Anandi's pain is not because of child marriage

di_vya thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
Balika Vadhu is my favourite show. In fact, it is the only serial that I religiously follow. It is a show that is doing great on both fronts - sticking to the BV line that it started with and still kept the storyine intact and impactful even today.
However, what our favourtie Anandi went through, was it only because of child marriage?
She entered a family led by Dadisa who has patriarchal mentality and deals with resistance in an autocratic manner. This led to the beginning of Anandi's hardships. She was made to conform to the belief that her role in the family will always be second to Jagya, that her sole purpose of being is to keep Jagya happy.
She cannot be better in studies than Jagya; will have to give up her educational pursuits. Her main task is to be able to cook good food; otherwise who would feed Jagya after Dadisa and Sumitra? She has to be a perfectionist in terms of household work; outside world is Jagya's domain. She can play and entertain herself, but only after all the household work is done.
But all of this is what many (not all - I know times are changing) of the married women in India hear, even those who did not undergo child marriage. Her role is still considered secondary to men.
Women are asked whether they are career-oriented or family oriented, as if both cannot co-exist. But a man is never asked this question.
If a man gets late in office, he is praised as somebody who is very hardworking. But if a woman gets late, she is immediately branded as somebody who does not care enough for her family!
A woman might be very bright and smart and as highly qualified as her husband, but she is still expected to be perfect - not just good - at cooking and home care.
In any discussion about her work, the praise is on the lines of how she is able to handle both work and family. Ever heard such a praise for a man?
A woman is expected to be careful of how she talks to her husband. She is told how she should never hurt his ego and should put forth her point tactfully. But a man is never given such instructuons - as if women do not and should not have self respect / ego.
I think the key reason for Anandi's hardships is this patriarchal mentality. This mentality is what made Anandi lose herself. From a bubbly, cheerful, confident and fun-loving person, she turned into a traumatised, demure self who accepted being second to her husband. Remember how she was justifying to Shiv Dadisa's stand of why women should eat after men have? This was the same Anandi who was so against eating the leftovers of her husband. And this change in character had happended much BEFORE Jagya abandoned her. She came to accept that she is less worthy; she started finding faults in herself and working towards being Jagya-worthy.
Jagya leaving her was not because of child marriage. It was again a manifestation of the patriarchal mentality. He never thought of Anandi as a person worthy of respect. For him she was just a sidekick who he abandoned the moment he got a chance - never gave a second thougth.
It was purely a case of adultery and cheating. Child marriage was used by him just as an excuse, the same way he used Anandi's 'orthodox' unmodern self as an explanation of why she was unworthy of him. He knew very well that Anandi could become "Gauri" if she was let to. That's why he opposed her studies and ensured she couldn't. Jagya left her because he wanted to, not because he married her in childhood.

Created

Last reply

Replies

56

Views

6.3k

Users

16

Likes

125

Frequent Posters

Missesha thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
I think J rejecting her on the grounds of being incompetent is more painful than her going through the experiences of Child bride.
However,everything in J-A relationship cannot be blamed on Child Marriage. It is because of Child Marriage, A could not be who she wanted to be.

Child marriage still remains the root-cause. If she was not married and made to compromise her dreams then, she would have been a different A today.
di_vya thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Missesha

I think J rejecting her on the grounds of being incompetent is more painful than her going through the experiences of Child bride.

However,everything in J-A relationship cannot be blamed on Child Marriage. It is because of Child Marriage, A could not be who she wanted to be.

Child marriage still remains the root-cause. If she was not married and made to compromise her dreams then, she would have been a different A today.

Yes, Misseha. I'm not contesting the evilness of child marriage.
What I'm trying to say is that marriage at a normal age also does not guarantee that you'll turn into a confident, competent person who is able to fulfill their dreams. You need around you a positive environment that is not biased against you just because of your gender.
Child marriage was the circumstance. The root cause was the gender bias. Anandi being incompetent was the consequence of this mentality only, don't you think?
earth1978 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
i agree to ur post by and large and it is a very good post.
teh thing is society, men and most importantly THE FEMALE RELATIVES OF MEN, ie mother and sister are just chauvinistic and dominat with an inherent sense of superiority. take educated , uneducated , wrking non working blah blah. hum saas hum nand and they wud treat the dil as dirt.
just becuase they happen to be related to a y chromosome!
they think it is their right, TV serials are all based on these stereotypes. ever seen a kind saas , a docile nand who is friends with bhabhi? nowhere!
the thing is all these things crush a woman, and they are delibrately crushed by these females to make the DIL mroe submissive, more complaint. hey want her to work in their house give them children but do nto want her to have rights.
it is all a well thought out strategy. but give this a backdrop of the bahu being a child and they have a field day! they can do and crush as as they please. becuase a child is mroe innocent, young, easily scared ... can be manipulated to do anything they please. a child's sens eof self esteem is just developing ... nto established yet. it is easier to crush it right then and thre. hence child marriages had comei nto vogue to give proverbial slaves and submissive sex workers with a clean womb to men and their parents!
so yes anandi was a victim of chidl marriage becuase her self esteem was crushed even before i had chance to develop properly. maybe her sufferings cud have reduced ... same jagiya wants to treat gauri like anandi. btu cant. becuase gauri 's self confidence is soaring!
in my own life, i was the msot educated bahu in entire khaandaan. but i wasnt allowed to work. then made to feel low about it! the only and sole appreciation i ever got was for my cooking which my saasu maa mistakenly believes she taught! so infact that too goes to herself only.
i have many other talents which get no recognition.
but i was able to combat all this becuase i was not a child. i was a mature woman with unshakable self confidence and even then i have had days of depression and loss of self worth. cant imagine a scared, outnumbered child going thru this process of systematic demolition.
Edited by earth1978 - 13 years ago
kabakaba4 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
Hi earth1978. You have reminded me of Gehna. I have compared her with Anandi.

