Is adultery crime or not

Patharsitara thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1
I m still pondering after watching this show . saying that we don't justify ema but asking for forgiveness from people who cheated that means people who cheat are not culprit but victim of treatment from their spouses.so I should support neighbour uncle who left his wife and child for love for younger girl.should I go to wife and advise her that she should ask for forgiveness from husband for not being beautiful and young that drive her husband to young girl.hmmm there are many cases where society blame spouse for cheating of his or her partner like that they are not good enough to hold relationship.bepannah is doing good job for showing perspective of cheaters that they should not be blamed alone for cheating ,so what if they lied to their partner and family ,so what if they spend money and time on outsider instead of family,so what if they instead of trying and understanding in marriage go and hang with other .
Hmmm quite interesting.divorce is option if you don't want to live with your partner.but that is tiresome and expensive and also bring lot of insult.so it's good to cheat .
So my question is cheating is crime or not 😛

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

879

Users

7

Likes

34

Frequent Posters

mango.falooda thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail 7th Anniversary Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: Patharsitara

I m still pondering after watching this show . saying that we don't justify ema but asking for forgiveness from people who cheated that means people who cheat are not culprit but victim of treatment from their spouses.so I should support neighbour uncle who left his wife and child for love for younger girl.should I go to wife and advise her that she should ask for forgiveness from husband for not being beautiful and young that drive her husband to young girl.hmmm there are many cases where society blame spouse for cheating of his or her partner like that they are not good enough to hold relationship.bepannah is doing good job for showing perspective of cheaters that they should not be blamed alone for cheating ,so what if they lied to their partner and family ,so what if they spend money and time on outsider instead of family,so what if they instead of trying and understanding in marriage go and hang with other .

Hmmm quite interesting.divorce is option if you don't want to live with your partner.but that is tiresome and expensive and also bring lot of insult.so it's good to cheat .
So my question is cheating is crime or not 😛



ugh I had this long message written out but here we go again! :)

so just like in real life, when discussions about cheating and marriage breakdown happens, it becomes a blame game. who is the victim? who is the bad person? but what the writer is attempting to show is that in some cases, (not necessarily all), a marriage breakdown isn't just about one person. there are two people in the relationship. rather than trying to figure out who is wrong, perhaps a better educational approach would be to ask the lessons we can take away and become better people.

in regards to the incident that you shared, another way to look at it is that many indian women fail to take care of themselves after marriage. now does that mean the husband was justified? NO. absolutely not. but when you hear of such stories, it is a reminder to other people to take care of themselves, to maintain emotional ties with your spouse even if you have been married for years etc etc... so being aware of issues does help perhaps.

please see my profile and previous posts but a theme that this drama covers but does not delve into deeply (and it should) is the impact of financial stress on a marriage. there should be discussion between the spouses on financial matters because that can break a marriage if not properly handled...
Edited by mango_pudding1 - 7 years ago
enlightenme thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Patharsitara

I m still pondering after watching this show . saying that we don't justify ema but asking for forgiveness from people who cheated that means people who cheat are not culprit but victim of treatment from their spouses.so I should support neighbour uncle who left his wife and child for love for younger girl.should I go to wife and advise her that she should ask for forgiveness from husband for not being beautiful and young that drive her husband to young girl.hmmm there are many cases where society blame spouse for cheating of his or her partner like that they are not good enough to hold relationship.bepannah is doing good job for showing perspective of cheaters that they should not be blamed alone for cheating ,so what if they lied to their partner and family ,so what if they spend money and time on outsider instead of family,so what if they instead of trying and understanding in marriage go and hang with other .

Hmmm quite interesting.divorce is option if you don't want to live with your partner.but that is tiresome and expensive and also bring lot of insult.so it's good to cheat .
So my question is cheating is crime or not 😛

This case is different there are no children involved. There is not much difference between Zoya and Pooja's age.
Sometimes forgiveness is very important to move on in life especially if the one's who cheated are no longer in this earth.

