Re: Anandi has two set of rules - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

62

Views

6.3k

Users

13

Likes

156

Frequent Posters

jayshree1942 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#11
Balikavadhu theme is kucchi Umar ke pakke rishte so story will go this way only.
Nimboli will be Anandi of jhalara family. She will reform kundan, akheraj and harki.

till date balikavadhu has proved at every stage that once your knot is tied u cant get out of it.

now i m not excited for anandi and nimboli reunion.

Because i know nothing great will happen even after reunion. Nimboli has to bear all relations anandi ex sasural and her child sasural .

Nimboli past will haunt her till her last breath .
GoodDoc_2105 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#12
Keep reading this line that what Anandi went through as Beendini of BH is same as the otheR child bridesORgirls face them even when they are married in their adulthood.
Does that make child marriage an accepted custom?

If child marriage was the norm and it is felt that girls lives are not damaged then why there is so much of work done against child marriage by the social reformers?

Just because Singhs were nice people does that mean that child marriage has not taken away anything from her?

Why do we all send our girls to school and why are we not getting them married off in childhood and put them in the hands of their in laws?

When a girl who wanted nothing but go to school and spend free time playing with her friends which is a natural desire for an eight year old girl is forced to forego all these things in the name of tradition how can it be right?
Isn't education and schooling her birthright?

It is one thing if the parents cannot afford to send the child to school therefore the child couldn't go to school and it is another thing when the child is married off at an age when she should be going to school and playing with dolls.

It is one thing to stay at home and look after younger siblings while mother went for work and another thing when the child is packed off to another place a housefull strangers and asked to make a home for herself amongst these strangers.




Stalwart. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: jayshree1942

Balikavadhu theme is kucchi Umar ke pakke rishte so story will go this way only.

Nimboli will be Anandi of jhalara family. She will reform kundan, akheraj and harki.

till date balikavadhu has proved at every stage that once your knot is tied u cant get out of it.

now i m not excited for anandi and nimboli reunion.

Because i know nothing great will happen even after reunion. Nimboli has to bear all relations anandi ex sasural and her child sasural .

Nimboli past will haunt her till her last breath .


Nimboli will open a school, top 10th exams like Anandi and then become Sarpanch of Jhalra. It will be declared as a district by CM and the collector/ some official who will be posted there will fall in love and marry her. Perhaps Anandi will die like Bhago convincing Nimboli to marry him or she might die saving her from some danger. Later Nimboli will find a good Beendini for her ex-husband. 😛
Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#14
Just as child marriage is not an acceptable custom, a woman going back to her ex-inlaws and living under the same roof as her ex with his current wife is not acceptable either.

When the makers themselves have put Anandi's relationships with her bal sasra over and above everything and projected them as the backbone support of Anandi's life, then why is it wrong to conclude that 'afterall Bal Vivah is not so wrong'

If Anandi really felt that bal vivah was a culprit then why is she still living in its shadows?

Either bal vivah is Bad or it is not.

It can't be bad when we are counting Anandi's tears and become a bliss when Anandi receives support.
SPuja thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#15
Creatives failed to show how and why bal vivah is wrong. Their point is balak var and his family will be like monsters - the girl will be made to do household works and has to leave study and then balak var will abandon her? Why always balak var and his family wrong? Is this the only thing why bal vivah is wrong? How can all families with a male child be wrong? And what if the family has both male and female children? The serial preaches something and shows something else.
Shinya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#16
Bhago and Khajan did not marry annadi thinking "it was best in her interests" but because it was the custom.

When bhairo realized that child-marriage was wrong, he and anandi tried to stop all child marriages happening in the village including Phooli's... But he did not nullify his son's and anandi's marriage.

Urmi's parents also did child marriage of their daughter as per the custom. Their daughter was not a burden to them as they were financially well off.

However, when anandi came to know about urmi's marriage, she nullified her marriage without giving any consideration to her feelings for her family.

She also got Urmi's father arrested but let her own father and father-in-law scot free... this is of course hypocrisy.


Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: SPuja

Creatives failed to show how and why bal vivah is wrong. Their point is balak var and his family will be like monsters - the girl will be made to do household works and has to leave study and then balak var will abandon her? Why always balak var and his family wrong? Is this the only thing why bal vivah is wrong? How can all families with a male child be wrong? And what if the family has both male and female children? The serial preaches something and shows something else.

Actually, makers succeeded in showing various ill effects of bal vivah on Balika Vadhus (since the title is highlighting vadhus and not balak var /vivah).

Through their lead Anandi - it was about how it snatches one's freedom to pursue their dreams
Phooli - the burden of bearing with widowhood
Sugna - Child out of wedlock
Champa - pregnancy and death
Gudiya - disturbed childhood.

Makers indeed succeeded in highlighting what little girls go through when burdened with child marriage.

But they undid their own doing when they decided to make Singhs as the backbone support in Anandi's life.

Anandi's return to BH was a huge backward step taken by the makers. It indicates that only if DSa was this nice in the past and if J never cheated her, bal vivah would have been perfect for Anandi.



Edited by Missesha - 9 years ago
1013962 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: Stalwart.


Nimboli will open a school, top 10th exams like Anandi and then become Sarpanch of Jhalra. It will be declared as a district by CM and the collector/ some official who will be posted there will fall in love and marry her. Perhaps Anandi will die like Bhago convincing Nimboli to marry him or she might die saving her from some danger. Later Nimboli will find a good Beendini for her ex-husband. 😛

In between there will be 5 years leap. By that time Kundan will be a good boy. Mangala will arrange for Nimbuli and Kundan s gahana. Then 26 year old kundan will love another girl and give laththi to Numbuli. Then collector can come.
hisusmita thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Missesha

Actually, makers succeeded in showing various ill effects of bal vivah on Balika Vadhus (since the title is highlighting vadhus and not balak var /vivah).


Through their lead Anandi - it was about how it snatches one's freedom to pursue their dreams
Phooli - the burden of bearing with widowhood
Sugna - Child out of wedlock
Champa - pregnancy and death
Gudiya - disturbed childhood.

Makers indeed succeeded in highlighting what little girls go through when burdened with child marriage.

But they undid their own doing when they decided to make Singhs as the backbone support in Anandi's life.

Anandi's return to BH was a huge backward step taken by the makers. It indicates that only if DSa was this nice in the past and if J never cheated her, bal vivah would have been perfect for Anandi.





@bold, I agree with you

but @red , how does it mean that her returning to BH shows Bal Vivah is a blessing?
This was shown that Singhs are too good. What they did is they believed in that custom but when they realized they did everything for her.

Anandi fought against the custom but when the people already realised their wrong doings why to cut all the ties with them.?

What DS did with A mostly because she strictly followed the custom, not because she hated Anandi. Beendhnis should not study , they should always follow their beendh, She was harsh with Suguna too.

When DS turned to a new leaf why should she cut her ties with them.?

They not only did for Anandi only, along with her they tried to help the society too, then why should Anandi become indifferent to them.

Yes, I agree creatives should have shown her living in Jaitsar but not in BH , That would have been a good step, not because I believe A dont have any right there, but because that would have been a better story.
Edited by hisusmita - 9 years ago
Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#20
Nobody is asking Anandi to cut ties with Dsa or jagya. But how fair is it that a woman goes back to her ex-husband's home and lives where he and his current wife are settled.

For me Jagya's ex and Dsa's grand-daughter are not two different people. She is only person at all times i.e. Jagya's ex. Her primary relationship with Singhs is that she is BH's Ex DIL.

Moreover, If Singhs and Dsa / J are too nice a people and have turned into new leaves, why didn't Anandi remarry jagya when he turned into a new leaf and was seeking forgiveness etc? Even Shiv was ready to back out.

At that time, her decision to chose Shiv over J (the man who betrayed her) was applauded. But now staying and living off the same betrayer is acceptable?

If I see good points in the show I will appreciate the makers and if I see them showing illogical or unacceptable stuff, I will question them too.

In my perception, no woman with self-respect and integrity will go and live with her ex and raise her kids there.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".