Anandi married as a child - submissive, polite!

Gehna was adult when she married Basant - she had a sharp tongue and always had an answer for Dadissa.

Anandi was crushed as a child by (then) strict Dadi, but Gehna was much stronger, cos she was older.
di_vya thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: kabakaba4

Hi earth1978. You have reminded me of Gehna. I have compared her with Anandi.


Anandi married as a child - submissive, polite!

Gehna was adult when she married Basant - she had a sharp tongue and always had an answer for Dadissa.

Anandi was crushed as a child by (then) strict Dadi, but Gehna was much stronger, cos she was older.

But was Gehna really able to counter Dadisa? Remember the episode in which after much friction, Gehna apologised to Dadisa and her tears fell on Dadisa's feet? Dadisa forgave her but how? I still can't forget the scene how Dadisa flicked off the tears with her feet. 😡
Sorry, but I think even Gehna turned submissive.
di_vya thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: earth1978

i agree to ur post by and large and it is a very good post.

teh thing is society, men and most importantly THE FEMALE RELATIVES OF MEN, ie mother and sister are just chauvinistic and dominat with an inherent sense of superiority. take educated , uneducated , wrking non working blah blah. hum saas hum nand and they wud treat the dil as dirt.
just becuase they happen to be related to a y chromosome!
they think it is their right, TV serials are all based on these stereotypes. ever seen a kind saas , a docile nand who is friends with bhabhi? nowhere!
the thing is all these things crush a woman, and they are delibrately crushed by these females to make the DIL mroe submissive, more complaint. hey want her to work in their house give them children but do nto want her to have rights.
it is all a well thought out strategy. but give this a backdrop of the bahu being a child and they have a field day! they can do and crush as as they please. becuase a child is mroe innocent, young, easily scared ... can be manipulated to do anything they please. a child's sens eof self esteem is just developing ... nto established yet. it is easier to crush it right then and thre. hence child marriages had comei nto vogue to give proverbial slaves and submissive sex workers with a clean womb to men and their parents!
so yes anandi was a victim of chidl marriage becuase her self esteem was crushed even before i had chance to develop properly. maybe her sufferings cud have reduced ... same jagiya wants to treat gauri like anandi. btu cant. becuase gauri 's self confidence is soaring!
in my own life, i was the msot educated bahu in entire khaandaan. but i wasnt allowed to work. then made to feel low about it! the only and sole appreciation i ever got was for my cooking which my saasu maa mistakenly believes she taught! so infact that too goes to herself only.
i have many other talents which get no recognition.
but i was able to combat all this becuase i was not a child. i was a mature woman with unshakable self confidence and even then i have had days of depression and loss of self worth. cant imagine a scared, outnumbered child going thru this process of systematic demolition.

I agree, when it is so dififcult for a grown up woman, the plight of a child bride is unthinkable! At times I feel our institution of marriage where a girl is supposed to leave her family itself is flawed.
A girl is forced to let go of her support system and suddenly finds herself among strangers. ANd she has to prove herself worthy of their love! The guy has to do no such thing!
kabakaba4 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: di_vya

But was Gehna really able to counter Dadisa? Remember the episode in which after much friction, Gehna apologised to Dadisa and her tears fell on Dadisa's feet? Dadisa forgave her but how? I still can't forget the scene how Dadisa flicked off the tears with her feet. 😡
Sorry, but I think even Gehna turned submissive.


Oh, yes, I do remember that scene very well, and that WAS awful. 😡
And, yes, Gehna HAS turned submissive! I just ment that she was stronger to start with, because she was older.

earth1978 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: di_vya

I agree, when it is so dififcult for a grown up woman, the plight of a child bride is unthinkable! At times I feel our institution of marriage where a girl is supposed to leave her family itself is flawed.
A girl is forced to let go of her support system and suddenly finds herself among strangers. ANd she has to prove herself worthy of their love! The guy has to do no such thing!

why do u think it is flawed only at times. the system is flawed since the day of its inception. it was , is and always will be flawed. it makes no sense when a woman is made to leave her entire family the guy holds on to his more than his dear life for ever. why?
not only that he makes the woman do things for his family when he never does any for hers. infact the woman ends up doing more for his family than he himself ever does.
cook, feed , serve then ... all this for no appreciation and often criticism.
the key word is outnumbered ... why are women/bahu more submissive, again becuase all her support systems are snatched the day of marriage. or the support systems themselves begin to look away. why are all men sher in their maand ? why are all saas so dominant and confident they can get away with anything? again the strength is in numbers. not in logic or reason or competence.
this system is unfair and is quite painful for even an adult woman to deal with. imagine a poor child who needs nurture and protection thrown among strangers with a system which sucks. cant even imagine their pain.
ghoshmedha thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
y r u nly blaming saas nd nanand of d gul...d parnts f d gul r @ fault demslves...it dsnt mttr hw mch d gul is educated,indepndent etc2...c is always belvd by hr own parents 2 lrn houshold chores,cookng etc...as if dats hr primary job nd dts hr nly quality in d marriage mrket!!!
also dey'll behav as if sm v.v.i.p. hs 2 b treatd if dr damad cms ova 2 dr hous,bt a bahu is nt evn treatd nrmlly...frgt bout xtra cre!!!
Edited by ghoshmedha - 13 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".