Real Barkat's grave - Confusion/ Usman's dark/shady past - Page 3

Originally posted by: arshi_arvi

It could be that the real Barkhat is still alive. She is probably in abroad and will be introduced later.

And Bobby's mother is a mystery to me. Maybe she is Mir khan and Sabhana's daughter. Mir khan probably raped Sabhana and Sabhana gave birth to the daughter without telling anyone and left the baby with Mir khan.

Originally posted by: _Littles12_

Answer:

Thats was main issue, Like I get it they dont prolong every issue, but a bit more of research or investigation would have helped in gaining more information. Literally they were handed that this is Barkat, and they believed it, no inquires, no Tests, no nothing, they all believed it was Barkat blindly. I mean even before all this they should have inquired A to Z to make sure the girl they are going to bring to their house, is the one? How do you just bring a girl in your house, and shower her with loves without assurity? Yes I get, emotions took over but you cannot let that happen. exactly, ok the family I can see got emotional as the unexpected happened and it was like they wanted to believe she is barkat even though there was a possibility tht she wasn't. I mean they actually took Mir's word for it...which is plain stupid...how could they trust a man that was a liar and a cheat... they had no proof tht she was barkat apart from the fact tht she was called barkat mir khan when the nikkah vows were being read out and that Mir said "haan barkat tumhari beti hai"... and this just means tht they took Mir's words as being the truth which just shows how stupid the family is including zain and aaliya. i mean they chose to believe Mir of all people?? didn't they once think that Mir could have lied. To me the biggest disappointment was Aaliya not questioning it... she's always been shown to be someone that picks up on things but this is the 2nd time since the shows started where i felt she failed to pick up on something which was so obvious to the eye. one when she couldn't sense the creepiness in zeeshan's voice whenever they spoke on the phone and now with her not questioning the possibility of barkat not being their barkat. I mean nafeesa/shazia made a valid point and picked up on the fact and even questioned it alone in their room and Aaliya had even overheard their conversation but did nothing - i had expected her 2 do something the min they showed tht she had overheard their conversation but she didn't. 😕 they really just rushed the "finding barkat" track which should have been a bit long... instead they r making this "barkat's evil plans/kill usman" track long unnecessarily... i dunno why they have to drag something which doesn't need dragging and rush something which should be developed over time. i.e. Aayat's track ended too soon - so much potential n so much could have been explored with that track but it was just too rushed

When Aliyah was telling Zain about everything she left out the picture part, and that should have been the first thing mentioned in my opinion as that is the most important object that triggered Aliyah to think and do what they should have done way before.

I dont know obviously, we are missing so much nothing right now is really making sense. All i can say Cvs better not forget about Usmans past Well i guess they didnt but as soon as the whole truth comes, they might find out why Mir even kidnapped Barkat in the first place.

How can you say there was no contact between the two brothers? We dont know, there might have been and Ghulam could have kept it a secret as he didnt want anyone to know. I mean for how long can you stay away from your sibling, I just feel like even if Ghulam isnt involved he definitely knows key info. the reason why im saying this is becos im sure aaliya had mentioned how Ghulam broke all ties with Mir when speaking to suraiya in front of the family and even shabana and ghulam had a conversation abt how he had thrown Mir out of his heart and life when he found out what he'd done. Having said that, what raises a suspicion on the contact issue is Ghulam going to meet Mir when he came to Mumbai to meet Barkat... how did Ghulam know where Mir would be...and the way he was at Barkat Villa before leaving it seemed like he'd been called by Mir to meet him and he was in a double mind abt going and eventually went to meet him. too many bloopers yaar. CVs have a lot of explaining to do but i get a feeling they wont pay attention to these points we r discussing here.

So, Usman killed Bobby Mir's real daughter, so right now the bobby in the house is actually a dancer whose name is also Bobby, but there was never such a scene between mir and bobby. No wait that doesnt make sense, I think as you stated before they should have had more Mir scenes but he barely came in the track they were too busy with Bobby's OTT acting. that's my assumption that Usman killed bobby (mir's real daughter) and mir decided to take revenge so he kidnapped barkat and bought her up making her believe she is bobby not barkat. and made her a dancer n do all these other illegal activities. i am only saying this as TB articles suggested tht dimple is actually the real barkat and not bobby but whether or not that is true is something which time will tell.

yeh i really wish they had shown more scenes with Mir... Mir-Usman's past is something i really was hoping they'd explore in this track but they didn't - there's too much focus on killing usman now... which again raises questions on why Mir would happily agree to kill a relative just becos he'd once sent him to jail...-- its a bit too dramatic and a really petty reason 2 have to kill someone, esp when tht someone is ur relative (ur sister-in-law's bro) that's why i feel there is ALOT more than whats been shown... well i'd like to HOPE there is more... a big disappointment from my end if CVs fail to explore mir-usman's characters in the remaining episodes of this track😕

Maybe even suraiya is unaware of the real history behind all this. i don't think that woman has any idea what goes on in her own house - she hardly knows her own children's problems either i.e. she didn't even know how chakkiwala had trapped Fahad into the mess until chakkiwala revealed it to her... and she hasn't even realised that zain is actually in love with aaliya. so i for one won't be surprised if she is totally unaware abt usman's shady past.