I wish Pooja-Yash were alive to see where it would land after cheating their partners. Two of them happily married with a newly added member to the family. Imagine Mahi, Madhu, Shakshi, Yash and Pooja under a single roof along with the new born. With debt to be payed off to the debtors. Imagine Pooja slogging in the morning with her prized MBA degree and in the evening in the kitchen preparing her family's lunch and dinner. By the night she would be so tired that the painter and poet in her will perhaps have to say goodbye atleast for an era. Pooja and Shakshi didn't realise the luxury they were enjoying in the Hooda house without actually doing nothing.
DreamOfEndless thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
Technically, adultery is a crime in India for men.. not for women. Section 497, IPC.

See: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adultery_law_in_India
malarmia thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
It is a crime & culprits deserve to be punished.
enlightenme thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: dreamy.tiara

Technically, adultery is a crime in India for men.. not for women. Section 497, IPC.

See: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adultery_law_in_India

Thank for the information.
Patharsitara thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: mango_pudding1



ugh I had this long message written out but here we go again! :)

so just like in real life, when discussions about cheating and marriage breakdown happens, it becomes a blame game. who is the victim? who is the bad person? but what the writer is attempting to show is that in some cases, (not necessarily all), a marriage breakdown isn't just about one person. there are two people in the relationship. rather than trying to figure out who is wrong, perhaps a better educational approach would be to ask the lessons we can take away and become better people.

in regards to the incident that you shared, another way to look at it is that many indian women fail to take care of themselves after marriage. now does that mean the husband was justified? NO. absolutely not. but when you hear of such stories, it is a reminder to other people to take care of themselves, to maintain emotional ties with your spouse even if you have been married for years etc etc... so being aware of issues does help perhaps.

please see my profile and previous posts but a theme that this drama covers but does not delve into deeply (and it should) is the impact of financial stress on a marriage. there should be discussion between the spouses on financial matters because that can break a marriage if not properly handled...

Power of lust is much Stronger than power of loyalty.marriage and sacred vows hold deep meaning.adultry is considered bad because a person backstab his or partner ,keep lying and keep them in dark.will you forgive a perspm whom you rely and trust and care backstab you for another person?will you understand his or her betrayal?a person as third person very easily say that betrayal and cheating can be forgiven.but ask the victim who feel that their whole world get shattered and destroyed,who feel like dying ,who feel insecure to trust anyone.
This show has not depicted the victim point of view.not once it was declared that Pooja and Yash had done crime to betray their partner.but they are said to be human with fault.sorry if anyone is decent human he or she would not cheat their partner.if they don't want to live with their partner they should have cut off their relationship from respective partners before starting their affair.but cheating and betraying their partner andkeeping them in dark is something that a pathetic selfish person can do.
How could they play with unconditional trust that their partner had given them.my problem with this show is that they are showing betrayal in marriage lightly.
In real life case it is so heart wrenching that one could imagine.they did not highlighted the consequences of betrayal.its not easy in practical life.i have seen people living like dead after betrayal.so philosophy and theory is very good but in real life philosophy not always work.
Giving lifelong trauma and pain to other and starting own life happily is Sinister.
Karma does not listen to philosophy and theory.so if any person think that he or she will be easily forgiven for sin because they are human with fault then they should always remember that karma bite back and karma do not listen to philosophy and forgiveness theory.
My pov end here

Edited by Patharsitara - 7 years ago
mango.falooda thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail 7th Anniversary Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Patharsitara



no one would argue that adultery is a good thing - it is not. but understanding the reasons or a breakdown in marriage can help others become wiser. for example, research indicates that financial stress is one of the top reasons for marriages breaking down the world over. Yash and Zoya's marriage breaking was initially strained by the financial stress and him not being able to share his burdens with her. Was he right in cheating? NO. but understanding that helps us viewers understand the impact of financial stress in relationships.

whether or not, one should forgive is a choice that everyone makes in all sorts of situations. however, we need to understand that forgiveness does not mean that the action becomes right and somehow whatever the person did is okay. actually forgiveness just means that we are no longer bound by hurt and anger towards that person or event and we learn to let go. sometimes there is reconciliation, sometimes there is no possibility for reconciliation. forgiveness only means letting go of the past and finding some measure of peace within ourselves.

