.
musicndance3 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3
This made my day a little more better Thanks!
Kiruravi thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
I hav never watched tht serial so knw nthng abt it's plot. But after reading ur brief explanation,i dnt want bp to go in EHT way. Cuz already lil damage has been done by this arshad trck.
It would seriously make the audience to quit the show :(
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
See during eht also entire fandom was bashing durga for deciding to get married to shaurya her sister's rapist. I was sleeping through that track till sakshi goenka intervenes strongly. But when i watched the show second time I understood it better. Because then u knew the story. Same is here is my take. This is a track that will make sense in retrospective. Here anjana will have to intervene or Mr hooda to stop the madness.
MargaritaLover thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: anjaanichudi

I hope it doesn't go dt way coz most here r Aditya fans n if Aditya is in pain or if Zoya is indifferent to him n punishes him, dn Zoya will get roasted in dis forum. Jen is already getting enuf hate. Moreover no lovey dovey scens between Adiya wud be a dampener.

I don't understand who are the people bashing Jen. Can't they differenciate between real and reel characters? Sad!
mystique_4008 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: anjaanichudi

I hope it doesn't go dt way coz most here r Aditya fans n if Aditya is in pain or if Zoya is indifferent to him n punishes him, dn Zoya will get roasted in dis forum. Jen is already getting enuf hate. Moreover no lovey dovey scens between Adiya wud be a dampener.



Who is hating on Jen? some people seem to have a problem with her idkw unless it's those people who can't differentiate between reel and real 😡
mystique_4008 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#8
I hope this doesn't happen already cvs have done enough damage to this track and some people are always criticising Zoya even when she is not wrong.
BeyondHorizon thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
Beautiful post Shruthi but maybe I cannot relate EHT with BP at this point and certainly not Durga with Zoya. I guess as characters they r diagonally opposite. Nithya burned in the fire of revenge and rose up a phoenix - Durga. While Durga had lost faith on relationships and optimism in life, Zoya did not let that shatter her belief in relationships. She moved on in life with a positive attitude, though as u rightly mentioned she is in a half dead state coz she never vented out her rage. She has bottled it all up and Adi proposing to her will plunge her into that fire once again n she will burn and this time she won't hold back her wrath. Like u said nectar won't pour forth but it will be poison. However in this case it is not justified coz in that rage she decides to marry Arshad. In Durga's case she had a clear agenda. EHT will be one of my all time fav shows despite that getting a hurried ending. Coming to Dev, I guess we were among the select few who appreciated the love story warna the amount of bashing Dev got, it was uncalled for 😵 I don't see how Dev made a mistake coz he was far away from Durga n he was held up with circumstances that did not allow him to even become aware of what was happening. By the time he got to know about it, Nitya was declared dead and what could the poor guy do? His only mistake would probably be not looking out for Payal. So what if Nitya was dead, Payal was still alive n he could have tried to find about her whereabouts and taken care of her on his own without letting the Goenkas know. This way he could have made up for his absence and also for the love he bore Nitya. Instead he wallowed in self pity over losing her. Durga never had feelings for him even when she married him coz in her mind he was just an innocent person who was getting pulled into a game he was never a part of. So she tried to shield him from his own conniving family. For Durga, Nitya was dead and she could not harbor the feelings of friendship for Dev even though she got to know about his innocence. But once she developed feelings for him, she loved him not as Nitya but as Durga and that's what she tells Dev in the last epi too - that even though he loves Nitya, Nitya will never think of him as anything more than a friend but Durga will always love him n he has to accept her as Durga if he wants her in his life.

Coming to the main topic, viewers will never forgive Zoya for subjecting Adi to that pain. Maybe in EHT it was acceptable bcoz the main focus was on the plot n not DevGa but here the main focus has always been AdiYa n if Adi has to suffer coz of Zoya n vice versa, no one will be happy My anger at this point is not that she got mad at Adi but that slap was so uncharacteristic of her n her marrying Arshad more so. And Arshad thrashing Adi? Got a lil too much to handle 😆 Thats y I am skipping this week's episodes n reading WU. I don't expect Zoya to start loving Adi in a few episodes, but I at least want Arshad track to end coz its making no sense just like Rajveer track.
shruthiravi thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 7 years ago
#10
@Mandy we need to see how it plays out. Sometimes people do irrational things in anger some sort of self destruction because for me zoya deciding to marry arshad is equivalent suicide. She had tried to stay afloat post yash betrayal and wasim had not spared her with her taunts. Now aditya has broken her. How long a person can be at the receiving end of taunts. Somewhere I can understand her. Though her and mine issue are different it has taken me immense strength to think rationally again. And such wounds are not given by outsiders but ur own family. Aditya has been her last hope of having self belief and proving her choice is right. She lost it with his confession. Mahi had told zoya is not broken after so much. But adi confession is going to break her.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".