Re: Anandi has two set of rules

1013962 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
When Anandi stops nimbuli from going to jhalra. I would like nimbuli to ask her why are you stopping me when you are sitting in your own bal sasural. You were treated so badly by this dokri and her ladeswar but now they are goddess n God for you and you comfortably stays with them saying this is your maika. You have lost me and I was raised in jhalra. Kundan Ji is bad to me disa is no one to me but like you I will reform Kundan Ji n make disa my dadisa n jhalra my maika so chill maa I am following your footsteps like you I will only come to see you on your death bed.
When dadisa n Jagya talks about legal rights to mangla mangla should ask on what legal rights you request Anandi to stay in this house. On what social ties you are clinging to her. So i am following your footsteps all her life I willl cling to nimbuli like dadisa and Kundan can have number of wives but nimbuli will always be at his service and friends forever like Jaan.
Badi haveli people n Anandi are hypocrit n double standard people they should first apply rules to themselves n then preach others. Anandi is bh s servant all her life so let her not give artificial lectures.

Created

Last reply

Replies

62

Views

6.3k

Users

13

Likes

156

Frequent Posters

Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
😆
people will oppose this idea... they will say Anandi was officially married to jagya with the consent of both sets of parents, whereas her daughter was not.

But most likely, this is what is going to happen. Nimboli will choose jhalra as her home.

And anandi's famous dialogue will be 'iss sab ka gunehgar hai BAL VIVAH'
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Anandi's situation and Nandini's situation are totally different.

Anandi
Anandi was not kidnapped by Bhairon Singh and was married off to his son.
Bhairon Singh came to Anandi's parents with a marriage proposal and Anandi's parents accepted the proposal because they liked what they saw of Bhairon Singh.

Dsa was doing child marriage so were Anandi's parents and a lot of others were doing child marriage of their children.

Later because of the way Dsa was troubling her the little girl stole money and ran away to her parents.Her mother dragged her back and threw her at Dsa's feet and told her that this is her home and she has to live or die there.

Later for reasons like social security and emotional bonds she chose to stay on in BH.

Sumi and Bhairon treated her like daughter and they did Kanyadan because Anandi's father wanted them to do Kanyadan.

Shiv and his parents considered Singhs as Anandi's maika.

Anandi returning to BH had a seal of approval from Shiv's family.

-----------------------------------

Nandini was not married off by her parents. She was kidnapped and was married off. So the marriage itself is not legal and it was made null and void by Anandi.

Anandi did not give away her child to Mangala or Akheraj as daughter or daughter in law.

Anandi's daughter landing in Jhalra was a result of a criminal act

Mangala claims that the child is her daughter,

So in no way are the situations similar.

Anandi's relationship with Singhs happened with the consent and approval all the important people in Anandi's life be it her parents, later on Shiv as well as his family.

If Anandi wants her daughter back she is right and if her daughter questions she has got good answers on this.

Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
I agree. Anandi has double standards and practices hypocrisy.
hisusmita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
People say the serial is against bal vivah but they show A getting everything thru Bal Vivah, that means they are supporting Bal Vivah

I disagee, the serial showed Bal Vivah is wrong. Thru A and others they showed how it effected Anandi and and others and took away every thing from her.

But they also showed this system is prevailing mostly because those people are ignorant, illiterate.

Thru Singhs, Anandi's parents they showed they did this Bal Vivah because they were ignorant. But they are not evil . When they realised how it effected the kids they they done everything to compensate as much as they can.

It has been clearly showed the system is bad. But what Singhs are doing for Anandi is because they are actually good human beings.

So there is no relation between what Bal Vivah took away from her and what she got from Singhs

That evil system took away everything from her

But the people are good who did that because of their ignorance realized that and proved that they are actually good at heart.


Edited by hisusmita - 9 years ago
Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6
That means if parents marry their child, it is acceptable. But if the child is kidnapped and married then it is not??


The emotional bond formation with the child husband and his family will be accepted and approved only if the child was married off by parents, but if such a bond is formed in a kidnapped-child-marriage, then the emotional bond is invalid? 😕

Emotions are emotions, they dont care about how the marriage happened... why should nimboli be deprived of her love for her husband's family?

why are her feelings for her teesa or kamli less important than her mother's feelings for sugna or dadisa ?

Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Shinya

That means if parents marry their child, it is acceptable. But if the child is kidnapped and married then it is not??



The emotional bond formation with the child husband and his family will be accepted and approved only if the child was married off by parents, but if such a bond is formed in a kidnapped-child-marriage, then the emotional bond is invalid? 😕

Emotions are emotions, they dont care about how the marriage happened... why should nimboli be deprived of her love for her husband's family?

why are her feelings for her teesa or kamli less important than her mother's feelings for sugna or dadisa ?

Well said.
Consent does not necessarily evoke feelings and lack of consent doesn't stop one from developing feelings.


GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: hisusmita

People say the serial is against bal vivah but they show A getting everything thru Bal Vivah, that means they are supporting Bal Vivah

I disagee, the serial showed Bal Vivah is wrong. Thru A and others they showed how it effected Anandi and and others and took away every thing from her.

But they also showed this system is prevailing mostly because those people are ignorant, illiterate.

Thru Singhs, Anandi's parents they showed they did this Bal Vivah because they were ignorant. But they are not evil . When they realised how it effected the kids they they done everything to compensate as much as they can.

It has been clearly showed the system is bad. But what Singhs are doing for Anandi is because they are actually good human beings.


So there is no relation between what Bal Vivah took away from her and what she got from Singhs

That evil system took away everything from her

But the people are good who did that because of their ignorance realized that and proved that they are actually good at heart.


@Bold - agree. Anandi's parents loved her very much and they were doing it in the best interest of their only daughter. Even in their ignorance they were trying to do what parents do for their child.
When Bhago dragged little Anandi and threw her at Dsa's feet she was doing it in the interest of the child.
Singhs and Anandi's parents both were decent people who were following the norms of the society they were living and corrected their mistakes and changed their views after they have seen ill effects of child marriage through Anandi and Suguna.

The system's fault was rectified by the people who were decent at heart.

------------------
Sad but Anandi had to lose a lot in life before Dsa and Anandi's mother realised how wrong they had been.
The more I see Choti Anandi series which shows Anandi's life before she became a Balika Vadhu the more convinced I get about how child marriage has taken away the most precious phase of her life her childhood.
Could they give her back the childhood that child marriage has taken away from her?
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9
They failed to show that bal vivah is wrong through Anandi's story. She gained so much from that relationship that she is sticking with only her balak var and his family. Every other relationships are forgotten. What she lost in bal vivah was just some unfortunate events that women face even if they marry after attaining legal age of marriage (education is not complete till 18 and mostly girls stop education even if they marry at 18, household work, cheating and abandoned bride none is a bad effect of bal vivah).
By what they show - Anandi clearly has two sets of rules, but the most irritating relates to lies - as if only she has the license to hide and lie and then go on preaching others that lies are bad.😛
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#10
Anandi's Balak Var even in his worst form was nothing like Kundan.The first and foremost thing.
Jagya and Anandi were really good friends who stood up for each other until Jagy decided to rebel against traditions and wanted to exercise his free will in the most damaging way. Sumi and Bhairon never treated Anandi like a DILbut a daughter.

Dsa was an authoritarian figure and the harshest of the lost but even she was never cruel like Akheraj and Harki.Even when she decided to gift a sauten to Anandi she said Anandi will always be part of the family if not as a DIL then as a daughter. She may have caused a lot trouble to that little girl but she never treated Anandi like she is trash or unwanted garbage.

The most important thing Sumi and Bhairon though considered Anandi as their daughter they never tried to take the place of Khazan and Bhago in Anandi's heart.

Anandi could maintain all her relationships because of the people who were involved.
Shiv's family saw Anandi's ex sasural as her maika and not ex sasural.

Anandi has no problems with Mangala Kamili being part of the child's life. If she doesn't want her child to go to Jhalra it is because of the safety issues and danger lurking in the form of Kundan.

It is Mangala who is trying to chop off all the other relationships of her chhori.

Anandi's respects her daughter's attachment towards Jhalra women while Mangala feels insecure with the girl's growing fondness for Anandi and her family.





Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".