Uroojj thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: Patharsitara

Power of lust is much Stronger than power of loyalty.marriage and sacred vows hold deep meaning.adultry is considered bad because a person backstab his or partner ,keep lying and keep them in dark.will you forgive a perspm whom you rely and trust and care backstab you for another person?will you understand his or her betrayal?a person as third person very easily say that betrayal and cheating can be forgiven.but ask the victim who feel that their whole world get shattered and destroyed,who feel like dying ,who feel insecure to trust anyone.
This show has not depicted the victim point of view.not once it was declared that Pooja and Yash had done crime to betray their partner.but they are said to be human with fault.sorry if anyone is decent human he or she would not cheat their partner.if they don't want to live with their partner they should have cut off their relationship from respective partners before starting their affair.but cheating and betraying their partner andkeeping them in dark is something that a pathetic selfish person can do.
How could they play with unconditional trust that their partner had given them.my problem with this show is that they are showing betrayal in marriage lightly.
In real life case it is so heart wrenching that one could imagine.they did not highlighted the consequences of betrayal.its not easy in practical life.i have seen people living like dead after betrayal.so philosophy and theory is very good but in real life philosophy not always work.
Giving lifelong trauma and pain to other and starting own life happily is Sinister.
Karma does not listen to philosophy and theory.so if any person think that he or she will be easily forgiven for sin because they are human with fault then they should always remember that karma bite back and karma do not listen to philosophy and forgiveness theory.
My pov end here


So true I feel the same.
If pooja was such a good girl such a good friend, how can she abort his baby without his consent. How can she carry anybody else's baby without cutting off with Aditya. Baby is not a virus that she got it when hash snizzed. Of course she had go a long way before carrying yashz baby.
Yash k defence k liya itna kafi hai k zoya was not his friend. Did he made her listen to him what ever he wanted her to know. It was easy for him to make another person friend instead of asking his wife to listen n understand him.

The show interpret that zoya n Aditya had flaws that's why their spouses cheated in them, in my poiny of view it's was easy for pooja n yash to cut off with their respective spouses and led a broke life. As they never mentioned money in their ema. If money was no pb n zoya n Aditya's feeling was no issue then why they hid? Now ppl will say that they didn't tell zoya n Aditya so that they would be hurt, toh ab kiya ho raha hai after being pregnant with another guy pooja gave happiness to Aditya. N I didn't get the logic k pooja aborted ur baby then pregnant from an other person toh it's justified don't say any bad thing about her.

rs-shailu29 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#10
adultery is crime ..
ppl in EMA needs to be open with spouses end it or fix they need to stop riding both at the same time ..

we hear few stuffs few ppl murder spouse to be with in affair ..

its crime ..
backstabbing is offensive too .
no matter what they show in tv or movies ...EMA is offensive ..

ppl might justify it but cheating is cheating ...


pooja blaming adi was her weakness without being vocal how can she blame adi ..

aborting is big thing if adi was not supportive she could have discussed with the elders like anjana (her mom is useless )and harsh didn't they had rights to know she was carrying ..


one word made pooja think adi was irresponsible and insensitive ...

ok if she wanted kid she could have ended up with adi and had baby and raised it on her own .

her logic of saving marriage by aborting was a joke to me ..
simple thing is that her love had faded out ..

mind it she got an option yash to take plunge and she blamed adi easy way to cover up her guilt ..
crossing the line and being pregnant with yash baby was biggest thing she could have waited till divorce thing was sorted but still poosh love was pure this is what cv's shown us ,...
crappy logic from cv's ..

because of adiya and stars showing is being loved otherwise this was crappist track ever in history of tvland

anyways poosh is the end adiya are beginnings ..

time to move on
Edited by rs..shailu29 - 7 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".