Real Barkat's grave - Confusion/ Usman's dark/shady past - Page 2

Good post!Well I think that Osman knows that Barkat is dead and he didn't tell Suriya about it becz she will nt be able to bare the shock..Maybe he found Barkat dead when she was a kid. and he buried her and kept this as a secret.. 😕

You have got some really good points there Yuvika. Never thought about it in this way. The points are actually very though provoking. Let's see what Beintehaa has got in store for us. If the CVs are gonna show it the way you told, then it's gonna be very interesting.

A really thought provoking post

They have prolonged barkaat's track. The TB article also said that she might be the real barkat. Maybe CV's are changing it or something? you never know. This show is unpredictable. Thats what i like about it.

thanks for ur comments guys... and yes usman is the one character that's left me confused... I mean his reaction to all the incidents which r taking place is very reserved n odd... which makes me wonder there is some mystery to him which is yet 2 be revealed... I really hope they do start to show his shady past becos usman since day 1 has been a very interesting character... and Naved being a talented actor really should be given the chance to explore usman Abdullah on another level.

great post, i was thinking the same, like how come the one buried her knew her name...i even thought may be mir khan did kill barkat but hid it from bobby, he could have lied to her to

Originally posted by: divikash

great post, i was thinking the same, like how come the one buried her knew her name...i even thought may be mir khan did kill barkat but hid it from bobby, he could have lied to her to

but after reading your topic it kinda explain's everything, may it is mir khan's daughter, and bobby could be real barkat

i think they should have hired you as the private detective, as you found out this much in one day time😆

but yes, a very good topic

Originally posted by: togepe30

If you notice carefully the nuances of Usman's acting yesterday when he was reacting to Barkat's 'Main Marr Jana Chahti Hoon'..

He didnt even look at her or look shocked...he was in a pensive mood...He knows she gave him that juice...I think he is aware that Barkat is dead..

The way he defended Aaliya was also very casually...Usman is not such a person...he has a strong personality...he does not talk so casually...

He didnt even look at Barkat during her natak...that made me realize he knows its not Barkat...but then why will he give 51% property to her if he knows its not her

I think they decided to bring in a new track from between...

Originally posted by: _Littles12_

Exactly My question, Maybe it is true that later on he found her but yet he is unaware that Bobby might actually be Barkat, or Maybe he does know but perhaps he is just doing this to make Usman Loathe, exactly what you said. Why can we not say it was actually Mir who made the FAKE to once again fool Zaya, Do you remember when Zaya entered the nikkah place, Mir was fully aware of their presence and their actions. yeh he returned and came before usman at the hospital becos he wanted to be found to take his revenge to another level. so although every1 gives credit to ZaYa I don't think they had much to do in finding Mir and Barkat becos all clues were given to them on the plate by Mir himself becos he wanted to be found. i dont think they would have found Mir had he not wanted them to find him. Everything happened as per his plan..I dunno what others think but I am so disappointed with the CVs for just giving Mir the disappearing act. he's meant to be an impt character in this storyline but somewhere he's been lost... we hardly see him... he needs to be back... and more focus should be placed on usman-mir's equation than anything else.

Wait, but then what about Ghulam, Aliyah's father? I Dont know I am getting not good ideas from, but I really dont wish for him to be involved in this.

Or maybe Ghulam found Barkat, but when he found her she was dead, and she was the one who buried him. But if that's the case why would Ghulam play along with Bobby being barkat if he knew barkat was dead. it doesn't make sense for Ghulam to be involved but I feel the pic thts been taken of ghulam n mir hugging will come into the pic soon...or I hope it does. they shouldn't leave it like a forgotten thing. 😕

Can you say that Ghulam kept her captive till she was alive? or even Mir, or perhaps even Usman, so she would be safe from Mir and never even told Suraiya about it. But why would Usman keep his own daughter away from him and hide this from his wife suraiya when he clearly knew that barkat missing and being kidnapped by a Bhopali man is the core reason for her dislike towards his sister and his hometown, surely he'd be the first 1 to bring barkat home to suraiya and go out of his way 2 protect barkat to ensure tht Mir doesn't reach her again.

I feel like we were so caught up with the Zaya confession that no one wanted anything but Zaya, so everyone forgot about that clearly. Thank you for reminding us, bu nonetheless, what really could be his dark past?

Maybe I am over-analyzing this but do you think Maybe Mir liked Suraiya however Usman and Suraiya were in love, that could be a reason

see what i dont understand one or another event kind a also brings Ayat in this, there are so many misconceptions, and theories but yet we dont know which one is true. the ayat theory I find hard to believe...becos its not like barkat/aayat were born in the same hospital and barkat was kidnapped just after being born...she was 2... surely shabana/ghulam knew what she looked like so if she had reached them in someway or the other, they wouldn't have kept her to themselves and name her ayat?? plus aaliya confirmed once to suraiya tht she didn't even know she had a chacha becos Ghulam never talked abt Mir and broke all ties with Mir as soon as he found out that Mir had kidnapped barkat...so Mir is unlikely to hand over barkat to ghulam when there hasn't been any contact between the 2 bros since the kidnapping.

Can Usman's past be some love with Mir khans wife than? I dunno I feel its more connected with bobby/barkat than the wives... I feel usman maybe by accident killed bobby...which made mir kidnap barkat n bring her up as bobby and made her the person usman would loathe as part of his revenge. becos isn't it weird that a man would kidnap the kids of a relative just becos tht relative sent him to jail for illegal activities? I mean that's a bit too dramatic...surely there is something more behind the reasoning of this kidnapping than what has been revealed by suraiya.

See what you did to me? driving me nuts? 😆couldn't help but share my views...sorry. 😆

my comments in red